Thread starter
#1
There has been a lot of lists that are asking, 'who are the top 10 or 20 players in the AFL?"
I think it's a bit hard to answer because you need to consider the age of the veteran's, injury problems, the big potential word etc.
So I put together a list of the 50 best players in the last three years. I did my best but imagine I have left plenty out (my apologies) ...
Please note that except for Judd I mixed up the list so it is not in order on purpose.
What I want to do is slowly remove people one at a time, until we have only 10 left.
To remove a player a poster must nominate someone off the list, then a second independent poster needs to confirm it. Then they will be removed.
Again I really do apologise if I have left anyone out.
1. Chris Judd
2. Barry Hall
3. Scott West
4. Joel Bowden
5. Matthew Pavlich
6. James Clement
7. Simon Goodwin
8. Daniel Kerr
9. Brendan Fevola
10. Sam Mitchell
11. Ben Cousins
12. Peter Everitt
13. Brett Kirk
14. Lenny Hayes
15. Chad Cornes
16. David Neitz
17. Luke Hodge
18. Simon Black
19. Mark Riccuito
20. Jonathon Brown
21. Brendan Lade
22. Nick Dal Santo
23. Luke Ball
24. Adam Goodes
25. Peter Bell
26. Dean Cox
27. Nick Reiwoldt
28. Ben Rutten
29. Nathan Buckley
30. Fraser Gherig
31. James Hird
32. Jude Bolton
33. Mark Williams
34. Tyson Edwards
35. Brad Johnson
36. Aaron Davey
37. Daniel Cross
38. Cameron Mooney
39. Jason Ackermanis
40. Warren Tredrea
41. Matthew Lloyd
42. Travis Johnstone
43. Matthew Scarlett
44. Michael Voss
45. Matthew Richardson
46. Brock McLean
47. Amon Buchanon
48. Chris Johnson
49. Nathan Thompson
50. Darren Glass
If some of you regulars can assist in providing updated lists I would really appreciate because work can often tie me up for large blocks.
I know you will feel that I have left some people off because it is harder than you think to squeeze them all in, but given we are aiming for a top 10 I don't think it matters really.
If there is someone glaringly obvious I will edit the main list.
Thanks
I think it's a bit hard to answer because you need to consider the age of the veteran's, injury problems, the big potential word etc.
So I put together a list of the 50 best players in the last three years. I did my best but imagine I have left plenty out (my apologies) ...
Please note that except for Judd I mixed up the list so it is not in order on purpose.
What I want to do is slowly remove people one at a time, until we have only 10 left.
To remove a player a poster must nominate someone off the list, then a second independent poster needs to confirm it. Then they will be removed.
Again I really do apologise if I have left anyone out.
1. Chris Judd
2. Barry Hall
3. Scott West
4. Joel Bowden
5. Matthew Pavlich
6. James Clement
7. Simon Goodwin
8. Daniel Kerr
9. Brendan Fevola
10. Sam Mitchell
11. Ben Cousins
12. Peter Everitt
13. Brett Kirk
14. Lenny Hayes
15. Chad Cornes
16. David Neitz
17. Luke Hodge
18. Simon Black
19. Mark Riccuito
20. Jonathon Brown
21. Brendan Lade
22. Nick Dal Santo
23. Luke Ball
24. Adam Goodes
25. Peter Bell
26. Dean Cox
27. Nick Reiwoldt
28. Ben Rutten
29. Nathan Buckley
30. Fraser Gherig
31. James Hird
32. Jude Bolton
33. Mark Williams
34. Tyson Edwards
35. Brad Johnson
36. Aaron Davey
37. Daniel Cross
38. Cameron Mooney
39. Jason Ackermanis
40. Warren Tredrea
41. Matthew Lloyd
42. Travis Johnstone
43. Matthew Scarlett
44. Michael Voss
45. Matthew Richardson
46. Brock McLean
47. Amon Buchanon
48. Chris Johnson
49. Nathan Thompson
50. Darren Glass
If some of you regulars can assist in providing updated lists I would really appreciate because work can often tie me up for large blocks.
I know you will feel that I have left some people off because it is harder than you think to squeeze them all in, but given we are aiming for a top 10 I don't think it matters really.
If there is someone glaringly obvious I will edit the main list.
Thanks

