Recommitted Harry McKay [re-signed to 2023]

[Malifice]

my point was they didnt offer a fair deal as they knew he was out of contract wanted to go to them on whatever salary they agreed and could just let him walk to them for free

Yeah a fair deal for McKay is a bit more than 'a future 1st'. Obviously being uncontracted and holding PSD pick reduces that, but there is a gap between 'Walk him to the PSD for free' and 'Fair market price'.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Genuinely think we'd let Cripps walk before letting Harry go if it was a simple matter of Norf sperging out again with some $10 mil contract offer. Most important player at Carlton

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

He has no contract. Your club aren't the ones "letting go", you have no grip.

 

[james Dean]

why the hell would he want to go to
North Melbourne

 

[The Nostradamus]

why the hell would he want to go to
North Melbourne

Money
twin brother plays there too
Money

also despite being last atm id argue we are a lot closer to a premiership than others above us

 

[Skull Face]

He has no contract. Your club aren't the ones "letting go", you have no grip.

could have picked a better club for a troll account, obvious much?

 

[Malifice]

could have picked a better club for a troll account, obvious much?

If it helps, just picture what's going on in his real life that has made setting up an alt account to troll strangers a valid way to cope with it.

 

[Skull Face]

If it helps, just picture what's going on in his real life that has made setting up an alt account to troll strangers a valid way to cope with it.

I always enjoy a bit of quality trolling though

 

[Malifice]

I always enjoy a bit of quality trolling though

You dont have to clean it up.

 

[Skull Face]

You dont have to clean it up.

Doggies fan, manofclay is my guess

 

[Skull Face]

You dont have to clean it up.

there is literally some s**t to clean up over in the regional boards, must have guessed who it was 1st try

 

[Sweet Jesus]

It's worth considering that he's on track to be a FA at the end of 2023.

Does he sign a two-year deal to give himself another window in two years or do Carlton sign him up longer term?

He could probably sign for two years on 800k apiece and then field FA offers. Or do Carlton say "here's 4 million over five years"?

 

[Virgin Dog]

It's worth considering that he's on track to be a FA at the end of 2023.

Does he sign a two-year deal to give himself another window in two years or do Carlton sign him up longer term?

He could probably sign for two years on 800k apiece and then field FA offers. Or do Carlton say "here's 4 million over five years"?

Given the rate Carlton is going, a 2 year deal seems sensible. Gives them 2 years to show improvement rather than risking wasting the majority of his career at a struggling club like Murphy before him, and Jones at Melbourne.

 

[Sweet Jesus]

Given the rate Carlton is going, a 2 year deal seems sensible. Gives them 2 years to show improvement rather than risking wasting the majority of his career at a struggling club like Murphy before him, and Jones at Melbourne.

Big pay day as a FA if he wanted it.

I suspect they might meet in the middle and agree $2.5 million over three years.

He'd be 26-27 at the end of that and could cash in as a FA, provided he maintains current form.

 

[THE_GUN]

The KPF player you would select with a top 5 pick you would be hoping , wishing , praying that in 5 years he becomes a talent like Harry McKay

easily worth a top 5 pick


But its looking like he is going to cost a fair bit of $$$ for him to sign long term

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Genuinely think we'd let Cripps walk before letting Harry go if it was a simple matter of Norf sperging out again with some $10 mil contract offer. Most important player at Carlton

Aside from your namesake.

 

[TheKITC]

Another nice game from Harry today, 4 more to the tally and outright second in the Coleman. Making a lot of people look foolish for writing him off.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Another nice game from Harry today, 4 more to the tally and outright second in the Coleman. Making a lot of people look foolish for writing him off.

Not to mention he was sick coming into the game and had just been cleared from a Covid test this morning.

 

[Blue_Steel89]

A few people laughed at me when I predicted Harry would be top 3 in the Coleman this year. Still early but doing well

 

[THE_GUN]

So what $$$ is he worth ?
How much will he ask for to stay ?

Should Carlton give him a 7 year deal and sign him up to be a 1 club player before he gets to free agency

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

So what $$$ is he worth ?
How much will he ask for to stay ?

Should Carlton give him a 7 year deal and sign him up to be a 1 club player before he gets to free agency

7 year deals are built to fail. No thanks. Start winning games and he'll stay for far less meaning we'd actually have salary cap room to shuffle around and improve as a team.

 

[Lore]

Not here to talk about North Melbourne. Thanks.

 

[Sweet Jesus]

So what $$$ is he worth ?
How much will he ask for to stay ?

Should Carlton give him a 7 year deal and sign him up to be a 1 club player before he gets to free agency

Meet in the middle and agree $2.5 million over three years.

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

Makes sense for Harry to sign until free agency and see if the blues improve

If they don’t you can’t blame him for leaving

Talk was they already had Charlie on 750 so Harry will be getting a nice contract

 

[james Dean]

4 years 800 k