List Mgmt. Hawthorn 2018 Trade discussion NO OPPOSITION SUPPORTERS Part 3

[Hawk Dork]

Buddy has played equal if not better at the swans

https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy...pid2=1488&fid1=P&fopt1=2016&fid2=P&fopt2=2011
Compare any year to any other past or present
He kicked more goals at Hawthorn and had better disposal efficiency, and gave away far more free kicks.

He peaked in 2008

 

[Pessimistic]

Buddy has played equal if not better at the swans

Cough 2008 Cough. Being heavily relied upon is not the same thing. Anyway I did say arguably.

 

[Judd2Sewell]

Buddy has played equal if not better at the swans

His best seasons with us:

2008 - 113 goals (4.5 p/g, career #1), 15.3 disposals, 6.3 marks (equal career #2), 2 tackles

2010 - 64 goals (3.6 p/g, equal career #3), 17.8 disposals (career #3), 5.6 marks (equal career #6), 3.8 tackles (career #1)

2011 - 82 goals (3.7 p/g, career #2), 18.2 disposals (career #2), 5.9 marks (career #4), 3.3 tackles (career #3)

2012 - 69 goals (3.6 p/g, equal career #3), 18.4 disposals (career #1), 5.8 marks (career #5), 3.7 tackles (career #2)

And with Sydney:

2014 - 79 goals (3.6 p/g, equal career #3), 16.7 disposals (career #6), 6.3 marks (equal career #2), 3 tackles (career #4)

2016 - 81 goals (3.1 p/g, career #7), 17.6 disposals (career #4), 6 marks (career #3), 2.6 tackles (career #6)

 

[MasterSamurai]

His best seasons with us:

2008 - 113 goals (4.5 p/g, career #1), 15.3 disposals, 6.3 marks (equal career #2), 2 tackles

2010 - 64 goals (3.6 p/g, equal career #3), 17.8 disposals (career #3), 5.6 marks (equal career #6), 3.8 tackles (career #1)

2011 - 82 goals (3.7 p/g, career #2), 18.2 disposals (career #2), 5.9 marks (career #4), 3.3 tackles (career #3)

2012 - 69 goals (3.6 p/g, equal career #3), 18.4 disposals (career #1), 5.8 marks (career #5), 3.7 tackles (career #2)

And with Sydney:

2014 - 79 goals (3.6 p/g, equal career #3), 16.7 disposals (career #6), 6.3 marks (equal career #2), 3 tackles (career #4)

2016 - 81 goals (3.1 p/g, career #7), 17.6 disposals (career #4), 6 marks (career #3), 2.6 tackles (career #6)

How on earth did this guy NOT win a Brownlow in either 2008 or 2011?? The mind boggles!

 

[Leather Poisoning]

How on earth did this guy NOT win a Brownlow in either 2008 or 2011?? The mind boggles!

Especially 2008.
Cooney had a great year but nobody is talking about how dominant he was in 2008 - people still talk about Buddy's ton and ask if it can ever be repeated.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Meh. Thread is done.