Opinion Heath Shaw return

[CFC2010]

I will cry tears of joy if he comes back. Then i will have to change my user name!

Just have to change it to HeathComesBack.......simple.

 

[jmac70]

i dont think he will come back, I think he will fit in somewhere but its too late for us. I would love him as a coach though. Rhys won assistant coach of the year. I reckon despite his idiosyncrasies he would be an awesome coach

Never say never. Maxy is back and Heater could well follow him.

 

[frizzle]

Never say never. Maxy is back and Heater could well follow him.

Maxy didn't have a falling out with Bucks. Heater did.

 

[MagpieJoel]

Never say never. Maxy is back and Heater could well follow him.

Not going to happen.

 

[HFF]

Hell no!

This has worked out beautifully for us for a change whereby Adams for Shaw was a great result.

He's finished.
You can see he's slowed down big time.
He's volatile behaviour is also not required.

 

[Dynamics]

Shaw is finished in big games. He'll get the footy in crappy h&a games by playing off his man bur he cant beat the better players anymore. He also cant handle pressure around a contest.

We now get the better end of the Adams trade with 6-7 years left.

Indeed we do.

In a sense it was a win/win trade as they got plenty of good footy out of Heater and the change did him good. The issue for GWS is that they didn't make a GF with him and he was clearly on the decline this year. Whereas we will have Adams for years to come. Some on here question Adams but I really rate him for his strength, ball winning and intensity. Just wish he was left in the middle permanently.

 

[jmac70]

Maxy didn't have a falling out with Bucks. Heater did.

Bridges can be easily mended

 

[Smoky]

He's volatile behaviour is also not required.

His on field passion is exactly what we could do with.

 

[TW Sherrin]

the end has come quick.

 

[TW Sherrin]

I will cry tears of joy if he comes back. Then i will have to change my user name!

my tears will be of a different kind.

 

[westozpie]

Um... NO!!! We are forever grateful for what he did in the granny but he's done. Do we really want him going of his tree at teammates because he thinks only he knows what's right.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Giants have said he isn't going anywhere via twitter.

Close thread.

 

[jathanas]

His relationship with he who coaches is broken beyond repair... as stated by Heater himself.

In my view he should never have gone but he isn't what we need right now. A return would have more sentimental value then practical value IMO.

I love the crazy bastard, always have, always will.

 

[Kilmo]

He's signed on for two more years at GWS

 

[Anzacday]

Maybe GWS said consider your options when looking at holiday destinations.

 

[CFC2010]

He's signed on for two more years at GWS

You can keep your user name now HeathComeBack

 

[Roverjg]

GWS have refuted comments by AFL Trade Radio and have advised Shaw is contracted for 2018 and he is a required player

 

[jatsad]

No more oldies.

Don't care who they are.

Trade young or draft.

 

[TradeDraft]

Shaw is about Finished and he won't come play for Bucks

 

[davywap]

This business about Ablett going back to Geelong has got me thinking about our Heater, and a possible return to Collingwood. I believe his contract at GWS ends at the end of next season. He will be 33 in 2019. He loves the Pies and might just consider a return if the coach has changed. Would you have him back?

**** NO, don't need him ****ing everything up

 

[Morganashlee]

Thread needs a poll with the following options

a) No
b) **** no
c) I love Heath but, no
d) Did you see his prelim effort? NO.

 

[JB1975]

Bridges can be easily mended

Not sure that bridge could be re-built, even if you had Gandhi working from one side and Martin Luther King on the other.

 

[TradeDraft]

Recruiting Heath Shaw makes as much sense as getting Chris Dawes back to the club.

Actually Dawes had a fair season with Sorrento for what it's worth. Another premiership medal to go with his one for the pies.

Dawes would make more sense then Heater Coming Back

 

[Anzacday]

Thread needs a poll with the following options

a) No
b) **** no
c) I love Heath but, no
d) Did you see his prelim effort? NO.

Pfft, you're assuming we care what you think.

 

[left at home]

Ah, no thank you