Harvey making his debut this week

[Lidge]

Thought some of you may be interested. Been selected this week for North with Leigh Harding being dumped to make room for him.

Feel free to vent your spleens (or post congrats if you're that way inclined)

 

[Bartholin Juice]

Squib.

Won't last long at a hard working and honest side like the Roos.

 

[Runk]

He's the greatest player ever to play the game according to him. Good luck getting the ball into your forward line. His head will keep blocking all your kicks into the 50. Total knob jockey. I hope North wake up to this soon.

 

[MOJOE]

First class tool...

Still wonder why the dons drafted him - surely they would have known he was a knob from the start? Then again, he has good bloodlines (even with the red hair!!!). Oh well!

 

[M29]

Unless he does something amazing in the next 20 minutes, I can't say we're going to miss him.

McGrath on the other hand. ****.

 

[bOmBeR_BoY1]

Today confirmed all our thoughts... Shane Harvey cannot play consistant AFL football and is better off suited returning to the Diamond Valley and earning a bit playing for a Northcote Park or West Preston! Am I being too judgemental in just his first game in Roos colours? No. We saw for ourselves when he played for Essendon he didn't have the proper application or consistancy to play AFL.

As for McGrath, good on him for getting a run and playing well. I will say bar last night's game, I have been much happier with having Justin Murphy this year.

 

[dave_27]

lol what an impressive debut for the kangas. dud

 

[Sports Capital]

He's to worried about his hair

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Originally posted by M29
Unless he does something amazing in the next 20 minutes, I can't say we're going to miss him.

McGrath on the other hand. ****.

Tough on Harvey. I had him among the best ..... for Carlton!

McGrath had a fantastic game. For the first time this season, Carlton scored points from the Murphy/McGrath trade.

 

[M29]

Ha!

Bannister did ok I thought. It was an ordinary game to say the least.

Neither team top 8 material. Though we can't talk. Massive gap this year between 5th and 8th in terms of skills.