Phantom Draft Gosaints12 Mock Draft Game - 7th of Nov 8am AEDT kickoff

[Gosaints12]

Draft Order;



R1



1: GWS - Aaron Cadman

2: Brisbane matched, (bid North) - Will Ashcroft

3: North - Harry Sheezel

4: North - George Wardlaw

5: St Kilda - Elijah Tsatas

6: Gold Coast - Bailey Humphrey

7: Hawthorn - Cam McKenzie

8: Geelong - Jhye Clark

9: West Coast - Mattaes Phillipou

10: Essendon - Reuben Ginbey

11: Carlton - Matthew Jefferson

12: Western Bulldogs - Jedd Busslinger

13: West Coast - Elijah Hewett

14: Melbourne - Oliver Hollands

15: Sydney - Brayden George

16: GWS - Jacob Konstanty

17: Essendon - Henry Hustwaite

18: Sydney - Harry Barnett

19: GWS - Josh Weddle



R2



20: GWS - Olli Hotton

21: West Coast - Isaac Keeler

22: Brisbane match, (bid Western Bulldogs) – Jaspa Fletcher

23: Essendon match, (bid Western Bulldogs) – Alwyn Davey

Multiple players found. Use birthday to differentiate. eg [PLAYERCARD="23/11/1962"]Joe Smith[/PLAYERCARD]

JR

24: Western Bulldogs – Lewis Hayes

25: Collingwood – Ed Allan

26: North - Lachlan Cowan

27: Hawthorn - Charlie Clarke

28: Collingwood - Max Gruzewski

29: West Coast - Coby Burgiel

30: Collingwood: Harry Lemmey

31: St Kilda: Mitch Syzbkowski

32: Carlton: Darcy Jones

33: North: Ethan Phillips

34: GWS: Noah Long

35: Adelaide: Max Michelanny (matched bid)

36: Port: Sam Gilbey

37: Hawthorn: Billy Dowling

38: Melbourne: Tom Scully

21

Tom Scully

Age

32

Ht

181cm

Wt

80kg

Pos.

M/F

Career

Season

Last 5

D

20.7

5star

K

9.9

4star

HB

10.8

5star

M

3.8

4star

T

3.5

5star

CL

2.3

4star

D

12.6

3star

K

7.5

3star

HB

5.1

3star

M

2.4

3star

T

1.1

2star

CL

0.8

3star

D

19.8

5star

K

8.8

4star

HB

11.0

5star

M

3.0

3star

T

4.6

5star

CL

3.8

5star

39: St Kilda: Nick Sadler




R3



40: Western Bulldogs: Adam D'Aloia

41: Fremantle: Jed Hagan

42: Hawthorn: Jakob Ryan

43: Sydney: Phoenix Foster

44: Fremantle: Hugh Davies

45: Fremantle: Jackson Broadbent

46: Essendon: Anthony Munkara (matched bid)

47: Essendon: Jayden Davey (matched bid)

48: Gold Coast: James Van Es

49: St Kilda: Toby McMullin

50: Carlton: Jason Gillbee

51: Richmond: Kaleb Smith

52: GWS: Harry Rowston

53: Geelong: Harvey Gallagher



R4

54: Adelaide: Will Verrell

55: Adelaide: Hugh Bond

56: Port: Luke Teal

57: Western Bulldogs: Jaxon Biggs

58: Fremantle: Jasper Scaife, (bid matched)

59: Richmond: Jovan Petric

60: Geelong: Jaiden Magor

61: Hawthorn: Blake Drury

62: Carlton: Jack Maibaum

63: North: Oscar Murdoch

64: Brisbane: Casey Voss

65: Collingwood: Nick Madden, (GWS pass)

66: North: Cooper Harvey

67: Brisbane: Shadeau Brain

 

[blueiris]

I didn’t mean that to sound nasty either. Just clarifying. If you offered 35 & 2 x future thirds then in the real world maybe…. But 40 and 43 for 35 and 55 may have also had a chance as it gives nth 2 picks still, which they will need/probably use, with added coverage for a Harvey bid just in case also.

All good

 

[weltschmerz]

If you are into 2 specific players, perhaps you would consider trading up when I am on the clock at 8.

I'm more interested in trading down if those players aren't there.

 

[bone2468]

Pick 13 and fremantle F1st up for trade

 

[Gosaints12]

blueiris pick 47 for a future 4th and Pick 52?

 

[blueiris]

blueiris pick 47 for a future 4th and Pick 52?

Sorry mate

 

[Gosaints12]

Sorry mate

Worth a go, Fair enough.

 

[Ash24]

GWS, Sydney and WC all declining my trade proposals

 

[Gosaints12]

GWS, Sydney and WC all declining my trade proposals

Welcome to the phantom draft. It gets heated in here sometimes.

 

[Gosaints12]

32 or 47 for sale if anyone wants it. Needs to include a future 4th in the deal.

 

[briztoon]

48; 50; 52 for 36 and 55

I will happily agree to that swap of picks.

Hawks can’t trade pick 48 to Brisbane, because Brisbane traded it to Hawthorn in the Gunston trade, it’s against AFL rules.

Would you do 40 and 43 for pick 35 and a Future 3rd

That’s not a good trade. Better off keeping pick 35 and just trading a future 3rd round pick for a current 3rd pick, from a team that won’t use the pick.

Probably won’t happen here, in a game, but it’s probable in the real thing.

 

[Gosaints12]

Hawks can’t trade pick 48 to Brisbane, because Brisbane traded it to Hawthorn in the Gunston trade, it’s against AFL rules.



That’s not a good trade. Better off keeping pick 35 and just trading a future 3rd round pick for a current 3rd pick, from a team that won’t use the pick.

Probably won’t happen here, in a game, but it’s probable in the real thing.

I will double check that rule. Are you sure because Brisbane got 55 back from the Cats?

 

[eth-dog]

Hawks can’t trade pick 48 to Brisbane, because Brisbane traded it to Hawthorn in the Gunston trade, it’s against AFL rules.



That’s not a good trade. Better off keeping pick 35 and just trading a future 3rd round pick for a current 3rd pick, from a team that won’t use the pick.

Probably won’t happen here, in a game, but it’s probable in the real thing.

Nah, that's only in the case on the night.

 

[Gosaints12]

Nah, that's only in the case on the night.

Trade stands, thanks guys.

 

[GoldenMagpie16]

Pick 16 up for sale

 

[briztoon]

Nah, that's only in the case on the night.

No, it’s not.

AFL rules are, no matter which trade period in the one year, you can’t trade a pick back to the team you got it from.

Back when Noble was still our GM of football, he explained it pretty clearly on the clubs podcast, and explained that the Lions kept a spreadsheet of such picks handy, to reference on draft night.

He even mentioned that the rule stopped the Lions from making a trade at the 2018 draft, when we were trying to trade back in the get Answerth late.

 

[eth-dog]

No, it’s not.

AFL rules are, no matter which trade period in the one year, you can’t trade a pick back to the team you got it from.

Back when Noble was still our GM of football, he explained it pretty clearly on the clubs podcast, and explained that the Lions kept a spreadsheet of such picks handy, to reference on draft night.

He even mentioned that the rule stopped the Lions from making a trade at the 2018 draft, when we were trying to trade back in the get Answerth late.

Could have sworn I saw a trade that disagrees with that but I can't remember right now.

 

[WilloTree]

woo hoo

Full boat, picks are up. Let's go.

Thanks Gosaints12 for organizing. This will be a lot of fun.

 

[PMBangers]

I'll just start it now because I'll defs struggle to get a pick up tomorrow morning

GWS Pick 1
Aaron Cadman
195 cm 91 kg
Tall Forward
GWV Rebels

I've spoken about him a ridiculous amount recently, so I'll do the lazy thing and just link the Rookie Me Central profile xx

STRENGTHS:

• Contested marking
• Forward craft
• Leading patterns
• Mobility
• Scoreboard impact
• Strength

IMPROVEMENTS:

• Set shot consistency
• Ground balls

Cadman has developed into one of the top prospects in the 2022 AFL Draft, so it is no surprise that there are plenty of strengths to his game that have allowed him sustained and consistent success at elite junior level. His prime strength compared to his peers is his contested marking, with his sticky and safe hands the clear standout trait that has him in the elite category for that area.

What allows Cadman to take so many marks - averaging 5.5 per game at NAB League and 6.3 in the AFL Under 18 Championships - are his forward craft and his leading patterns. He knows when to lead and when to engage in a wrestle, and though his natural body strength is another area that works in his favour, Cadman is best known for finding the space inside 50, leading into the space and taking the ball cleanly.

More than capable of crashing packs, Cadman is more of a clean grab marker that enables him to more often than not pull down the contested grab. He took six of them - at 1.5 per game - for Vic Country and is hard to spoil when his arms are outstretched. Though taller players might have longer reach. Once the ball is in his hands, it is near-impossible to spill it from there.

Cadman plays a simple but effective game for a key forward. He works hard on the lead, picks the right time to go, and has the safest hands to be able to pull down the mark. His mobility - which while not an elite athlete like a Max King - is still an asset, with Cadman able to move reasonably well for a readymade forward who is well along the way to being fully developed. Unlike others who are better described as beanpoles, Cadman has the best of both worlds in being strong, but also mobile.

Once Cadman has done all the hard work of finding the space, leading and taking the mark, his set shot goalkicking can let him down. Though, it is not a case of him being a technically poor set shot for goal. In fact, sometimes Cadman can be nailing majors from anywhere within 60m of the big sticks, but it is more his consistency when it comes to set shots - as it showed when Vic Country fell short of Vic Metro, booting 3.3.

In Round 5 of the NAB League he booted 1.3, then returned in Round 8 against the Jets to slot 5.0. The next week he kicked 4.4, then 5.1. Back-to-back weeks of 2.5 and 3.3 were followed up by 4.0 in the final round of the regular season. Effectively, a confident Cadman is a match-winning dominant player, but he can have his woes in front of goal.

Another area of improvement which is not as crucial to his role as a key forward is his ground ball ability. Cadman is so good in the air, and mobile, that he also competes well at ground level. If he can be a touch cleaner below his knees, he can take his game to another level.




Smythe with North Melbourne

 

[Ash24]

Are we able to please sticky the users picking for each club? Makes it easier when tagging the person for the next pick.

 

[Smythe]

PICK 2 - North Melbourne - Bid for Will Ashcroft

blueiris Do you match.

 

[Gosaints12]

Offical trade: Brisbane trade 38 and a future 4th to St Kilda for Pick 32.

 

[blueiris]

PICK 2 - North Melbourne - Bid for Will Ashcroft

blueiris Do you match.

Brisbane Lions Match Welcome ASHCROFT
Smythe your up again mate

 

[Gosaints12]

@p

Brisbane Lions Match Welcome ASHCROFT

Sorry mate held you up there.

 

[Gosaints12]

Sorry mate held you up there.

I’ll do the math soon.

 

[blueiris]

Sorry mate held you up there.

All good mate