Harley out for 2009?

[martyk]

If the team performs well (as in '08), he will be OK to come back and regain his form in the side.
The bad regarding Harley is he has had NO match practice at all this pre-season! If the team is not dominating, this bloke will be a big liability to the team. He'll refuse to play in the 2s, as he has in the past... which is ridiculous.
Solution? He shouldn't be Captain. The day of the older captain is gone. You need younger players who will front up without requiring a substantial amount of games to get their form back... Any player (Harley incl.) should never have the opportunity to regain form in a premiership contending side like Geelong. NEVER! Flags are slim pickings as we know... Harley should have retired. We have a wealth of young blokes eager to have a crack at it. The club is taking a step backwards with Harley... not forward. His leadership can remain off the field.

 

[budge11]

If the team performs well (as in '08), he will be OK to come back and regain his form in the side.
The bad regarding Harley is he has had NO match practice at all this pre-season! If the team is not dominating, this bloke will be a big liability to the team. He'll refuse to play in the 2s, as he has in the past... which is ridiculous.
Solution? He shouldn't be Captain. The day of the older captain is gone. You need younger players who will front up without requiring a substantial amount of games to get their form back... Any player (Harley incl.) should never have the opportunity to regain form in a premiership contending side like Geelong. NEVER! Flags are slim pickings as we know... Harley should have retired. We have a wealth of young blokes eager to have a crack at it. The club is taking a step backwards with Harley... not forward. His leadership can remain off the field.

I was surprised when I read this. Is this the general consensus with Geelong fans?

 

[Exhale You]

I was surprised when I read this. Is this the general consensus with Geelong fans?

No, far from it.

If you look through martyk's post (and those of his aliases) you'll see that he's nothing more than an obsessive and attention seeking anti-Harley troll.

 

[JUBJUB]

I was surprised when I read this. Is this the general consensus with Geelong fans?

Nope,most of us know martyk is a tool who hates Harley.martyk is the #1 [and only] ticket holder of the Josh Hunt Fan Club,so I think that explains a fair bit his mentality.

 

[JUBJUB]

He'll refuse to play in the 2s, as he has in the past... which is ridiculous.

I see you're suffering from short term memory loss and can't remember events from 18 months ago.

 

[darren forssman]

martyk is the #1 [and only] ticket holder of the Josh Hunt Fan Club,so I think that explains a fair bit his mentality.

incorrect. renegade has a monopoly on the membership of the josh "drawstring" hunt fanclub.

 

[AlphaDark]

No, far from it.

If you look through martyk's post (and those of his aliases) you'll see that he's nothing more than an obsessive and attention seeking anti-Harley troll.

Troll = Gold.

 

[JUBJUB]

incorrect. renegade has a monopoly on the membership of the josh "drawstring" hunt fanclub.

I also forgot Catfan79.Okay,so there's 3 [and that's all] members of his fan club.

 

[martyk]

I also forgot Catfan79.Okay,so there's 3 [and that's all] members of his fan club.

Then there are those (JUB JUB a great example), who can't help but bite the bait each and every time.

Good work for keeping true to form.

 

[Hinkley29]

Then there are those (JUB JUB a great example), who can't help but bite the bait each and every time.

Good work for keeping true to form.

So you are admitting to being a troll?

If so - piss off and don't come back.