Whatever he gets, they should deduct 3. Carr's been asking for it for years.
How many weeks Brennan?
- Thread starter SirJimi05
- Start date
- Tagged users None
One week for an act that is shunned in a street fight. What a joke.
Cousin Jed
Retired President of BigFooty
How is it flawed? 1st time offenders get off lighter.
If he does it again he'll get a month.
There is nothing absurd about the system.
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
Discounts for having a good prior record are laughable. Discounts for an early plea are even more laughable. Neither actions reduce the severity of what the player did. There should be additional points for bad records, meaning that there is still incentive to not have a bad record (ie have a good record) but no discounts for not having previous reports.
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
Why should you get 2 less weeks for it being a first time offence and an early plea? Neither of them change the action which was a dog act, regardless of what jokes you make about Josh Carr.
Cousin Jed
Retired President of BigFooty
Its how almost every system of law works over the land. Don't like it, move to the Middle East.
I hope you aren't referring to me about the Josh Carr jokes too.
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
Nah not refering to you. I find them funny anyway but they aren't relevent.
Pretty ignorant post re the Middle East though. Pretty poor form mate.
Pretty ignorant post re the Middle East though. Pretty poor form mate.
What a disgrace
Josh Carr is the last footballer I would stand up for but this is just terrible
Josh Carr is the last footballer I would stand up for but this is just terrible
melbournemartin
Brownlow Medallist
I guess Hall on Staker would be heavy impact but such an occurance is a bit of an outlier for the current points system. Can anyone else remember some "heavy impacts"?
Hollow Knight
Imperfect vessel
- May 3, 2005
- 96,471
- 106,625
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Scuderia Ferrari, Dallas Cowboys
Please tell me this was a joke post.
Please.
You really think that headbut was delivered with heavy force? Heavy impact would have put Carr down and out.
Did the tribunal take into account the elbow-shove on Carr with the ball 25 metres away when he was lying on the ground some 3 minutes before this headbutt?
Watch the video, 30 seconds into the last quarter.
Clearly a pre-meditated headbutt by Brennan - shame on the AFL for not making an example of him.
Watch the video, 30 seconds into the last quarter.
Clearly a pre-meditated headbutt by Brennan - shame on the AFL for not making an example of him.
Yeah....that's the way responsible administrators work - throw the penalty that the rules prescribe out of the window at a moment's notice.
Mr Unrealistic
Debutant
Apparrently Wikipedia have a thought on it as well
i wonder if cue ball the runner got a please explain from the afl. i reckon cue ball will get his lights punched out one day
Apparrently Wikipedia have a thought on it as well
I cannot stop laughing.
Thanks for that.
Why don't the AFL have the balls to ban him?
A please explain for what?
Yep, and I enjoyed it as much as the next Port supporter.
Are there any rules saying he can't carry on like that? I have no idea?
PowerForGood; said:
Ridiculous.
If Brennan meticulously plotted and planned to take Carr out with a headbutt, he didn't do a very good job did he?
I mean, your assertion is tantamount to a henchman planning a grizzly murder and then ending up shooting the intended victim in the big toe.
