Review Good/Bad v Gold Coast, Round 5

[Scorpus]

only in your vader-esque mind.

if you have to invent fake positions you're opinion is invalid.

Nope, nearly every team has an intercepting defender. I guess you're just stuck in the past.

 

[Sanders]

Third tall defender typically, though today when Talia went off he played as the deeper of the two KPDs

(Someone had to answer)

I know what position he plays, and he's not a superstar if he stays there. which is why dumbass is trying to pretend he plays a made up position.

Hartigan was the deeper of the 2 playing on Lynch.

 

[marty36]

Best game of the year for Hampton the faith is paying off

 

[DD#23]

Watch the replay and see how many times he's in space waving for the ball but the ball carrier ignores him.

this seems to happen a lot, makes you wonder.

 

[Bicks]

 

[Paladin]

what position does he play?

Today he was a KPD.

Normally a third tall. Are you saying he cant be a star like Josh Gibson or Harry Taylor?

 

[Samcro24]

I know what position he plays, and he's not a superstar if he stays there. which is why dumbass is trying to pretend he plays a made up position.

Hartigan was the deeper of the 2 playing on Lynch.

Haven't you seen ID on a team sheet?

 

[NTRabbit]

I know what position he plays, and he's not a superstar if he stays there. which is why dumbass is trying to pretend he plays a made up position.

Hartigan was the deeper of the 2 playing on Lynch.

I know, but no one else was going to give the answer :V

I felt Lever was the deeper of the two playing on Wright, but I suppose they did move Lynch up and down a bit, and Hartigan always stuck with him.

 

[Sanders]

Nope, nearly every team has an intercepting defender. I guess you're just stuck in the past.

it's not even a smart deflection. it's a stupid bit of made up invention.

unless of course we have kicking defender, handballing defender, spoiling defender, rushed behind defender, out of bounds defender, fumbles defender, out marked defender, turn over, or any other number of act based roles

there is a difference between an act on a field and a position.

 

[Sanders]

Haven't you seen ID on a team sheet?

don't think anyone else has either.

 

[Elite Crow]

* looking at our reserves side, we wouldn't want any more injuries.

 

[Sanders]

Today he was a KPD.

playing on?

 

[NTRabbit]

I will say that the number of times Wright found himself going for a mark over the top of his man in Mackay, Laird, or Brown was pretty concerning, because they don't exactly have the tall quartet of GWS

 

[Scorpus]

it's not even a smart deflection. it's a stupid bit of made up invention.

unless of course we have kicking defender, handballing defender, spoiling defender, rushed behind defender, out of bounds defender, fumbles defender, out marked defender, turn over, or any other number of act based roles

there is a difference between an act on a field and a position.

His role is specifically to chop out other players and intercept attacks. He's rarely isolated one on one, he plays the spare man a lot. He's not a third tall.

I guess you don't watch our structures close enough and think we have rigid positions like "full back" and "center half back" these days.

If anything, Cheney and Kelly are "third talls"

 

[Sanders]

I know, but no one else was going to give the answer :V

but they can't say that, and still hold the conclusion. so the only way to make it work is to invent a new position.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Not good, he didn't look happy

Neither did Cameron, to be fair

 

[Paladin]

playing on?

2 metre Peter.

You dont think he can be a star in the Gibson/Taylor mould?

 

[Squiba]

2nd 1/4, Menz got near it a few times. Should have been squared up 20m out by Eddie but didnt get hit. Once unlucky to bit be paid an in the back free, another laid a tackle. Only around it deep in the fwd line. Needs to start finding his own ball and work up the ground like in round 1

*BTW I'm on Menz watch while the replay is on. Loving the games of the Crouch's, Laird, Smith, Sloane, Hampton and Hartigan solid defensively.

 

[Sanders]

His role is specifically to chop out other players and intercept attacks. He's rarely isolated one on one, he plays the spare man a lot. He's not a third tall.

I guess you don't watch our structures close enough and think we have rigid positions like "full back" and "center half back" these days.

this is embarrassing. dig up you clown

 

[Bicks]

I will say that the number of times Wright found himself going for a mark over the top of his man in Mackay, Laird, or Brown was pretty concerning, because they don't exactly have the tall quartet of GWS

 

[Pdub]

Bickley has no idea what he's talking about, and very rarely does - it's why he washed out of the coaching game and has some low rent media roles

Walsh offered Bickley an Assistant coaching role, Bickley turned it down as he no longer had a desire to be a senior coach after he saw what happened to Sanderson.

 

[Jarman3]

Watching the telecast on TV now. Why the **** are they making us sit through all the half time bull****? The game is over, just have your ad break then go straight to the third quarter - I don't have much interest in watching all the Bob Murphy stuff from the other game.

 

[Pdub]

Rory, Rory, Rory

 

[Sanders]

2 metre Peter.

You dont think he can be a star in the Gibson/Taylor mould?

he obviously resembles enright a lot more than taylor.

Gibson is like Rance, a player able to switch, zone off and provide run but first and foremost a key, close checking, athletic body on body defender. or at least was in his prime. Taylor was the same.

Lever is a ******* 3rd tall defender and he is not a superstar unless he can be a key defender. and cut down on the turnovers.

 

[Scorpus]

this is embarrassing. dig up you clown

I guess you also think Lynch plays as a "third tall" and McGovern as a "third tall". What about Cameron as a "small forward". I guess Smith isn't a "rebounding defender" but a "half back flank"?

Then again, your views being stuck in the past would explain a lot of things.