hedgehog's complete phantom draft v.2 (with explanations)

[hendo8888]

Would be pretty happy with this.
Bartlett, JM-P, Wanganeen and Kurtz/Sumner would be a great draft for the crows.

 

[peggles]

Much obliged.

If I were to critique ours:

Richmond

3. Richmond - Dustin Martin
19. Richmond - Ben Griffiths
35. Richmond - Alex Carey
44. Richmond - Josh Donaldson
51. Richmond - Daniel Menzel
67. Richmond - Sam Shaw
71. Richmond - Serhat Temel
78. Richmond – Pass
89. Richmond - Pass

I would, from the players you noted were still available then, replace Donaldson with Houghton, Menzel with Harwood and Shaw with Sumner (if McNeill not still about)

Giving us:

Dustin Martin
Ben Griffiths (though would go Stevens if available)
Alex Carey
Joel Houghton
Ryan Harwood
Byron Sumner
Serhat Tehmel
+1 PSD

and giving me great delight.

Cheers and thanks

i thought the same regarding harwood. if still available at our 5th pick definitely take him.

great work uptheguts. that would be a superb draft for us.

 

[bards]

Good Effort, I am too lazy to even attempt it. You have the Hawks taking a couple of ruckman, including one at their first pick. I think they will take ruckman, but they need one that is ready. Maz Gawn at 206cm is an excellent prospect, but I doubt he can be ready at 18 to play in the ruck in round 2 if Taylor or Renouf go down. If he is a one or two year prospect, he is less needed, based on Bailey eventually getting back. They will take a young ruck, but later, maybe even a rookie. They will fill the ruck whole with a mature aged player (could be a recycled spud), purely as a back up. You picked 2 inside mids for us, but we need outside mids. We have Sewell, Mitchell, Lewis, and Hodge inside. Hopefully the hawks grab some outside mids instead.

Anyhow, great effort, I wouldnt know where to start.