By all means debate it. I take it you think it's heavily stacked in the Lions' favour?
I don't want Gunston to leave at all, but I think that this is what a hard nosed list management trade would look like.
Sorry mate.
Yep, way heavily weighted toward them.
Gunston is massively versatile. Has kicked 50+ goals many times & has shown this year that he can play HBF. He gets around the ground as well as anyone & is strong on the lead & in contested marking (for his size). And, he's a 3x Premiership Player - he's done the yards & built the current culture - we need him to be inducting the new dudes & showing them how it is done.
And he's only 25/26. He'll be there when we challenge again & will make our KPFs better for it.
Gunston, Roughy, Cyril & Smith are my only untradable players (Smitty mainly 'cause he's my favourite).
We snuck Gunners away from Adelaide when he was still cheapish - Schacke won't be. I'd much rather we chase KPF as Free Agents than have to trade for them. Otherwise they cost us in both Picks & cash.
Doc Dre & Kade Stewart aren't even real things as far as trades are concerned.