Apparently he is a "St Kilda" supporter. LOL
More like a Cat's supporter who created a 2nd BF account so he could vote twice in the poll for Geelong and also post endlessly about how Geelong are the best team wjhile pretending to be a neutral.
He also started a second thread on the main board under his St Kilda account intending to support the premise that Geelong are the best: the topic of the thread was something like "Was 2011 the most difficult premiership ever won?"
And one time he posted how he believed all the people who voted for Hawthorn in the poll were Hawthorn supporters.
It is really small and really funny, and says something about how insecure some Cat's supporters are.
Well whether PJAYS is a cat supporter or not, I couldn't care less. Like you said "some" Cat supporters are insecure.
Anyone who this insecure about their team reminds of Trumpism now or the GOP's in the US.
They're not interested in objective anylsis. They are just believe on reality and they are trying to convince you that their reality is the only true reality.
Every counter point you bring up is just misunderstanding of their reality.
Been a Hawks supporter (and I'm also a AC Milan supporter and used to be a Chicago Bulls fan) so I've seen over the decades what dynasties look like, particularly the best ones. The best ones tend to be:
- long lasting
- changed the game (usually for a long time)
- Had the best players or player
- Always defended their title in successive years
- There was no question if they were the best at the time
- They had a lot imitators
You would probably need all those things to be a sporting dynasty and the extent of those attributes would determine how great of a dyansty.