Gladiator Ratings Rd1

Remove this Banner Ad

ozzyoslo

ozzyoslo

BUY BITCOIN !!!
Veteran 10k Posts
Mar 15, 2008
13,123
7,878
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Simple concept really :

A THUMBS UP :thumbsu: TO PLAYERS WHO YOU THOUGHT PLAYED ALRIGHT,
A THUMBS DOWN :thumbsdown: FOR THOSE YOU THINK PLAYED BAD
AND A :division: DIVISION SYMBOL FOR THOSE WHO YOU ARE DIVIDED ON = NOT SURE .

Happy to start off proceedings for Rd 1.
  • 2 Marley Williams :thumbsu:
  • 4 Shaun Higgins :division:
  • 6 Lachlan Hansen :division:
  • 7 Jack Ziebell :thumbsu:
  • 8 Nathan Hrovat :division:
  • 9 Andrew Swallow :thumbsu:
  • 11 Luke McDonald :division:
  • 12 Lindsay Thomas :thumbsdown:
  • 14 Trent Dumont :division:
  • 16 Scott D. Thompson :thumbsdown:
  • 18 Shaun Atley :thumbsdown:
  • 21 Jy Simpkin :division:
  • 22 Todd Goldstein :thumbsu:
  • 25 Robbie Tarrant :division:
  • 28 Kayne Turner :thumbsu:
  • 30 Jarrad Waite :thumbsu:
  • 31 Braydon Preuss :division:
  • 34 Jamie Macmillan :thumbsdown:
  • 39 Mitchell Hibberd :division:
  • 42 Declan Mountford :division:
  • 43 Sam Gibson :thumbsdown:
  • 50 Ben Brown :thumbsu:
Just going through people thoughts on certain players made me to start this thread.....some people think player x did ok whilst canning player y......
 
Harris 10 said:
The thumb for Ziebell is the wrong colour and the wrong way around.
Click to expand...
Play the game properly or not at all , I appreciate you playing though ;)

template below
  • 2 Marley Williams :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 4 Shaun Higgins :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 6 Lachlan Hansen :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 7 Jack Ziebell :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 8 Nathan Hrovat :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 9 Andrew Swallow :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 11 Luke McDonald :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 12 Lindsay Thomas :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 14 Trent Dumont :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 16 Scott D. Thompson :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 18 Shaun Atley :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 21 Jy Simpkin :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 22 Todd Goldstein :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 25 Robbie Tarrant :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 28 Kayne Turner :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 30 Jarrad Waite :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 31 Braydon Preuss :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 34 Jamie Macmillan :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 39 Mitchell Hibberd :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 42 Declan Mountford :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 43 Sam Gibson :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 50 Ben Brown :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

  • 2 Marley Williams :thumbsu:
  • 4 Shaun Higgins :thumbsu:
  • 6 Lachlan Hansen :thumbsdown: x100
  • 7 Jack Ziebell :thumbsu:
  • 8 Nathan Hrovat :division:
  • 9 Andrew Swallow :division:
  • 11 Luke McDonald :thumbsdown: x5
  • 12 Lindsay Thomas :thumbsdown:
  • 14 Trent Dumont :division:
  • 16 Scott D. Thompson :thumbsdown: x1000
  • 18 Shaun Atley :thumbsdown:
  • 21 Jy Simpkin :division:
  • 22 Todd Goldstein :division:
  • 25 Robbie Tarrant :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 28 Kayne Turner :thumbsdown:x 5
  • 30 Jarrad Waite :thumbsu:
  • 31 Braydon Preuss :thumbsdown:
  • 39 Mitchell Hibberd :thumbsdown:
  • 42 Declan Mountford :division:
  • 43 Sam Gibson :thumbsdown: x5
  • 50 Ben Brown :thumbsu:
 
naturally north said:
  • 2 Marley Williams :thumbsu:
  • 4 Shaun Higgins :thumbsu:
  • 6 Lachlan Hansen :thumbsdown: x100
  • 7 Jack Ziebell :thumbsu:
  • 8 Nathan Hrovat :division:
  • 9 Andrew Swallow :division:
  • 11 Luke McDonald :thumbsdown: x5
  • 12 Lindsay Thomas :thumbsdown:
  • 14 Trent Dumont :division:
  • 16 Scott D. Thompson :thumbsdown: x1000
  • 18 Shaun Atley :thumbsdown:
  • 21 Jy Simpkin :division:
  • 22 Todd Goldstein :division:
  • 25 Robbie Tarrant :thumbsu::thumbsdown::division:
  • 28 Kayne Turner :thumbsdown:x 5
  • 30 Jarrad Waite :thumbsu:
  • 31 Braydon Preuss :thumbsdown:
  • 39 Mitchell Hibberd :thumbsdown:
  • 42 Declan Mountford :division:
  • 43 Sam Gibson :thumbsdown: x5
  • 50 Ben Brown :thumbsu:
Click to expand...
Lol. I'm in tears from x100s! But you beat me to it you bastard!
 
Will put some notes after a couple I guess. I quite like the idea tbh.
  • 2 Marley Williams :thumbsu:
  • 4 Shaun Higgins :thumbsu:
  • 6 Lachlan Hansen :thumbsdown:
  • 7 Jack Ziebell :thumbsu:
  • 8 Nathan Hrovat :division: too anonymous for my liking and didn't see much defensive work, but is new
  • 9 Andrew Swallow :thumbsu:
  • 11 Luke McDonald :division: Some good, some bad.
  • 12 Lindsay Thomas :division: Close to being a thumbs up, but set shots...
  • 14 Trent Dumont :thumbsu:
  • 16 Scott D. Thompson :thumbsdown:
  • 18 Shaun Atley :thumbsdown: Possibly harsh, but wanted more from him.
  • 21 Jy Simpkin :division: Good signs, but so little output.
  • 22 Todd Goldstein :thumbsu: One of the more 'meh' thumbsup I'll give, considering his opponents.
  • 25 Robbie Tarrant :division: Some good, some bad, s**t team mates.
  • 28 Kayne Turner :thumbsu: Went missing, but when on is on. Almost a *shrug*.
  • 30 Jarrad Waite :thumbsu:
  • 31 Braydon Preuss :division: His double chase on the wing saves him from a thumbs down. Needs fitness.
  • 34 Jamie Macmillan :thumbsdown: Expected better from him. Was almost servicable (and is as missing from your template as I thought he was at the game)
  • 39 Mitchell Hibberd :division:
  • 42 Declan Mountford :division:
  • 43 Sam Gibson :thumbsdown: Was he ever a gutbusting option for a kickout from defence? I miss that Gibson. Got a bit of it but was pus.
  • 50 Ben Brown :thumbsu:
 
The below is relative to expectations i.e. Hrovat wasn't our worst but I expected more.
  • 2 Marley Williams :division:
  • 4 Shaun Higgins :thumbsu:
  • 6 Lachlan Hansen :thumbsdown:
  • 7 Jack Ziebell :thumbsu:
  • 8 Nathan Hrovat :thumbsdown:
  • 9 Andrew Swallow :thumbsdown:
  • 11 Luke McDonald :thumbsdown:
  • 12 Lindsay Thomas :thumbsdown:
  • 14 Trent Dumont :thumbsu:
  • 16 Scott D. Thompson :thumbsdown:
  • 18 Shaun Atley :division:
  • 21 Jy Simpkin :thumbsdown:
  • 22 Todd Goldstein :thumbsu:
  • 25 Robbie Tarrant :thumbsdown:
  • 28 Kayne Turner :thumbsu:
  • 30 Jarrad Waite :division:
  • 31 Braydon Preuss :division:
  • 34 Jamie Macmillan :division:
  • 39 Mitchell Hibberd :division:
  • 42 Declan Mountford :division:
  • 43 Sam Gibson :thumbsdown:
  • 50 Ben Brown :thumbsu:
 
  • 2 Marley Williams :thumbsu:
  • 4 Shaun Higgins :thumbsu:
  • 6 Lachlan Hansen :thumbsdown:
  • 7 Jack Ziebell :thumbsu:
  • 8 Nathan Hrovat:division:
  • 9 Andrew Swallow :thumbsdown:
  • 11 Luke McDonald :thumbsdown:
  • 12 Lindsay Thomas :thumbsdown:
  • 14 Trent Dumont :division:
  • 16 Scott D. Thompson :thumbsdown:
  • 18 Shaun Atley :thumbsdown:
  • 21 Jy Simpkin :division:
  • 22 Todd Goldstein :thumbsu:
  • 25 Robbie Tarrant :thumbsdown:
  • 28 Kayne Turner :division:
  • 30 Jarrad Waite :thumbsu:
  • 31 Braydon Preuss :division:
  • 34 Jamie Macmillan :division:
  • 39 Mitchell Hibberd :division:
  • 42 Declan Mountford :division:
  • 43 Sam Gibson :thumbsdown:
  • 50 Ben Brown :division:
 
  • 2 Marley Williams :division:
  • 4 Shaun Higgins :division:
  • 6 Lachlan Hansen :thumbsdown: 100% underdone. Looks gone.
  • 7 Jack Ziebell :division: Captain that seriously needs to do better with ball in hand. Swallow and JZ we're competing yesterday for the prize of turning it over the most.
  • 8 Nathan Hrovat :division:
  • 9 Andrew Swallow :thumbsdown: Busts his arse but then achieves very little from his efforts because of skill limitations.
  • 11 Luke McDonald :division: Seems to be confused in contests, don't know where he's at.
  • 12 Lindsay Thomas :thumbsdown: Frustrating. He looked solid in the JLT series.
  • 14 Trent Dumont :thumbsu:
  • 16 Scott D. Thompson :thumbsdown: I don't know where he's at atm. 2013 form may never return.
  • 18 Shaun Atley :thumbsdown: looked alright in the JLT series. Might need time to settle in his new role if he will be there permanently.
  • 21 Jy Simpkin :division:
  • 22 Todd Goldstein :thumbsu: Tries his heart out, for little in return from mids. Brilliant.
  • 25 Robbie Tarrant :thumbsdown: Probably underdone.
  • 28 Kayne Turner :thumbsu:
  • 30 Jarrad Waite :thumbsdown: 1.7?
  • 31 Braydon Preuss :division:
  • 34 Jamie Macmillan :division:
  • 39 Mitchell Hibberd :division:
  • 42 Declan Mountford :division:
  • 43 Sam Gibson :thumbsdown: unsurprisingly spent the most on the ground for almost zero impact. Gaff destroyed him.
  • 50 Ben Brown :thumbsu: provided options and kept the Eagles backline busy and nervous. Should team up with Daw when he gets up.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

D
2023 Season Pressure Rating
Replies
7
Views
490
Horizons_00
Horizons_00

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top