Good Call. Bad Call. BAD Call.

[TelkoTheGreat]

yer i meant to say Valenti Deserves a spot on our senior list for 2010.

 

[RangaInTeal]

One of McLean, Jones or Moloney need to go at the end of the season, Their Disposal via foot is just not good enough?

*For the record rate all three highly and would love to have one at Port if we couldn't get Daniel Harris, with draft consesions and perseved limited talent in this years draft, would trading one of these lads for a seccond round Draft pick be an option?

 

[Bartram_Class]

One of McLean, Jones or Moloney need to go at the end of the season, Their Disposal via foot is just not good enough?

Agree with the 2nd call, but bad call overall. Many players ahead of them for the chop.

Jamie Bennell is a bit soft.

 

[proka123]

Agree with the 2nd call, but bad call overall. Many players ahead of them for the chop.

Jamie Bennell is a bit soft.

Bad call, he's only young, give him a break.

Melbournefc will win it's next 2 games.

 

[Jeebs]

Bad call, he's only young, give him a break.

Melbournefc will win it's next 2 games.

Bad Call.

MFC will turn over 50%+ of its current senior list in the next 3 years

 

[Supermercado]

Bad Call - we haven't got the grapefruits to do it.

Gold Coast are closer to making the finals than we are

 

[J-Train]

Bad Call - we haven't got the grapefruits to do it.

Gold Coast are closer to making the finals than we are

Bad Call. GC will be 5 years before they make finals. Dees can be there in <5 if the right moves are made.

Since Todd Viney, Melbourne have not had a decent inside mid.

 

[The Dr]

Bad Call. GC will be 5 years before they make finals. Dees can be there in <5 if the right moves are made.

Since Todd Viney, Melbourne have not had a decent inside mid.

Bad call. Brock McLean was more than decent in 2006 and last year before he got injured. Junior is underrated too.

The biggest positives for the Dees this year has been the work Jimmy Stynes and co have done off the field.

 

[RangaInTeal]

Bad call. Brock McLean was more than decent in 2006 and last year before he got injured. Junior is underrated too.

The biggest positives for the Dees this year has been the work Jimmy Stynes and co have done off the field.

Good call, The right motions have been put in place and if Melbourne can become successful like carlton or Essendon in the next 3 years will be a power house within 10 years!

 

[RangaInTeal]

Melbourne have an abundance of Big men, But lack Genuine quality Midfielders and for this there Big men look ordanary with poor delivery and lack of pressure on the ball carrier, the 2009 draft should be about getting Midfielders with good foot skills?

 

[whelan=legend]

Melbourne have an abundance of Big men, But lack Genuine quality Midfielders and for this there Big men look ordanary with poor delivery and lack of pressure on the ball carrier, the 2009 draft should be about getting Midfielders with good foot skills?

Good call, great call, fantastic call

Getting Scully/ Trengove would be more beneficial then getting Scully/ Butcher

 

[Wonaeamirri33]

Good call, The right motions have been put in place and if Melbourne can become successful like carlton or Essendon in the next 3 years will be a power house within 10 years!

Absolutely Ranga. Very good call, and we welcome your postings mate...

Our gameplan and its effectiveness will become far more evident on the field during next season.

 

[CM Sean]

Good call. The 04/05 version version please, I believe he currently goes by the name of Alwyn.

Bad call

Aaron Davey's better then Alwyn

Jack Watts should not be allowed to exit the 50 metre arc of our forward line. (This way his opponent can run off and Jack can stay back to create something to kick to at all times)

 

[RangaInTeal]

Bad call

Aaron Davey's better then Alwyn

Jack Watts should not be allowed to exit the 50 metre arc of our forward line. (This way his opponent can run off and Jack can stay back to create something to kick to at all times)

Bad call, Its about game plan and team development. I also can not remember Johnathon Brown or Warren Tredrea sitting at full forward as 18/19 year olds, Johnathon Brown Time and Time again ran back with the flight of the ball and Warren Tredrea laed his opponents up to the ball and either pushed them under the flight or held front posission, only now they are maturing they are playing deeper. Even Buddy and Roughead are frequently up the ground. Only having one tall target is not helping Watts cause!

Melbourne is 68% more likely to Draft a red head than any other club?

 

[Major Colvin]

Bad call, Its about game plan and team development. I also can not remember Johnathon Brown or Warren Tredrea sitting at full forward as 18/19 year olds, Johnathon Brown Time and Time again ran back with the flight of the ball and Warren Tredrea laed his opponents up to the ball and either pushed them under the flight or held front posission, only now they are maturing they are playing deeper. Even Buddy and Roughead are frequently up the ground. Only having one tall target is not helping Watts cause!

Melbourne is 68% more likely to Draft a red head than any other club?

good call. Who are there...bate, blease, cheney...in memory of Peter Walsh

 

[kv_baby]

Brock 'The Tortoise" McLean is the worst experienced midfielder going around in the afl atm.

 

[Dez!]

Brock 'The Tortoise" McLean is the worst experienced midfielder going around in the afl atm.

Shit call.

James Frawley is Melbourne's best defender.

 

[Jeremias]

Shit call.

James Frawley is Melbourne's best defender.

May I?

I say yes.

Chip is a very impressive kid who is showing some really good signs. He's still fairly light and only young so isn't going to monster his opponents just yet, but you can tell that the kid can flat out play and has a pretty bright future.

Brad Green should be played as a permanent forward from the goalsquare.

 

[Den11]

Good Call

Watts will play a shocker this week due to the Watts V Nic Nat build up for this game

 

[Major Colvin]

Good Call

Watts will play a shocker this week due to the Watts V Nic Nat build up for this game

good call. though will interesting to see how Naitanui. Im looking forward to watching him.

Its reasonable to make comparisons between players after two games

 

[Den11]

Bad Call - We all knew Watts was a three year prospect like othe KPP

Melbourne should blood all their kids who they think have potential, regardless of form, to see who can make it at AFL during the last half of the season

 

[chopper41]

Bad Call - We all knew Watts was a three year prospect like othe KPP

Melbourne should blood all their kids who they think have potential, regardless of form, to see who can make it at AFL during the last half of the season

Good call. We need to find out what we've got.


Should I get a hair cut tomorrow?

 

[master bate]

Good Call - But who is left - McNamara and Strauss are the obvious ones. Besides that there is Bail, McKenzie, Hughes, Zomer and Healey. Hughes and McKenzie deserve a go late in the season but the other 3 don't look likely. I don't mind if they don't blood kids, as long as they don't give games to players who are finished and don't offer anything on field.

Mark Jamar and John Meesen can be a premiership winning ruck division

 

[master bate]

Good call. We need to find out what we've got.


Should I get a hair cut tomorrow?

Once again I got in too late, so I'll answer your question and re ask mine.

Bad call - if you are anything like your name sake in chopper you should stay away from hair cuts. Remember the pink do he sported for a while. That said in late 2005 he came from nowhere with the bleached do.

Mark Jamar and John Meesen can be a premiership winning ruck division

 

[Wonaeamirri33]

Once again I got in too late, so I'll answer your question and re ask mine.

Bad call - if you are anything like your name sake in chopper you should stay away from hair cuts. Remember the pink do he sported for a while. That said in late 2005 he came from nowhere with the bleached do.

Mark Jamar and John Meesen can be a premiership winning ruck division

Good call!

Austin Wonaeamirri will make a big impact when he returns, hopefully before the end of this season