Competition I̶f̶ IT'S A̶i̶n̶'̶t̶ BROKE D̶o̶n̶'̶t̶ FIX IT! : Week 17 - St. Kilda Cracking Logo Clash

[cannavo]

Ladies and Gentlemen........

For too long, we have witnessed the horrors football jumpers can produce

This stops now!

Each week a jumper that has been seen as bad, horrible, shocking or the general consensus isn't fond of
will get a makeover while keeping its certain themes.
Next under the knife is

St Kilda 2008 Clash Jumper

(a.k.a The cracking logo)

Main Theme: White Base with Red and Black
Secondary: Use of the club logo​

RULES

• Entries must include 1 jumper front and back (Shorts and Socks optional)
• You must keep at least 1 theme coming from the jumper
  • eg. Hawthorns diamond jumper must include diamonds
  • St Kildas yellow jumper must promote Pura light milk by keeping a yellow base etc.
• You cannot copy any past designs from the club
  • Taking elements are allowed
• Maximum 2 Entries
• Any other questions, please ask.

NOTE: The quote "It's broke, Fix it" can mean "What's your take on this?"​

List of jumpers with links
Links updated!


Past Results

• Week 1 - Hawthorn Diamond
• Week 2 - St Kilda Pura Light Start Yellow Away
• Week 3 - Carlton M&M
• Week 4 - Western Bulldogs Ballarat
• Week 5 - West Coast OCHRE
• Week 6 - Fremantle Tripanel
• Week 7 - Port Adelaide Gradients + Lightning
• Week 8 - Brisbane Piss Stain
• Week 9 - Collingwood Barcode
• Week 10 - Hawthorn Kokoda
• Week 11 - Richmond Silver Top Taxi
• Week 12 - Melbourne Pink Lady
• Week 13 - Hawthorn T-shirt
• Week 14 - Western Bulldogs Origin
• Week 15 - Hawthorn "Modern" Clash
• Week 16 - Adelaide Toothpaste
• Week 17 - St Kilda 2008 Clash In Progress

Jumpers to be done

• Adelaide Hawk
• Brisbane Funnel
• Brisbane Lionside
• Essendons Shade Of Grey
• Geelong Tramp Stamp
• Geelong Gradient Hoops
• Gold Coast Wave
• Hawthorn Flying Hawk Clash
• Melbourne 2015 Clash
• North Melbourne Logo With Wavy Lines + (Inverse for show)
• Port Adelaide Gradient Stripes
• Richmond Logo with wavy lines
• West Coast 2010 Protruding Head Clash

​

 

[cannavo]

 

[Barrybran]

I quite liked the 2008 clash. Certainly a lot better than the extra wide white tri panel.

 

[magpienato]

A bit rushed because of my exams but here's what I threw together:

 

[Barrybran]

A bit rushed because of my exams but here's what I threw together:
View attachment 439250

Eddie will love that

 

[Speck]

Love the idea, but I wonder if the theme is a bit too generous. White base with black and red describes all our clash jumpers, would love to see how people could incorporate our logo front and centre on a jumper while keeping it good.

Just a thought, don't intend to criticize anyone.

 

[Cody_]

 

[Bryce_Jersey17]

Surely the main theme is “logo front and centre” with the secondary as “red and white stripes as side panels/ side stripes”

 

[magpienato]

Love the idea, but I wonder if the theme is a bit too generous. White base with black and red describes all our clash jumpers, would love to see how people could incorporate our logo front and centre on a jumper while keeping it good.

Just a thought, don't intend to criticize anyone.

Yeah that's actually a fair point. After all, it's a competition to make a specific clash jumper look better with the elements it has.

 

[magpienato]

Just out of interest, does anybody actually know why St Kilda made this clash jumper with "cracks" in it? When I first saw it I just assumed it was a bit of stretching which was weird for an AFL jumper but only recently I learned that this was done by design. Odd.

 

[magpienato]

Eddie will love that

AFL's solution: have both Collingwood and St Kilda play in their clash

 

[cannavo]

Surely the main theme is “logo front and centre” with the secondary as “red and white stripes as side panels/ side stripes”

True, this heat's got me thinking sideways, oh well

 

[Prison bar Pete]

use an un-cracked logo & it was a perfectly reasonable clash jumper

 

[Javelin]

use an un-cracked logo & it was a perfectly reasonable clash jumper

I remember when the poll went up to decide which clash would be used. There was another option with an un-cracked logo, but I recall it had other design elements which made it inferior. There was also the ability to provide feedback on the designs, and I remember stating that this design should be used with an un-cracked logo because no emblem should be tarnished deliberately. Sadly they didn't listen to me

 

[Bryce_Jersey17]

Just out of interest, does anybody actually know why St Kilda made this clash jumper with "cracks" in it? When I first saw it I just assumed it was a bit of stretching which was weird for an AFL jumper but only recently I learned that this was done by design. Odd.

“Aesthetic”

 

[just_kick_it]

Its been a long time but Im back...

 

[Fizzler]

Its been a long time but Im back...
View attachment 439379

GANTY! Glad you're back mate.

 

[just_kick_it]

GANTY! Glad you're back mate.

Thanks! Ive got a bit of spare time at the moment before I do some travelling so Ive been lurking around a bit and finally decided to pull my finger out and design something. Im pretty happy with how it turned out as well!

 

[Mero]

Well; this is easy to come up with a design for

This is the design that was leading the poll for the Clash jumper on the St.Kilda website shortly before the close of voting.
However, with a sudden rush of over 1000 votes and the cracking logo jumper somehow pipped it at the post, just as voting closed.
How do I know this?
I designed this, based on the Fitzroy preseason jumpers from 12 years before this.
I followed the online poll every day because I stood to get one of the jumpers if my design was chosen.