Hyperthetical trade scenario

[Punt_Road_Roar]

The original "hypothetical" we'd take, but no-one in their right mind would ever take that. So you're spot on tugga. Adding Judd to our lineup would be akin to plonking a cocktail umbrella on a glass of sewage. Sure he's one of the best I've seen, and he's still only a young lad, but he wouldn't be our messiah. If he misses a game at WC, they still win. If he'd miss a game for us, we'd still get pumped. Quality depth is what we should be about. This will take us years still.

Now that is funny.

What else I find funny is we are talking abouts trades and the 2007 season hasnt even started.

"We've got High Hopes, We've got High Hopes"

 

[polakthetiger]

If anyone syas Deledio in the same sentence as trade you should die.

Well said, and to say, Spud, he doesn't have the 'potential' to be as good as Judd is ridiculous. There are 5% of players in his age group in the country who have the 'potential' to go on and be as good, and who knows, even better than Judd. Lids is definately in that group. Sometimes the negativity on this board is laughable. Lids is 19 y.o and Bling 20. Yep, not much upside from either from here

 

[cherryripe]

ROFL...........Tambling isn't worthy of wiping Judds @ss. Will go down as one of richmonds worst draft picks in History. Over rated hack. As for Deledio, we can only hope he becomes as half as good as Judd, cos he never will reach the pinnacle of Judds performances

Frawley is that you?

 

[tigerdan]

ROFL...........Tambling isn't worthy of wiping Judds @ss. Will go down as one of richmonds worst draft picks in History. Over rated hack. As for Deledio, we can only hope he becomes as half as good as Judd, cos he never will reach the pinnacle of Judds performances

And I thought PLSC was a tad negative.

What was your previous user name by the way?

 

[PLSC]

judd is worth 2 top 10 picks and a quality player and even then the eagles would still think about it

keep dreaming because we cant do it and crap thread