How many weeks for Caddy?

[1990crow]

Yes, trying to hit the ball, missed and got the head. Free kick every day of the week. Do you think he was trying to hit the guy and take him out? Didn’t look like that to me when watching it real time, but I could be wrong.

100% he tried to collect Mackay. And he succeeded.

 

[zacaxel1975]

100% he tried to collect Mackay. And he succeeded.

So similar to Toby Greene last year against the dogs player? Why only a week then because the outcome was much worse.

 

[Great8]

100% he tried to collect Mackay. And he succeeded.

Surely if you wanted to take a player out you wouldn’t slap them but instead use a clenched fist?

 

[Great8]

Really felt Rance should have been fined for staging. Thought that was real poor and needs to be stamped out

 

[1990crow]

Really felt Rance should have been fined for staging. Thought that was real poor and needs to be stamped out

He’s a serial offender too.

 

[maskmcgee]

clearly 0

 

[Marcus DuQuesne]

Was a little pay back thing for an earlier incident ...well disguised but should get a week.

 

[Marcus DuQuesne]

Surely if you wanted to take a player out you wouldn’t slap them but instead use a clenched fist?

That's the point did not want to take him out just wanted to give a gentle reminder...looked like a payback for earlier incident...1 week move on.

 

[MattyB_76]

Surely if you wanted to take a player out you wouldn’t slap them but instead use a clenched fist?

Who gives a shit what you do with your hand when you hit them with your forearm?

 

[HTT]

Christian is a joke. A week for Douglas, a week for Caddy, everyone gets a week. Reckless in going for the footy, deserves a warning & a fine to say "just scale it back a bit". Sure, if he does the same thing again this week - give him a week.

 

[1990crow]

Christian is a joke. A week for Douglas, a week for Caddy, everyone gets a week. Reckless in going for the footy, deserves a warning & a fine to say "just scale it back a bit". Sure, if he does the same thing again this week - give him a week.

All I hear is a lot of whining.

 

[HTT]

All I hear is a lot of whining.

Sorry, some of that stuff coming out of the crowies over summer must've rubbed off.

 

[Struggle]

Another situation where the outcome is more important than the action. Classic mrp. Should be a fine at worst

 

[Farm Boy]

Another situation where the outcome is more important than the action. Classic mrp. Should be a fine at worst

A fine would be too harsh. There was nothing in it.

 

[HairyO]

100% he tried to collect Mackay. And he succeeded.

No he didnt. It was reckless. He was going to spoil but should have known better to swing his arm like that.

It deserved a week and got a week.

The AFL have finally decided to be serious and consistent about head hits. I assume the lawyers have warned them there could be dozens of multi million dollar lawsuits like the NFL if they dont take it seriously.

Of course lets see what happens after Round 20 when big names have a couple of fines, or have done something which for the previous 20 rounds has been a week.