Autopsy Heartbreaking loss to swans by 2 points

[CFC2010]

anyone what how many injuries in total that is this year with Moore's hammy recurrence?

Too many

 

[jonob1995]

Too many

i know. but do we have an exact number?

 

[CFC2010]

i know. but do we have an exact number?

Four I think

 

[TradeDraft]

My Dad said on News said Swans last goal was Touched

 

[Temploar]

+ picking up the NAB rising star favourite at pick 6 in the draft
+ picking up an AFL ready made tall forward in the rookie draft
+ developing players stepping up to the next level, such as Grundy, WHE, JT, JDG, Langdon, Maynard, Cox, Aish, Sier
+ continued strong output from mature players like Pendles, Sidebottom, Adams, Treloar

Those developing players stepping up to the next level has definitely been the catalyst to our improvement.

Grundy is equal with Gawn as the best ruck in the comp. No doubt about it. Both have their strengths and weaknesses though.

WHE probably the most accurate set shot for goal in the comp. Next to Josh caddy. Underrated player.

JT has gone from a banned player with a questionable future to someone who contributes every week and pops up for a sneaky goal or 4 occasionally.

JDG is very close to being elite. His running power is amazing. When he's at full speed he's lightning quick.

Combine that with the Stephenson rotation we had going on in the forward line between JDG/Stevo and both of them at top speed are seriously damaging over time to the opposition defenders.
Stephenson has been so important playing a great first year and him breaking some games open has been vital.

Cox is integral to our structure.

Defence held up well at full strength. Maynard good. Scharenberg and Dunn very good before injuries.


A bright future ahead if we can get these players on the park more often.

 

[caloschwaby]

My Dad said on News said Swans last goal was Touched

Legit what I thought when I saw it...

 

[Temploar]

My Dad said on News said Swans last goal was Touched

So next weeks banner is gonna say IT WAS TOUCHED instead of IT WAS A THROW

 

[TradeDraft]

So next weeks banner is gonna say IT WAS TOUCHED instead of IT WAS A THROW

or Both

 

[TradeDraft]

How we lost last night must been the way we lost the GF's when the Collywobbles where Evented

 

[Axl the great]

Four I think

And in his interview at the airport he looks totally jack of it and not like someone wanting to stay.

 

[Temploar]

How we lost last night must been the way we lost the GF's when the Collywobbles where Evented

For me it just felt like from the third quarter I knew we weren't gonna win. Just felt like it was set up to be a heartbreaking loss when Moore went down. Seen it happen too many times.

 

[Temploar]

And in his interview at the airport he looks totally jack of it and not like someone wanting to stay.

What did he say

 

[CFC2010]

And in his interview at the airport he looks totally jack of it and not like someone wanting to stay.

Basically said what we’re doing is not working......no shit Collingwood.

Send him OS this week.......enough is enough.

 

[JOELY]

And in his interview at the airport he looks totally jack of it and not like someone wanting to stay.

Didn't really get that impression at all. Look disappointed but pretty measured.

 

[Temploar]

Basically said what we’re doing is not working......no shit Collingwood.

Send him OS this week.......enough is enough.

Send him to the German doctor that Reid went to and then In the pre season get him to the high altitude training that swanny went to.

They must do whatever they can to get this kid right because he has rare potential but I think he might actually need some good months off. His body might be sick of constantly repairing itself.

 

[Pie eyed]

No salt

They gave it their all.

Buddy Franklin. What can you do?

Dunn would have been handy.
Expecting Moore too beat Buddy was a stretch and Madgen would have been a miracle in his first match.

 

[TradeDraft]

For me it just felt like from the third quarter I knew we weren't gonna win. Just felt like it was set up to be a heartbreaking loss when Moore went down. Seen it happen too many times.

I said at Half Time when I found out Moore done a Hammy AGAIN we had no chance of winning

 

[Civilest]

From round 1 in order.. we have had about 20 full quarters this year with one man short. Excludes part quarters and late withdrawals


Collingwood: The Pies picked up a couple of injuries late in the game with Josh Smith nicking a hamstring in the fourth quarter and Ben Crocker coming off after copping a knock to his back. Darcy Moore was icing both Achilles tendons in the rooms afterwards but isn't believed to have picked up any fresh concerns. .... 0 Qtrs

Tim Broomhead broke both the tibia and fibula in his left leg at the nine-minute mark of the first term, when he tried to soccer a goal and his leg collected the goalpost. The impact was sickening and the forward was stretchered from the ground in obvious pain, before taking to hospital by ambulance. Darcy Moore went down to the rooms late in the second term to be assessed for a hamstring injury. He returned to the ground briefly but did not appear for the second half. Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley said Moore had suffered hamstring tightness and was in doubt for the Magpies' round three clash with carlton ......5 Qtrs

Collingwood: The Pies' have one of the worst injury lists in the competition, but appeared to get through unscathed in another positive to their night.

Collingwood: The Magpies had a clean bill of health to complete a perfect night.

Collingwood: The Magpies escaped with a clean bill of health.

Collingwood: Tom Langdon was a late withdrawal from Sunday's game, with the Magpies saying the defender had been "managed" in the wake of the four-day break following their Anzac Day win over Essendon. James Aish came from the ground early in the third term with a left knee injury after being crunched in a marking contest. The midfielder took no further part in the game. Brayden Maynard went into the rooms after appearing to suffer a right ankle injury but returned to the field. Ben Reid limped from the ground in the dying minutes with a an Achilles problem and could miss several weeks. .... 1 qtr

Collingwood: Darcy Moore came off the ground in the second quarter complaining of a hamstring injury. The club confirmed it was the same hamstring he injured earlier in the season against Greater Western Sydney in round two. Tom Phillips left the field groggy after his head collided with teammate Chris Mayne's leg when he kicked a goal in the third quarter. Not long after he was ruled out of the game.... 3 Qtrs

Collingwood: More ill-luck for small forward Alex Fasolo who will undergo scans this week to learn the extent of a syndesmosis injury. It was his first game back for 2018. ...3 Qtrs

Collingwood: Travis Varcoe's night ended early when he came off the ground in the third quarter with a hamstring injury. Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley said after the game Varcoe had suffered a "likely strain".... 1 Qtr

Collingwood: Magpie Steele Sidebottom copped a hefty corkie to his left leg in the final term, but stayed on the field and played out the game... 0 Qtrs

Collingwood: Injury-prone Magpie Daniel Wells limped from the field in the second term with a left foot issue, but he returned to the field and had five disposals in the final quarter. ....1 Qtrs

Collingwood: Collingwood is hopeful Adam Treloar has escaped a serious hamstring injury after the midfielder went down grabbing his leg and writhing in pain. The Magpies believe the onballer succumbed to a severe bout of cramp. Defender Levi Greenwood was placed in the concussion protocol after a high hit from Blue Dale Thomas, with coach Nathan Buckley saying he would be assessed during the week.... 0 Qtrs

Collingwood: Defender Lynden Dunn was the only casualty from the contest, limping off with a knee injury in the third quarter. Coach Nathan Buckley said Dunn would need scans, but he was "concerned" about the injury....1Qtr

Collingwood: Will Hoskin-Elliott suffered a right knee knock late in the opening term and came from the ground, but returned relatively early in the second quarter and played out the game. A positive day suffered a late negative when Flynn Appleby suffered a right hamstring injury late in the final quarter....0 Qtrs

Collingwood: Darcy Moore dislocated his finger in the second term but came back onto the ground after receiving treatment. Brayden Sier copped a heavily corked left quad in the third term and despite trying to get it moving on the stationary bike he was unable to return to the field and will be assessed during the week. Tom Langdon (right knee) should be right to face the Roos. Mason Cox should be in the frame to return after being a late withdrawal with hamstring tightness....1Qtr

Collingwood: Darcy Moore was late withdrawal with hamstring soreness just 15 minutes before the opening bounce. After the game, Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley said the club would not know the severity of Moore's injury for another 48 hours.... 0 Qtr

Collingwood: Matt Scharenberg was the big one for the Pies. A simple change of direction in the fourth quarter saw the 22-year-old's left knee buckle, with scans expected to confirm the need for a reconstruction. Meanwhile, Jeremy Howe didn't play after quarter-time following a friendly-fire collision with Darcy Moore. Moore's knee hit Howe's forehead flush, which left the defender with concussion. He'll be tested throughout the week, as will Brody Mihocek, who played out the game with a sore ankle. ... 3Qtrs

Collingwood: Darcy Moore suffered a hamstring injury and played no part in the second half.... 2 Qtrs

 

[El cane]

I reckon Sidey rushed his long kick at goal with seconds to go. Appeared like he could have run to 50 to have a proper shot. Did the same thing in the first quarter too. I bet he wishes he could have that shot again.

 

[Roverjg]

Those developing players stepping up to the next level has definitely been the catalyst to our improvement.

Grundy is equal with Gawn as the best ruck in the comp. No doubt about it. Both have their strengths and weaknesses though.

WHE probably the most accurate set shot for goal in the comp. Next to Josh caddy. Underrated player.

JT has gone from a banned player with a questionable future to someone who contributes every week and pops up for a sneaky goal or 4 occasionally.

JDG is very close to being elite. His running power is amazing. When he's at full speed he's lightning quick.

Combine that with the Stephenson rotation we had going on in the forward line between JDG/Stevo and both of them at top speed are seriously damaging over time to the opposition defenders.
Stephenson has been so important playing a great first year and him breaking some games open has been vital.

Cox is integral to our structure.

Defence held up well at full strength. Maynard good. Scharenberg and Dunn very good before injuries.


A bright future ahead if we can get these players on the park more often.

I agree that Cox has been great for our structure this year, but after watching last nights game I think it is the two talls in our forward line that is integral to our structure. When Cox was out injured against WCE we fell apart with only one tall. We looked good with the two talls until Moore was injured and Miochek had to go back. Our structure fell down with the sole tall.

 

[Jonno94]

I reckon Sidey rushed his long kick at goal with seconds to go. Appeared like he could have run to 50 to have a proper shot. Did the same thing in the first quarter too. I bet he wishes he could have that shot again.

He had the game in his hands in that moment and blew it, had options running into 50 as well.

 

[TKiL]

And in his interview at the airport he looks totally jack of it and not like someone wanting to stay.

Looked and sounded completely uninterested

 

[TradeDraft]

I agree that Cox has been great for our structure this year, but after watching last nights game I think it is the two talls in our forward line that is integral to our structure. When Cox was out injured against WCE we fell apart with only one tall. We looked good with the two talls until Moore was injured and Miochek had to go back. Our structure fell down with the sole tall.

Did sure look like it. Mihocheck went back and Structure went to Hell

 

[Roverjg]

In my earlier post I detailed our injury list during Buck's Tenure. I now highlight our injury list over the 2017/2018 in comparison to the Tigers.

2017
Saw 5 Pies play every game (22) – Adams, Crisp, WHE, Maynard & Sidey. Moore put together his best season (played 21 games) following two years of persistent injuries. We recruited Wells via FA and he booked straight into the Medico’s room.
Varcoe missed 14 games
Scharenberg and Wells each missed 12 games
Langdon missed 11 games
Sinclair missed 9 games
Broomhead & De Goey both missed 8 games
Reid missed 7 games
Greenwood & Pendles both missed 6 games
Elliott missed 5 games

2018
This year we have had 7 Pies play all the games to date (19) – Crisp, Grundy, Phillips, Sidey, Thomas, WHE and Stephenson
Broomhead, Elliott and Fasolo have missed 19 games. Did not count the 10 minutes Fasolo & Broomy played)
Wells has missed 15 weeks
Aish, Moore and Reid have each missed 13 games
Greenwood has missed 10 weeks
Treloar and Varcoe have both missed 6 games
Dunn has missed 5 games but will be out for the foreseeable future
De Goey has missed 5 games
Maynard has missed 4 games
Langdon has missed 4 games
Appleby has missed 3 games
Cox, Howe & Scharenberg have each missed 2 games however Scharenberg will be out for the next 12 months

Richmond
Tigers had 9 players play all 25 games (Astbury, Castagna, Cotchin, Ellis Grigg, Grimes, Martin, Rance & Rioli) & 6 players play 24 games
2017:
Vlastuin missed 7 games
Houli & Short missed 4 games
Caddy, Edwards & Prestia missed 3 games
Riewoldt missed 2 games

2018:
Tigers have had 7 players play all games to date (Edwards, Grimes, Lambert, Nankervis, Rance, Riewoldt, Short). Astbury, Castagna, Cotchin, Grigg & Martin have missed one game
Rioli has missed 11 games
Prestia has missed 10 games
Houli has missed 9 games
Ellis has missed 4 games
Caddy has missed 2 games

 

[nahnah]

My Dad said on News said Swans last goal was Touched

unless it was touched off the boot it wasnt touched, the ball had well passed the line before Phillips got to it. Costly mistake not having someone on the goal line.