- Joined
- Jun 8, 2007
- Posts
- 16,904
- Likes
- 27,541
- Location
- MAdelaide
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- I'm a lover, not a fighter
Thread starter
#1
Just a question to really put us in perspective here:
Given whatever spot they fill in the team (full forward, ruck, etc), how many of our current players would get into that Brisbane team of invincibility? Forget about game-plan - obviously ours is different from theirs... I'm just talking on talent.
Raph would never get a game, forward or back, in the Lions '03. Kosi would not. Roo would. Hayes would. The resurrected mummy (Ball) would. Harvey would. Max, I would argue, would. There's more, but you get the idea...
There's plenty of other names we can argue about. The point is, i think this might be a helpful way of thinking about do we have the cattle it takes to win a premiership?
Given whatever spot they fill in the team (full forward, ruck, etc), how many of our current players would get into that Brisbane team of invincibility? Forget about game-plan - obviously ours is different from theirs... I'm just talking on talent.
Raph would never get a game, forward or back, in the Lions '03. Kosi would not. Roo would. Hayes would. The resurrected mummy (Ball) would. Harvey would. Max, I would argue, would. There's more, but you get the idea...
There's plenty of other names we can argue about. The point is, i think this might be a helpful way of thinking about do we have the cattle it takes to win a premiership?

