Opinion Historical Best Teams with a Theme

[Kane McGoodwin]

Best 22 Traded In including Free Agents
B: Brown, Caven, Bassett
HB: Massie, M Stevens, Torney
C: Seedsman, McLeod, Connell
HF: Lynch, Robran, Bond
F: Betts, Carey, Welsh
R: Jacobs, D Jarman, Thompson
I: Jenkins, Koster, James, Bode

Vs

Best 22 Traded Out including Free Agents
B: Wellman, Davis, Lever
HB: McKinnon, Bock, Mattner
C: Knights, Dangerfield, Vince
HF: Vardy, Tippett, Gunston
F: McGovern, Modra, Cameron
R: Rehn, Stenglein, Johnston
I: Maric, Lyons, Greenwood, Wright

 

[Thetrader15]

Best 22 Traded In including Free Agents
B: Brown, Caven, Bassett
HB: Massie, M Stevens, Torney
C: Seedsman, McLeod, Connell
HF: Lynch, Robran, Bond
F: Betts, Carey, Welsh
R: Jacobs, D Jarman, Thompson
I: Jenkins, Koster, James, Bode

Vs

Best 22 Traded Out including Free Agents
B: Wellman, Davis, Lever
HB: McKinnon, Bock, Mattner
C: Knights, Dangerfield, Vince
HF: Vardy, Tippett, Gunston
F: McGovern, Modra, Cameron
R: Rehn, Stenglein, Johnston
I: Maric, Lyons, Greenwood, Wright

No place for Betts in the teaded out team?

 

[Mego Red]

No place for Betts in the teaded out team?

Not sure he can play for both teams!

 

[Scorpus]

Best 22 Traded In including Free Agents
B: Brown, Caven, Bassett
HB: Massie, M Stevens, Torney
C: Seedsman, McLeod, Connell
HF: Lynch, Robran, Bond
F: Betts, Carey, Welsh
R: Jacobs, D Jarman, Thompson
I: Jenkins, Koster, James, Bode

Vs

Best 22 Traded Out including Free Agents
B: Wellman, Davis, Lever
HB: McKinnon, Bock, Mattner
C: Knights, Dangerfield, Vince
HF: Vardy, Tippett, Gunston
F: McGovern, Modra, Cameron
R: Rehn, Stenglein, Johnston
I: Maric, Lyons, Greenwood, Wright

Traded out team would absolutely demolish the traded in team

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Traded out team would absolutely demolish the traded in team

Traded in has more premiership players though.

 

[Thetrader15]

Not sure he can play for both teams!

Why, are they playing against each other?

 

[Thetrader15]

Traded out team would absolutely demolish the traded in team

I don't know, if we have each pmayer at their peak it would be close...Carey, McLeod, DJ.

Do McGuinness, Greg Anderson and Tony Hall count as trade in players?

 

[Thetrader15]

Best team of lefties:

FF Bode Perrie Greenwood
HF Knights Ingerson Atkins
C Anderson M Crouch Schwerdt
HB McKinnon Keath Mattner
FB Bassett Caven Kelly
Ruck: Mickan Goodwin McGuinness
Bench: Hudson Burns Murphy Grigg

 

[Scorpus]

Best Team of AFC Players Who Were Rookie Picks

B Bassett - Rutten - Doughty
HB Laird - Bock - Mattner
C Henderson - B. Martin - Jaensch
HF Wright - Podsiadly - Cameron
F Porplyzia - Jenkins - Murphy
R Jacobs - E. Curnow - Greenwood

I Petrenko - O'Brien - Kelly - Keath

 

[Thetrader15]

Best team of SA v Vic (classified those outside of SA/Vic as one or the other (e.g. McLeod)

SA:
FF Betts Modra D Jarman
HF Edwards Walker McLeod
C Goodwin Smith Vince
HB Bickley Rutten Laird
FB Johncock Smart Hart
Rucks: Rehn Riccuito McGuinness
Bench: Vardy Burton Laird Doughty

Vic:
FF Gunston Tippett Jenkins
HF Sloane Carey Lynch
C Van Berlo Dangerfield K Johnson
HB Reilly Caven Stengein
FB Lever Talia Massie
Rucks: Hudson B Crouch M Crouch
Bench: Douglas Torney McGovern Atkins

 

[radiojake]

Best team of players who finished their Crows career with a losing record

B: Tasker McCartney Wellman
HB Jaensch Pittman Ellen
C: Connell A.Jarman Anderson
HF: Liptak Carey D. Brown
F: Petrenko Modra Hall
R: Mickan McDermott McGuinness
Int Podsiadley Thiessen Marshall Klug

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

State of Origin

SA
B: Hart, Rutten, Johncock
HB: Smart, Bock, Laird
C: Anderson, Ricciuto, Goodwin
HF: D Jarman, Robran, Burton
F: Welsh, Modra, Edwards
R: Rehn, McDermott, Thompson
I: Smith, Bickley, McGuiness, Porplyzia

VIC
B: Otten, Talia, Lee
HB: Reilly, Caven, Massie
C: Johnston, Mrouch, Sloane
HF: Knights, M Stevens, Lynch
F: Gunston, Jenkins, Betts
R Maric, Dangerfield, Brouch
I: S Stevens, Douglas, Seedsman, Ellen

 

[Bovo]

Best 22 Traded In including Free Agents
B: Brown, Caven, Bassett
HB: Massie, M Stevens, Torney
C: Seedsman, McLeod, Connell
HF: Lynch, Robran, Bond
F: Betts, Carey, Welsh
R: Jacobs, D Jarman, Thompson
I: Jenkins, Koster, James, Bode

Vs

Best 22 Traded Out including Free Agents
B: Wellman, Davis, Lever
HB: McKinnon, Bock, Mattner
C: Knights, Dangerfield, Vince
HF: Vardy, Tippett, Gunston
F: McGovern, Modra, Cameron
R: Rehn, Stenglein, Johnston
I: Maric, Lyons, Greenwood, Wright

I would swap Wright for Vardy

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I would swap Wright for Vardy

They are both in the side.

 

[Bovo]

What about best 22 that never made more th

They are both in the side.

whoops!

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Glenelg Players
B: Viska, Jameson, Tasker
HB: R Thompson, Bartlett, Koster
C: Marshall, McDermott, Rouvray
HF: Lamb, Fogarty, Liptak
F: Bode, M Murphy, Hall
R: Herbert, Gibbs, McGuiness
I: Hinge, Sellar, Byrne, S Cook

Excluded non-SA draftees who played for Glenelg prior to the Crows Sanfl.
Johnston
Douglas
Angwin
Picioane

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

West Adelaide
B: Jericho, Rutten, Laird
HB: Howard, Patterson, Lamb
C: Fielke, Ricciuto, Beech
HF: Lindner, A Richardson, Welsh
F: Hocking, Modra, Marsh
R: Rehn, Porplyzia, Edwards
I: Micken, Schmidt

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

North Adelaide
B: B Hart, Tasker, Wellman
HB: Turner, Davis, Wintle
C: Atkinson, A Jarman, T Cook
HF: Wright, Carey, Saliba
F: Ladhams, Gill, L Johnston
R: Herbert, D Jarman, D Hart
I: Mail, Howard

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

WWT
B: Crowell, McGregor, Petrenko
HB: Smith, Bock, Lindsay
C: Payze, Ellis-Yolmen, Weiderman
HF: Knight, Klug, Burton
F: Skipworth, Biglands, Kluzek
R: Negri, Vince, Shirley
I: Pesch, Schoenberg, Cicolella

 

[Thetrader15]

Best skinny team
FF Marsh Schell Griffin
HF Menzel S Stevens Thiessen
C McKay (C) Burton Tregenza
HB Symes Lever Henderson
FB Hart Doedee Armstrong
R Rehn Van Berlo Vince

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Norwood
B: L Brown, Warhurst, Bown
HB: Bassett, Maynard, M Kelly
C: Theissen, A Jarman, J Gallagher
HF: Campbell, Robran, Grigg
F: Jericho, Ross, L Johnston
R: Pittman, James, Rowe
I: Keating, S Cook

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Best skinny team
FF Marsh Schell Griffin
HF Menzel S Stevens Thiessen
C McKay (C) Burton Tregenza
HB Symes Lever Henderson
FB Hart Doedee Armstrong
R Rehn Van Berlo Vince

Jericho & Troy Bond unlucky...

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

South Adelaide
B: Torney, Smart, X
HB: Powell, Groom, X
C: Doughty, Goodwin, X
HF: Sampson, Bone, X
F: Fitzgerald, P McIntyre, X
R: Clarke, Koster, Bickley

South haven't been such a big provider to the Crows compared to other Sanfl clubs...

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Centrals
B: Lee, X, X
HB: McKinnon, Ingerson, X
C: Milera, X, Schwerdt,
HF: T Cook, Schell, Vardy
F: Tongerie, Menzel, Hocking
R: X, Hart, Callinan

Few gaps for Centrals too...

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Sturt
Miserable to put together a side...

B: Jaensch, Tasker, X
HB: Begley, Hinge, Mattner
C: L Stevens, Martin, Wilson
HF: Sanderson, X, X
F: T McIntyre, X, X
R: X, Nelson, Atkinson