Hyperbole aside, might Australian cricket be in trouble due to societal factors?

TigerCraig

Premiership Player
Joined
Jun 12, 2002
Posts
3,176
Likes
575
Location
Sydney
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Manly
#51
Seems India have no problem finding excellent players, despite their parents dying young, living in poverty in shanty shacks, having little to no possessions and sometimes at best having little more than a 5-foot wide alley to play in.
This is actually part of their strength now.

Crash Craddock made the point (and so does my Indian wife) that in the past the cricket team was made up of generally well to do men who came through the good schools and clubs and had talent, skill and technique but not always the fire. They also generally came from a small number of states - of about 250 test cricketers since independence over half have been from Maharashtra (Mumbai), Delhi or Gujarat.

Since the IPL most players from lower socio-economic groups have been getting a chance to make their names
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Scotland

Hall of Famer
Joined
May 5, 2006
Posts
45,202
Likes
46,167
AFL Club
West Coast
#52
It's nothing to do with population. Australian's these days grow up with a sense of entitlement, from a young age, through their teenage years and into young adulthood. Plucking players out of junior leagues at 12 and 13 to head off to elite development camps and systems just reinforces that mentality. Some clearly deal with it better than others but for every Ponting there's dozens of spuds who should never have made it past grade cricket.

We're legitimately talking about Daniel Hughes and the next Lehmann as possible test cricketers. **** me, I won't watch a single test with those hacks in the team, it's hard enough with the Marsh brothers spudding it up.
It is when said population lives and breathes cricket. England has twice the population we have, but most of them don't grow up playing cricket and it's always raining anyway.

We seem to produce very limited cricketers. When the conditions aren't within a narrow band our bowlers and batsmen seem to look lost. The MCG pitch was shit, but it was playable. We made it look like a road and a minefield with poor bowling and batting. Bowl full on the stumps at the Indians and you'll most likely just be clipped off the pads. Bowl full on the stumps to our guys and you're a good chance of an LBW. Some of our dismissals are just bizarre. Mitch Marsh vs Ashwin - WTF was Marsh doing? Ball was outside leg and he somehow got outside the line and got an outside edge.
 
Joined
Dec 31, 2018
Posts
8
Likes
4
AFL Club
West Coast
#53
How chubby are the kids these days???!! Deadset all they eat is fast food and energy drinks. How on earth are we going to produce the next pat Cummins if our next gen cricketers are all 120 kilos
 

Doodlesweaver

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Apr 17, 2010
Posts
12,843
Likes
5,001
Location
London
AFL Club
Fremantle
#57
Probably deserves it's own thread elsewhere but do we have any sporting areas of traditional strength where we're actually getting better?

Cricket, rugby, swimming & Summer Olympics in general, tennis... we used to be good at these sports.

Test team stinks, that's pretty well established. Wallabies are 6th or 7th in the World and haven't won the Bledisloe for 15 years and the WC for nearly 20. SR participation has become a bit of a joke and the ARU couldn't organise a chook raffle. We won 16 gold and 58 medals overall in Sydney compared to 8 and 29 in Rio. Results have been trending down each games since 2000. Tennis we used to win the Davis Cup. Wasn't that long ago it took us about 5 years just to get back into the World Group. We have a couple of players floating around the top 50 but seem to produce almost exclusively ********s now so none of our guys are yet good enough to shake off the 'yeah but he's still a dickhead' thing.

On the flip side our basketball team has never been stronger. We've got more players going through the US college system and US professional league than ever. Once upon a time winning a medal of any colour at the Winter Olympics was a big deal. These days we go in with a couple of medal fancies in various disciplines each time, all of which spend most of their time training overseas. We're pretty good at a lot of women's sports but then I think we just provide more opportunities than other countries and the relative international standards aren't that high.

Do other countries just do it better than us now?

NB: Mocking England in the 90s was almost a hobby. Cricket team sucked, and they won 1 goal and 15 medals overall at Atlanda 96. They've gone 10th, 10th, 4th, 3rd, 2nd in the medal tallies since. And kicked our arse in a couple of Ashes series home and away. They even had a male tennis player win Wimbledon, even if he's from Scotland.
$$$$$ - they've been funding sport like there is no tomorrow.
 

Scotland

Hall of Famer
Joined
May 5, 2006
Posts
45,202
Likes
46,167
AFL Club
West Coast
#58
$$$$$ - they've been funding sport like there is no tomorrow.
Yep. The UK had been chasing hosting an Olympic Games since Barcelona and being awarded the 2012 games gave them a focus to be one of the best performed nations. They really put their money where there mouth is. Team GB winning 27 gold medals an Olympic Games would've been laughed at in the 90s, and in 2016 that's what happened. Swimming, cycling, rowing, gymnastics... they even won the women's hockey. Neither of our hockey teams made it out of the quarter finals, previously we've been gold medalists in both.
 

Chaisa

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jun 2, 2013
Posts
8,960
Likes
7,908
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
The Exers
#59
I don't think the decline in Australian cricket is so much a talent issue as a development issue. What you see with the batsmen is a lot of guys averaging early 40's with 60+ SR's, which suggests that batsmen still have the talent, but the ability to build innings does not seem as prevalent as what it was 10-20 years ago.

As for why this is.....that is a trickier question. I'm blaming Greg Chappell.
 
Joined
Jul 20, 2015
Posts
250
Likes
226
AFL Club
Fremantle
#60
From my experience, it's not the kids that are the issue, it's their 45 year old parents who aren't willing to sacrifice their entire weekend for one kid's sport

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk
 

Richard Pryor

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Feb 6, 2013
Posts
6,362
Likes
8,006
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#61

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Gavin Excell

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Posts
23,980
Likes
23,732
Location
Bentleigh
AFL Club
Geelong
#62
I think the elite young athletes are choosing Australian Rules Football due to the number of positions available. Secondly there would be a smaller percentage of the population that are active as children, with even fewer being able to afford an expensive sport like cricket.
This

Best sports kids choose the footballs

Cricket is almost a niche sport now in Australia.

The comparison to India where cricket is everything is stark
 

wolmeister

All Australian
Joined
Nov 7, 2013
Posts
866
Likes
489
AFL Club
West Coast
#63
How chubby are the kids these days???!! Deadset all they eat is fast food and energy drinks. How on earth are we going to produce the next pat Cummins if our next gen cricketers are all 120 kilos
They all aspire to become the next Rahkeem Cornwall.
 

Caesar

Ex-Huckleberry
Joined
Mar 3, 2005
Posts
23,053
Likes
7,811
Location
Tombstone, AZ
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
#64
I really don't think it's any more complicated than recreational options getting a lot more diverse, and cricket not being a very attractive sport for kids to play. It's very expensive, requires huge time commitments, and even good players spend a hell of a lot of time standing around in the hot sun with minimal involvement in the action.

Chuck in the talent drain from the increasing professionalisation of other sports, and it would be surprising if we weren't producing fewer good cricketers.
 

Moonwatcher

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Dec 14, 2007
Posts
15,340
Likes
11,236
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
#66
I think the elite young athletes are choosing Australian Rules Football due to the number of positions available. Secondly there would be a smaller percentage of the population that are active as children, with even fewer being able to afford an expensive sport like cricket.
Carey is a case in point. Dropped by GWS and is now playing for Australia. AFL sides have international quality cricket players on their list. With the 2 best Australian batsmen suspended, it only takes the AFL pinching one or 2 more of the potential best Australian top order and we're a weak team.
 

amazingjoshy

Premiership Player
Joined
Apr 29, 2005
Posts
3,803
Likes
3,669
Location
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
#67
From my experience, it's not the kids that are the issue, it's their 45 year old parents who aren't willing to sacrifice their entire weekend for one kid's sport

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

It's the kids AND their parents. These days, who wants to spend their entire weekend out in the sun, mostly standing or sitting around doing nothing, when instead they can go off and play 2 hrs of basketball on a Sat arvo (and be in the action the whole time)?

If you think our Test team is bad now, give it 15 years. I don't know where the players are going to come from.
 

Richard Pryor

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Feb 6, 2013
Posts
6,362
Likes
8,006
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#68
It's the kids AND their parents. These days, who wants to spend their entire weekend out in the sun, mostly standing or sitting around doing nothing, when instead they can go off and play 2 hrs of basketball on a Sat arvo (and be in the action the whole time)?

If you think our Test team is bad now, give it 15 years. I don't know where the players are going to come from.
Specifically basketball is a huge reason for the Windies decline if I'm not mistaken.
 

greatwhiteshark

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Oct 3, 2007
Posts
9,252
Likes
8,148
Location
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
West Perth
#69
I played in 4 premierships in footy before I was 12 and one cricket premiership before I was 14. Kids would miss out on being selected and only a very small percentage of us went on and played high level.
The system is different now where participation is what it’s all about, winning and losing is not part of a young child’s world now.
The system today is not producing any more better players than it did 40 years ago because there is always going to be a minute amount of talented kids.
You simply cannot pick kids out of thin air and think coaching will make them good players, you either naturally can play or you can’t. There will always be some exceptions but for the most part it is what it is.
The drop out in sport was always large in My era as well, in fact they probably dropped out even earlier as they went and focused on something they were good at.
Parents were a non issue in my era also as only a small percentage of them even watched you and if things didn’t go your way all they said was talk to your coach and get better. Parents knew it was not their place to interfere and solve their kids issues. And coaches never consistently told you what a star you were they simply installed the basics of the sport and let you work things out yourself.
We were also lucky that most of our coaches were all former top line footy and cricket players and were not impeded by stupid coaching accreditation’s. You learnt from people who knew, not from people who have only read about it.

The systems I grew up with in my opinion are far better but I don’t blame the modern system for Australia’s talent at the minute, we are just in a bit of a bad trot and in time we will be back top of the tree like we have done forever. Just be patient and accept that right now our players are simply average.
 
Last edited:

smasha

Premium Platinum
Joined
Sep 7, 2003
Posts
34,889
Likes
26,586
Location
Richmond Paddock
AFL Club
Richmond
#71
This is actually part of their strength now.

Crash Craddock made the point (and so does my Indian wife) that in the past the cricket team was made up of generally well to do men who came through the good schools and clubs and had talent, skill and technique but not always the fire. They also generally came from a small number of states - of about 250 test cricketers since independence over half have been from Maharashtra (Mumbai), Delhi or Gujarat.

Since the IPL most players from lower socio-economic groups have been getting a chance to make their names
India like China are finally seeing the advantage of having a humungous population and tapping into a much larger talent field,yes I know it’s only 11 versus 11 on the field but with a population of 1.4 billion,that’s a hugely bigger talent pool.

Would Germany win all those WC’s with a population of 20 million? I wouldn’t think so.

Aussie grit kept us on top for 20 years,we will be back despite the huge pendulum swing in today’s World where money is everything.

Out of all the countries in cricket,we love to put ourselves down,it’s an Aussie thing,when we fail in a few series,it’s like the World has fallen down.

Look at our incredible achievements in the long term history of the sport and cheer up Australia,if you want too lol.

We will be back,sandpaper gate has set this team back,this year’s cricket Summer reminds me very much of the Summer when England tore through Australia because our stars were playing in World Series Cricket.

A transitional year and we only just lost to India last night by a whisker!
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom