Review Good/Bad vs Collingwood, 2020

[Scorpus]

Gave Collingwood the game on a silver platter after half time.

Was absolutely winnable and we s**t the bed

Deflating

 

[GROTTO]

Eleni, please no more she is not surely an elite umpire to be at AFL level.

 

[Scorpus]

The positive is Rory Laird played like an All Australian quality player in the midfield.

Keep him and ship off the Crouches

 

[GROTTO]

Pies could have rested another 6 players, missed opportunity by Buckley.

 

[Mego Red]

Honestly, Matt to Geelong and Brad to St Kilda seems like a good result.

 

[Geoffa32]

When you can't convert set shots you better be dammed good to win games.

We are not that.

Smithers poor kicking doesn't help.


Good to see Hberg play well, he and Stengle have a good understanding.



Eleni, umpiring did not cost the game. But she is a bad umpire.



Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[GROTTO]

Our players dont have the skillset to hit targets inside 50. We are better off, bombing long and hoping for Fog to crash packs/McAdam to take a mark or let our smalls like Stengle collect the crumbs.

 

[Mego Red]

Probably 51% positive tonight. That's my takeaway. Unfortunately that doesn't win you a game.

 

[FR0GGY]

Good
Laird takes home the seniors pay packets.
Stengle improving each week
Berg with some confidence

bad
Seniors can give their match payments to Laird
McAsey needs to play forward
Fitness and strength

 

[Sack Chapman]

The Good:

McPherson – one of our few really promising kids.

Himmelberg – Starting to look like a key forward

Laird – wtf didn’t Pyke ever try Laird as a midfielder

Keays – Really feel sorry for this kid

Stengle and MacAdam - did some good things



The Bad:

-Riccuito’s involvement in Crows games. Supporters should start a petition.

-Skills – Shocking. Worst I have seen in a long time

-Smith – game changer. Trade.

-Walker – Hurry up and get to 200

-McHenry, McAsey – Rebuilding starting with half back flankers (Hamill and McPherson). Cunning plan Ogilvie. The rebuild hasn’t started yet.

-Fogarty – overrated

-LogicPlus sponsoring the Crows. Woops.

 

[dblstR]

We desperately need to be back in the SANFL to give some of these kids experience against bigger bodies at a lower level.

Impressed with Laird, McPherson, Stengle and Berg.

Fitness terrible.

We could've won that game but gave them absolute gifts.

Umpiures can get absolutely ****ed. That was always going to happen after the Melbourne game.

 

[1991firstgamer]

Better signs
Umpires love Collingwood don't they

Sent from my SM-J730G using Tapatalk

 

[latinoheat]

Good: mcadams mark and goal

bad :McAsey

ugly: umpiring

 

[bates121]

The positive is Rory Laird played like an All Australian quality player in the midfield.

Keep him and ship off the Crouches

He might have got a lot of it not sure he did a whole lot with it. Just another MCrouch effort get 35+ but no real damage.

 

[Tex200]

Initial thoughts

Loved Lairds game tonight - outstanding.

Smith and McAsey cost us 4 goals directly. Can forgive McAsey.

EH and Stengle were great.

M Crouch - did he do a single thing that advantages our side tonight.

 

[GreyCrow]

The Good

First half intent
Game plan looks to be play on
Laird
Sholl
Keays

The Bad

We need a tackling coach
Umpiring
We let the game get away
Smothers
Smithers

The Ugly

Lynden Dunn

 

[spexau]

Completely winnable game thrown away by some simple, dumb turnovers. Laird should've been playing midfield for years, he's an absolute natural in there.

 

[Troy87]

Outstanding
Laird as a mid

Good
Berger worth keeping
Effort

Bad
Deplorable skills and turnovers
Brodie Smith's critical turnovers
McAsey out of his depth

 

[WetCrow1991]

Ugly:
The Umpiring.

Imagine putting in a good effort, playing on, putting on pressure and then having that forced out of your game because the umpires start paying imaginary free kicks to the opposition and at the same time give you zero rope.

Disheartening to a winless side, like why ******* bother trying when the ******* game isn't even officiated remotely fairly?

Putting aside the skills and the fitness, honestly this was a ******* joke.

* Eleni and Razor Ray. Complete dickheads, and * the AFL.

 

[CrowBloke]

A new low.
They have found new, even worse ways to lose.
+9 to -17 in 3rd quarter was football self-destruction.

 

[Bernie L]

Decision making very poor.
Work rate without the ball terrible.
And I cant work out if the kicking was s**t, or players up the ground didnt give an option.
We really lack an A grade mid.

 

[Crows I Am]

That was the most disappointing loss of the year. We were all over them early and then lost our bundle again. Giving them 2 goals in 10 seconds before 3 quarter time killed any chance we had.

Umpires did all they could to make sure we couldn't get back into it. We didn't help ourselves either though, can't remember a game where our kicks were smothered so much, killed our momentum and quite often resulted in a goal for them.

 

[Scorpus]

Smith's kick under no pressure to a Collingwood forward in scoring range after we pissed around switching in defense cost us the game.

Sucked the life out of the match. That single error was absolutely unforgivable

 

[mcattack]

At least a glimpse of hope for the future. Few boat anchors tonight. Shame we cant run out game. Walker was a bit average. Stengle was good. Didnt mind bergs game. Dude will be a big loss next week.

 

[Damp Squarie]

Honestly, Matt to Geelong and Brad to St Kilda seems like a good result.

I doubt they’d want them.