Hill and Stack want out

[scooter600x]

Josh has some burnt bridges at West Coast dating back to his U18 national champs year.

WC is one club we won't be trading him to.

 

[Mofra]

Josh has some burnt bridges at West Coast dating back to his U18 national champs year.

WC is one club we won't be trading him to.

One player manager believed it was a done deal (over a week ago) however it seems that cold water has been poured over the deal.

Carlton will be central players this trading period and they are notoriously bad to deal with.

 

[Bodicifer]

Interesting to see if they turn up to the B+F. I can remember attending one year and talking to the pornstar himself, Jordan "Ron Jeremy" McMahon. It was weird in that setting in the knowledge we all knew he wouldn't be at the kennel the following season, including obviously himself.

 

[fronkalicious]

I want picks for Hill & Stack, not players from WCE.....We need at least one late pick to take Faulks, and none of the WCE players mentioned are any good at all. May also need the later round picks to finalise other deals for Everitt, Veszpremi etc.

Given it sounds we're moving a late pick for Djeukerra, and have our 1st and 2nd rounders tied up on the FS lads, we're goingt to be a bit short on live picks in the draft. Id still like a couple. Happy to move the Harbrow pick for Jetta too, but definitely not Walker.

 

[stefoid]

We will get a 4th or something from WC for Stack, wont we?

 

[topdog]

We will get a 4th or something from WC for Stack, wont we?

The only time WC will give us a 4th round pick for Stack is, if they weren't going to use it any way. Which is also very likely

 

[Hard Ball Get]

I'd be very uncomfortable if we lost both Hill and Everitt. Both are capable of being very good players.

This.
Especially Everitt

 

[junior27]

Here is a 3 way trade proposal to discuss....

Beau Dowler and Rick Ladson to Carlton, Andrew Walker, and Hawthorns 3rd round pick to Bulldogs, Andrejs Everitt and Josh Hill to Hawthorn.

Sounds pretty reasonable to me but I'd be happy to discuss

 

[doggies ftw]

I dont know, I wouldnt mind it but I really dont want to lose Everitt, I think Eade would take it though!

 

[scooter600x]

Here is a 3 way trade proposal to discuss....

Beau Dowler and Rick Ladson to Carlton, Andrew Walker, and Hawthorns 3rd round pick to Bulldogs, Andrejs Everitt and Josh Hill to Hawthorn.

Sounds pretty reasonable to me but I'd be happy to discuss

Dowler will be delisted and Ladson is a VFL player at best, Brett Ratten wouldn't take the time to answer that one.

I would want more than Walker and a pick in the late 50's for Everitt and Hill as well.

Happy to trade Everitt and Hill and would almost accept Walker and pick 37-ish (Haw 2nd round), just. Would hope for better trading them seperately.

 

[ArNcHiSe]

stack and hill to west coast?

with stack and hill wanting to go back to perth and with spangher and mckinley wanting to come back to melbourne, maybe we can do a straight up swap for those two. both players a under 25 and could fill the role we need. we could also then trade everitt to brisbane for sherman if possible. so what do you guys think?

 

[SBI]

Re: stack and hill to west coast?

I seriously don't see how Spangher or McKinley fill a role for us. I mean I could play as a small forward, but it doesn't mean I'd do the job for us either.

 

[Dogs_r_barking]

Re: stack and hill to west coast?

McKinley is norf bound.

 

[dogwatch]

Re: stack and hill to west coast?

What's wrong with using this thread:

"Hill and Stack want out"
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=760210&page=9

 

[OldSchool]

Re: stack and hill to west coast?

What's wrong with using this thread:

"Hill and Stack want out"
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=760210&page=9

I have merged them together.
It was only a couple of threads from the top so I don't know how it was missed.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Re: stack and hill to west coast?

On merging threads,
it always bugs me that the new thread title is used. Why isn't it the original? Is that just the way it is or is it just easier to chuck them together that way?

EDIT:
Nevermind... I looked at the bold part at the top of the post box not the thread title... obviously you can change which thread is merged into the other.

 

[scooter600x]

Re: stack and hill to west coast?

I seriously don't see how Spangher or McKinley fill a role for us. I mean I could play as a small forward, but it doesn't mean I'd do the job for us either.

Don't forget that the player has to agree to a trade.

Why would Sprangher agree to come to a club where his main role would be cleaning Lake, Morris and Williams' boots?

 

[ArNcHiSe]

Re: stack and hill to west coast?

I seriously don't see how Spangher or McKinley fill a role for us. I mean I could play as a small forward, but it doesn't mean I'd do the job for us either.

i saw spangher play alot this year and he can easily step up into the backline so easily and let lake go foreward full time.

 

[SBI]

Re: stack and hill to west coast?

Why do we want Lake to go forward full time? He's one of the best full backs in the league, and only an average forward in bursts. Would be hurting our team more than helping him to take him from the backline.

 

[maddog37]

Bump.

Lots of talk about hill so far.


Absolutely nothing about stack yet........

Anyone? Bueller? Bueller?


Ps. Good call from dogs r barking about McKinley to north on October 3rd.

 

[Nath09]

McKinley to North for pick 86...

 

[Werewolf]

McKinley to North for pick 86...

Absolute steal IMO. With just over a day to go, is there any word on Stack?

 

[The Coon Dog]

Absolute steal IMO. With just over a day to go, is there any word on Stack?

No one's interested in giving up anything to get Brennan Stack.

The best he can hope for is the Dogs & Eagles to look at him as a welfare project with one delisting him & the other undertaking to pick him up in the rookie draft.