Remove this Banner Ad

Goodbye everyone

  • Thread starter Thread starter 4blues
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
4blues

4blues

Cancelled
Joined
Jul 28, 2006
Posts
1,387
Reaction score
0
Location
Hampton Park Victoria
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
SpringvaleDistricts ,ManU
Goodbye to all the fantastic posters who i have meet over the last 2 years, Last night barrage was the straw that broke the camels back and i have e-mailed BF and cancelled my subscription, have fun all and go the might Blues.
 
So I was not the only one thinking that way - how can it be that we are on our own Carlton board and can sometimes leave it feeling worse than when we logged on. I may join you 4blues but don't burn your bridges 4blues, I am not and I was the one that was supposedly physically up AB's arse - in the thread that was rightly removed within minutes.
 
Harden up guys, this is like everything, it's not all rainbows and sunshine! Couln't you have hung around for another 9 months to celebrate the birth of our 17th flag?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

People, people we should not be fighting amongst ourselves!
Head to the Bay and unleash upon Hawks, Bombers, Dockers, Eagles etc trolls
It is the season to be jolly
 
Jeremias said:
I must have missed some excitement last night here on the Carlton board....
Click to expand...

You just missed the jousting on the AB threads and the following one which was quicky deleted

Bentickslander.jpg


The OP should have been carded

Sublime said:
Should never get to the point where someone wants to quit though. Poor form.
Click to expand...

Spot on
 
Unfortunately, there are always going to be people who believe they are are bigger and better than everyone else on here, and make a point of stating so.

We all love this great club, there should be no infighting but it tends to happen when egos get in the way of things. Shame. But we're sounding more and more like Richmond supporters.
 
AndyWalkersGirl said:
Unfortunately, there are always going to be people who believe they are are bigger and better than everyone else on here, and make a point of stating so.

We all love this great club, there should be no infighting but it tends to happen when egos get in the way of things. Shame. But we're sounding more and more like Richmond supporters.
Click to expand...
I am!:)
 
again you are just as guilty as staying off the thread as this whole page actually. but you want to insult ppl by calling them halfwits & a flog
I call your flog and raise u a c*** sxxxxxng M'Fer

Cant blame him for leaving, thats real bad form
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Why leave because of one clown when there are so many good people on here?
The mods will sort it out I am sure
 
Remember when Walshy said he was leaving and never coming back ?

Too bad he didn't come good on his promise :D
 
I think the problem comes from our own bagging our own players and defending their right to "call a spade a spade" and then we demand our right to "call an idiot and idiot".

Truly - what is to be gained by bagging a Carlton player. If you want to critique him - go for it but watch your adjectives and descriptors - you can be honest and still be respectful

During all the crap last night, I got a call telling me that Mark McGough's (remember him) older brother died in a diving accident - just think of his parents having to bury their oldest son before Xmas - Puts it all in perspective does it not

ps 4blues - Thy retired once but came back so you can too. Imagine this board w/o thy
 
Five said:
I think the problem comes from our own bagging our own players and defending their right to "call a spade a spade" and then we demand our right to "call an idiot and idiot".

Truly - what is to be gained by bagging a Carlton player. If you want to critique him - go for it but watch your adjectives and descriptors - you can be honest and still be respectful

During all the crap last night, I got a call telling me that Mark McGough's (remember him) older brother died in a diving accident - just think of his parents having to bury their oldest son before Xmas - Puts it all in perspective does it not

ps 4blues - Thy retired once but came back so you can too. Imagine this board w/o thy
Click to expand...

Would have made my stay a whole lot easier and more fun.
 
Meeeeeeeh.......toughen up son.
you cant go running away from every conflict that arises in life.
Players always have and always will be citicised on this board.

When you start a personal attack on a poster that criticizes a player you start to get personal. Defend the player if you like, no need to attack the poster.

Five may be playing the innocent party here but was responsible for the initial personal attacks following my criticism of AB. He is friends with ABs junior coach and seems to take criticism of AB a little personally.

In the polls thread he was up in arms and on the attack purely because a poll re AB had been started.

Other posters coming in and part quoting an ongoing argument dosnt help either.

As a poster said about Jake the Snake recently ' dont go away and sulk, just harden the fxxk up' as life will throw you a lot worse at times than was seen here last night.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Some posters on here need to learn how to criticize players in an appropriate manner ..i believe the mods should edit their posts to make them appropriate .

Just remember these players you are abusing pulled on a Carlton jumper ..which is a lot more than you will ever do .

Criticism without being abusive is not too much to ask .
 
Blues_Man said:
Some posters on here need to learn how to criticize players in an appropriate manner ..i believe the mods should edit their posts to make them appropriate .

Just remember these players you are abusing pulled on a Carlton jumper ..which is a lot more than you will ever do .

Criticism without being abusive is not too much to ask .
Click to expand...

Hear hear.

Though I don't see the point of leaving the site of the back of an argument with one or two posters. There's probably dozens on posters on the Carlton board alone that you get along with - why let a handful ruin the experience for you?
 
doh its me said:
Meeeeeeeh.......toughen up son.
you cant go running away from every conflict that arises in life.
Players always have and always will be citicised on this board.

When you start a personal attack on a poster that criticizes a player you start to get personal. Defend the player if you like, no need to attack the poster.

Five may be playing the innocent party here but was responsible for the initial personal attacks following my criticism of AB. He is friends with ABs junior coach and seems to take criticism of AB a little personally.

In the polls thread he was up in arms and on the attack purely because a poll re AB had been started.

Other posters coming in and part quoting an ongoing argument dosnt help either.

As a poster said about Jake the Snake recently ' dont go away and sulk, just harden the fxxk up' as life will throw you a lot worse at times than was seen here last night.
Click to expand...

I think most people will see where the personal attacks came from.
If you are referring to this as the start

Change your name to tickets - as if we all don't all know these things.
It is just that we can think of better things to post other than who will be delisted when it is PRESEASON :eek: I am embarrassed for you :rolleyes:

Then I think we know who has to toughen up LOL
 
Blues_Man said:
Some posters on here need to learn how to criticize players in an appropriate manner ..i believe the mods should edit their posts to make them appropriate .

Just remember these players you are abusing pulled on a Carlton jumper ..which is a lot more than you will ever do .

Criticism without being abusive is not too much to ask .
Click to expand...

I agree and believe Bentick was never criticised in an inappropriate manner. I just really stated that I didnt think he was good enough, giving my reasons for this belief.

As pointed out last night there were dozens of posters last year referring to Ackland as Hackland, which is far more belittling than was what was written about AB.

These same posters now are on their high horse about criticism of AB because they prefer him.

The OP of the poll contained little if no criticism of AB....it was just a damn poll as I thought Jacko was unlucky and Bentick lucky.

You dont have to support every list management decision your club makes to still support your team.

The world would be a sad place if filled with "yes" men who agree on everything. There is room for disagreement and debate, without attacks on the ppl that do so.
 
I'm sure bentick doesn't care about people bagging him due to the fact he is an AFL FOOTBALLER and GETS PAID TO PLAY FOOTBALL for a living. So no need for anyone to get upset. Us bentick fans can give it to his doubters when he racks up 30 in and under touches in a wet weather game.

On a side note, how does russel get games over AB? Picking russel over AB is like picking watson for a test match over a superstar victorian.
 
Five said:
I think most people will see where the personal attacks came from.
If you are referring to this as the start

Change your name to tickets - as if we all don't all know these things.
It is just that we can think of better things to post other than who will be delisted when it is PRESEASON :eek: I am embarrassed for you :rolleyes:

Then I think we know who has to toughen up LOL
Click to expand...

I think the personal attacks started from you in both threads, clearly in the Poll, so dont act the innocent party here Five, you are starting to look silly again.

"Change your name to tickets" - "I feel embarrassed for you" - condasending insults without swearing - congratulations in starting a fight that escalated bit by bit in such a way.

As I have said before 'part quoting' dosnt provide accurate pictures of events......if ppl want to see what happenned they should go read through the whole threads.

I am plenty tough enough mate, you dont see me running from conflict, and certainly tough enough to take on the likes of you, but that statement is just another example of your attempted use of provocation to start an argument.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom