Hogan worth

[Belnakor]

surely this is all predicated upon Neale goin g to Brisbane first?

we basically have pick 6 thats it without him going, so yeah if we want Hogan we need to drop Neale.

 

[Midnite65]

With all of the top 10 this year draft wise from the East I think we are going to be prepared to deal away any high picks we have. Even if we picked up two guns with a 5 and 6 do we really want to hear every year about them going home, wasn't it bad enough with Cerra this year? This is the first legitimate KPF that may want to come to us in years so we won't be saying no.

 

[Wigarus]

The last time we tried to get a key forward from Melbourne, he said on our website he wanted to come home and then he went to Brisbane for the money.


trade week hasn't even started yet jeepers

 

[yoong]

I suspect Melbourne is interested and semi nudging Hogan our way as they see we may potentially have 2 high picks from our impending Neale trade.
I’ll be curious are to see if they are willing to deal if Hogan nominated us but Neale decided to stay. Will they take the 6 + something else if pick 5 is not in the picture?

 

[Clems Knee]

The last time we tried to get a key forward from Melbourne, he said on our website he wanted to come home and then he went to Brisbane for the money.


trade week hasn't even started yet jeepers

Hmmmm.

 

[Dirty_banchez]

Why do we need so many threads? We only need a List Management, Draft, and Hypothetical trade threads.

 

[mayne iac]

Because it is Hogan, just pick the threads you want to read and read them. It aint that hard.

 

[Purpellian Anchor]

Five cartons of full strength, 50 ham sandwiches, 200 meat pies, a ride each week in Fyfe's chopper, and our 2019, 20 and 21 1st.
With Hogan lifting us up to top of the ladder no 1 at the end of each year it will be pick 18 times 3. Alternatively we could be 3 times last being 3 - 1st's if we finish last in each year....but we should get an early pick comp. LOL

 

[Rion]

5 & 6/future first would be mighty dumb. We're still deep in a rebuild and need to rely heavily on the potential of high end picks to lift us out of it.

 

[go_the_dockers]

I personally am happy to offer 6, 2019 1st round pick for 35, 2019 2nd round pick and Hogan.

 

[TheLastCall]

I personally am happy to offer 6, 2019 1st round pick for 35, 2019 2nd round pick and Hogan.

This is about right.

 

[basashi]

I can't wait for his first screwup so I can clench my fist and shout "Hoooogan!" in a stage German accent.

 

[Rob]

Neale stays IMO, I can’t see how a newly married player with a Perth partner who owns a business is going anywhere.

Get your head out of the sand, Neale is gone.

If we can get Hogan for Neale then it's a fair outcome for us.

 

[Dockernut]

We're still rebuilding, not having at least one high pick would be a terrible result. Even if we have to trade a future first I'd do it if it meant we hung on to 5 or 6 or whatever it is this year. I don't think we'll roll over though, even if it is Hogan.

Hope not, but you never know. Rosich may go full Schwabb to get a few more bums on seats.

 

[rgauci]

Get your head out of the sand, Neale is gone.

If we can get Hogan for Neale then it's a fair outcome for us.

We’ll see. Care to put a little wager on that?

 

[88mph]

Trading our first pick for another injured player?

Our SC guys haven't got the best record, too risky imo.

Use the pick on the best available.

 

[wayToGo_]

Hogan on one foot would still be our best KPF

 

[clivenator26]

We’ll see. Care to put a little wager on that?

I will - $50

 

[holy diver]

We’ll see. Care to put a little wager on that?

I'll take that action. PM me. Neale is gone. I'll go $100 if you like.

 

[mightymouse75]

Melbourne arent too concerned. What does that tell you ? Dont need to sell the farm.

 

[rgauci]

I will - $50

I'll take that action. PM me. Neale is gone. I'll go $100 if you like.

Just waiting to hear back from the original person. Then I’ll get to you both, but I’m not taking wagers against the whole board.

Ok, I’ll take 50 bet from each of you.

 

[Del183359]

If Neale was staying, I can see no reason why he would delay in making the announcement. Besides wouldn’t he have a responsibility to let the club know well in advance of the draft so they can formulate the logic behind their selections or am I missing something?

 

[Okinakashi]

or am I missing something?

Don't think so. He still hasn't made up his mind

 

[TheLastCall]

Don't think so. He still hasn't made up his mind

He'll announce tomorrow after the Doig tonight. Probably let his closest friends know tonight.

 

[wayToGo_]

He'll announce tomorrow after the Doig tonight. Probably let his closest friends know tonight.

No wonder he's annoyed and leaving, we've told him the wrong night to come and receive his Doig medal.