- Banned
- #51
Would have thought that these would be the same type of people who would rather Sydney win a premiership than anyone else just because it’s a NSW team? Even as a success I’m not sure if there would be a real rivalry
How the AFL lost the battle for Sydney
- Thread starter Deadly Assassin
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Would have thought that these would be the same type of people who would rather Sydney win a premiership than anyone else just because it’s a NSW team? Even as a success I’m not sure if there would be a real rivalry
The AFL can certainly win certain areas of Sydney, preferably the cashed up ones... Let the bogan areas follow NRL.
What sort of crowds does your average NRL home and away game get?
- Oct 19, 2017
- 559
- 1,066
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Jul 5, 2012
- 24,745
- 40,163
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Kidding, right?
True. A lot of my Swans-following mates are totally into the Swans. But unlike me, they’re also totally into the Wallabies.
I’m not sure a comparable phenomenon exists in the footy states.
- Jul 5, 2012
- 24,745
- 40,163
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Kidding, right?
Good post!
Oscarman
Norm Smith Medallist
Veteran
Melbourne Demons - Jake Lever Player Sponsor 2018
Melbourne Demons - Katherine Smith AFLW Player Sponsor 2018
Melbourne Demons - Ben Kennedy Player Sponsor 2017
Melbourne Demons - Katherine Smith AFLW Player Sponsor 2017
Zombie Lover
SuperCoach Leagues Winners - BigFooty Division 1
Melbourne Demons - Ben Kennedy Player Sponsor 2016
Cos a lot of Vic based AFL fans think they have to destroy the NRL. Will never happen.
RocketBooster
Debutant
Support for the Swans is strong and increases year by year. A well run club with sustained on field success and in touch with their supporter base. The Swans are the #1 team across all the codes for support around the City/inner west / Northern Sydney areas
GWS support in Sydney has peaked and they will struggle to gain even minimal extra support in Western Sydney for the next 10-15 years.
GWS needs a couple of academy players who radiate the star power of Buddy Franklin and play for a decade. A story arc of having played League in their youth would be a bonus.
Until that can happen GWS will struggle to gain further meaningful western sydney area support.
GWS support in Sydney has peaked and they will struggle to gain even minimal extra support in Western Sydney for the next 10-15 years.
GWS needs a couple of academy players who radiate the star power of Buddy Franklin and play for a decade. A story arc of having played League in their youth would be a bonus.
Until that can happen GWS will struggle to gain further meaningful western sydney area support.
Thanks
Those averages seem healthier across the board than say 10 years ago
This reminds me of the arguments AFL fans have on here over who has the bigger membership or "XXXX is now part of the big four clubs". Same as the AFL and media bragging about the size of the new media deal.
It's just a pointless pissing contest that has no impact on the enjoyment of watching the game. It's ego at the top of the sports, but most people couldn't care at all, and the amount of revenue the game has doesn't seem to flow down to the fans or local footy. I'm involved in a junior football club and we pay the AFL a fee for each player, not much comes back.
It's just a pointless pissing contest that has no impact on the enjoyment of watching the game. It's ego at the top of the sports, but most people couldn't care at all, and the amount of revenue the game has doesn't seem to flow down to the fans or local footy. I'm involved in a junior football club and we pay the AFL a fee for each player, not much comes back.
Rugby league is a better game to watch on TV than in person, Union even more so. AFL is better in person than on TV. For this reason AFL crowds will always be better regardless of how many people support the code.
GWS is a long term investment. It provides an additional game for TV and is in a significant growth area, with a lot of migrants that arent wedded to RL and are ripe to become possible AFL fans in the future. It needs time; hardly a sunk cost fallacy, as it's not evident that it won't eventually work.
I wonder what a real cost benefit analysis would show us.
Generations? How many? Whats will be the $$$$cost? What guarantee it will work in Generations, or centuries, or ever?
The NRL crowds in the area are not really that great considering the population. So How does one quantify it being a success.
PS you cant discount the cost.
- Jul 5, 2012
- 24,745
- 40,163
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Kidding, right?
I agree with posters that the timeframes here are huge and it's way too early to be declaring a result of any kind, but I also can't help thinking that (a) there's a big difference between being the only AFL team in a town and being the second AFL team in a town, and (b) the world is such a different place to 1982, when the Swans arrived in Sydney, that we can't just say "well it worked in the end for the Swans so it'll work for GWS eventually".
I'd say the two biggest points to make are that the Swans most probably soaked up all the Aussie Rules support at the time when they started from The South Melbourne move. A lot of expat Southerners & local Aussie rules people began to support them. Also, the Swans got a big boost from the Rugby League wars of the 1990's.
It certainly took 30 years to 'get it together'.
To repeat what I've said before, GWS exist, & thus one hopes they do grow. However, that is far from certain. Meanwhile, the costs mount. Its natural to be concerned.
Kobe Gryant
extremely overqualified chemistry teacher
People are missing the point a bit here IMO, It's not even really a battle against Rugby League, it's just a battle for sporting interest in general, and there's a variety of reasons for this.
Being a Victorian living up here, the AFL vs NRL argument is far less prominent than you'd think. From suburb to suburb it varies in allegiance, but you're honestly more likely to find a bloke who couldn't give a rats about sport as a whole, which just isn't the case in other Australian states.
Aussies in general love winners, but in Sydney it's a different level. If you're not winning virtually nobody cares, and even if you are, nobody cares until the finals. There's not the same buzz throughout the season of riding the wave to a premiership or going to games, and that shows through crowd figures in both sports.
The Swans do pretty well crowd wise and I attend a few games with mates just to get back into the spirit of things, but I think even Sydney supporters would agree that it's definitely viewed more as a 'night out', rather than a cauldron for rostered on supporters like the MCG is during the season.
That fact is in Sydney that's what sport is...it's just another aspect of the entertainment industry. It's a different demographic up here and it's not an age thing either, it's just the way it is.
It comes back to Sydney's elitist view of things IMO. Every state has it's less desirable suburbs, but in Sydney there's a definite nastiness towards the west, and therefore you're not to behave as a 'westy' would and it's something I had to adjust to after moving here. I live in the North Shore and it's honestly pretty horrible what's said about people who are less fortunate, or live out west just by choice.
That behaviour comes into sport as well in terms of the passion. You can watch, but you can't be too invested. It's unfortunate and there's a variety of geographical reasons for it, but it's just the way things are up here. It's far more cut and dry in terms of suburban stereotypes than other cities than I've lived in, but again that's just personal experience.
Being a Victorian living up here, the AFL vs NRL argument is far less prominent than you'd think. From suburb to suburb it varies in allegiance, but you're honestly more likely to find a bloke who couldn't give a rats about sport as a whole, which just isn't the case in other Australian states.
Aussies in general love winners, but in Sydney it's a different level. If you're not winning virtually nobody cares, and even if you are, nobody cares until the finals. There's not the same buzz throughout the season of riding the wave to a premiership or going to games, and that shows through crowd figures in both sports.
The Swans do pretty well crowd wise and I attend a few games with mates just to get back into the spirit of things, but I think even Sydney supporters would agree that it's definitely viewed more as a 'night out', rather than a cauldron for rostered on supporters like the MCG is during the season.
That fact is in Sydney that's what sport is...it's just another aspect of the entertainment industry. It's a different demographic up here and it's not an age thing either, it's just the way it is.
It comes back to Sydney's elitist view of things IMO. Every state has it's less desirable suburbs, but in Sydney there's a definite nastiness towards the west, and therefore you're not to behave as a 'westy' would and it's something I had to adjust to after moving here. I live in the North Shore and it's honestly pretty horrible what's said about people who are less fortunate, or live out west just by choice.
That behaviour comes into sport as well in terms of the passion. You can watch, but you can't be too invested. It's unfortunate and there's a variety of geographical reasons for it, but it's just the way things are up here. It's far more cut and dry in terms of suburban stereotypes than other cities than I've lived in, but again that's just personal experience.
Its almost like when you want it to be the VFL but pretend its the AFL - people in another parochial af city see through the facade.Shocking proof the Swans and GWS have failed to attract fans.
AFL loses the battle for Sydney: Swans and GWS fail to attract fans
Hundreds of millions of dollars in AFL cash has not been enough to win the battle of Sydney against the NRL. New figures have shown the Swans and GWS are AFL liabilities and fans are tuning outwww.dailymail.co.uk
The expansion strategy isn't really about crowds... it's about TV viewership and getting a bigger TV deal. I can't comment with any experience on Sydney culture or the NRL, but my understanding is that the NRL does disproportionately well from TV viewership versus game attendance...maybe that's because it's a product better viewed on TV than live, or maybe it's a reflection of Sydneysiders and the way they consume sport. Either way, the AFL managed to score a bumper TV rights deal and I suspect the existence of GC and GWS was a big factor. I don't image they see it as a failure. Not yet.
League is actually better to watch on tv.
- Sep 19, 2007
- 19,066
- 17,620
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Anaheim Ducks, PSV Eindhoven
Of course it is it doesn't have BT and co ruining the commentary. And Channel 7 camera angles and directing are diabolical.
KissKiss
Norm Smith Medallist
- Nov 26, 2012
- 7,725
- 8,722
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
I dunno some of the NRL commentators are shockingly bad. Its more an Australian thing than an individual sport thing. We just have crap standards for commentary
Two questions :
1) Should we send BT to league as a trojan horse
2) League folk are notoriously thick as pigshit, but are they thick enough to have him ruin their game on telly?
3) if not do we need a good hard look at ourselves?
Instead of actual qualified broadcast journalists we have the good blokes club getting gigs, overseas sports players make so much money in their sport they retire when they have finished. The shitferbrains ex footy players with no job prospects after footy that are in the good blokes club get footy broadcast spots.
- Mar 17, 2014
- 10,871
- 12,766
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Articles like in the OP never emanate from Victoria, its always from the north which i find interesting. Racing is another interesting comparison (also run by PVL). They have basically tried to destroy racing in Victoria with prizemoney, not for the interest of the sport but to "win" the non existent racing war.
- May 3, 2007
- 36,302
- 21,041
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Man City, Valencia, Lazio, Panthers
All 18 teams played a part in that 4.5 billion dollar tv deal between 2025-31, even North Melbourne pitched in.
Similar threads
