Review Good/Bad vs Sydney

[spenze]

Sydney is going to challenge the 2 game ban given to Tom McCartin for his bump on Shane McAdam

There's a video in the link - graded careless, high impact, high contact

Thoughts?

MATCH REVIEW: Swan banned for first final, Cat's season over

The Match Review Officer's findings are in for Saturday's matches in round 23

www.afl.com.au

Chose to bump, that one is clear cut

 

[PeterSalt]

Chose to bump, that one is clear cut

Sydney fans beg to differ

Be interesting to see how chook lotto plays out at the tribunal

 

[spenze]

Sydney fans beg to differ

Be interesting to see how chook lotto plays out at the tribunal

Only natural that they would but I'd still think the same if it was another clubs player and not Macadam. Think 2 is probably about right for it

 

[PeterSalt]

Only natural that they would but I'd still think the same if it was another clubs player and not Macadam. Think 2 is probably about right for it

Yeah .. I just had a Barry Hall flash back when I read a comment on the MB

 

[Slippery Pete]

I should have had a deeper look.

 

[Checksider]

FFS .....get Rankine into the midfield .....he mesmerises opponents ....and has speed to burn

It's currently my main peave !

Would love to see it. Maybe on the cards next season with more fitness under his belt?

 

[Jeffcrowe]

That's fine ....we've been over this infinitum ....you can't expect kids to play like experienced players .....kids haven't the body's to weather a long season of pressure footy

We're carrying a lot of players currently .....I thought we were horrible last night ....to get so close, who gets the credit for that ?

There’ll be a hell of a lot of this worked on in pre season re game scenario an closing out games that we couldn’t afford to spend time on last season which was alot about working on ball movement ( which paid dividends )

But also we must get stronger mentally re finishing

So I’m sure alot of players will do some of the stuff that Fog and Thilthorpe are doing re mental training

 

[WaynesWorld19]

So I’m sure alot of players will do some of the stuff that Fog and Thilthorpe are doing re mental training

Do you know what that training entails ?

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Do you know what that training entails ?

Psych sessions

It’s mainly about belief and executing in the moment

As well as resilience and being able to work on the spot to turn things around in game if they aren’t going well which goes back to first point

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Psych sessions

It’s mainly about belief and executing in the moment

As well as resilience and being able to work on the spot to turn things around in game if they aren’t going well which goes back to first point

So, developing self belief, and a healthy ego

 

[MRB37]

Would love to see it. Maybe on the cards next season with more fitness under his belt?

Fitness is not an issue Rankine is struggling with. He's not in there because Nicks doesn't want him in there.

 

[BRL121]

When you see what Izak is capable of up forward it's surely a bit of dilemma as to where the team is best served with his innate sense around goal.

He's certainly a boundary-line magician, like Betts.

 

[jackster83]

He's certainly a boundary-line magician, like Betts.

I'd like to see footage of that one that was disallowed from the Betts pocket again. That looked more in than Jeremy Cameron last week or Jamie Elliott a few weeks back.

 

[PeterSalt]

I'd like to see footage of that one that was disallowed from the Betts pocket again. That looked more in than Jeremy Cameron last week or Jamie Elliott a few weeks back.

It would've been interesting if Collingwood lost that game to Geelong

Like wise if we won our home game against Collingwood after the Murphy fiasco

 

[NSolis]

No coaches votes published this week? Bit strange, usually they are available by Monday afternoon.

 

[Stephen2]

Coaches votes:

• Goal umpire = 5 votes
• ... the rest...

 

[MsTopG]

No coaches votes published this week? Bit strange, usually they are available by Monday afternoon.

The probably felt embarassed that the goal umpire got a vote for Sydney.

 

[WeeBlake]

That last goal by Rachele is not getting enough credit. Was amazing.

 

[Mr_Moogle]

When you see what Izak is capable of up forward it's surely a bit of dilemma as to where the team is best served with his innate sense around goal.

Sure but he could still play him in there is bursts just to make us less predictable.

 

[PeterSalt]

Sure but he could still play him in there is bursts just to make us less predictable.

You'd use him a bit like Stuart Broad wandering up to the batters end and playing with a bail

 

[Sanders]

Bad: Celebrating a goal before the umpire has booked it. This s**t is totally avoidable.

This aged well

 

[Sanders]

Libbas shot clearly missed and was 26 years ago

Hold on. Where did this reappraisal come from?

It didn’t clearly miss, the bulldogs players celebrating still maintain to this day it was a goal. Our players said they weren’t sure

The tv angles are inconclusive

There is nothing clear at all, then or 26 years later

Except maybe, we can start to understand a little about how they felt.

What if it was a mistake, and they were right? That would be pretty hard to swallow

Thankfully no one knows for sure

 

[Mostyn]

Fitness is not an issue Rankine is struggling with. He's not in there because Nicks doesn't want him in there.

Hmmm, I'm not sure whether we're better off with Rankine getting a few more cheap touches on the wing, instead of being a forward option.

 

[FR0GGY]

Hold on. Where did this reappraisal come from?

It didn’t clearly miss, the bulldogs players celebrating still maintain to this day it was a goal. Our players said they weren’t sure

The tv angles are inconclusive

There is nothing clear at all, then or 26 years later

Except maybe, we can start to understand a little about how they felt.

What if it was a mistake, and they were right? That would be pretty hard to swallow

Thankfully no one knows for sure

Same umpire?

 

[Slippery Pete]

What if it was a mistake, and they were right?