Hawthorn 2008 vs Collingwood 2010

[Black Haze]

Which side do you think was better? Both did well to knock off Geelong when it mattered during their dominant 2007-2011 run, and are often underrated in discussions about best premiership sides.

 

[PowerfulPies2023]

Tough one. Both lost onlyb4 games for the season. Their finals campaign was exceptional. We needed a replay and could have lost if not for a lucky bounce. We both smashed bulldogs week 1 of the finals. Hawks Granny was better than our first one. I honestly can't split them.

 

[MasterSamurai]

Maybe pies but just.