Recommitted Ian 'Bobby' Hill + R3 (40) to Collingwood for R3 (43) + F2

[VinnieB]

For a notoriously inconsistent player, he was bloody consistent across his career as per my OP on him above. 4 30+ goal seasons and another 4 20+ goal seasons. Effectively 8/8 seasons above 20 goals when he played more than 15 games.

and AA

 

[PieLebo87]

and AA

That’s right.

Was actually a 2 time AA - 2009, then again in 2011. I’m still saddened he retired in 2011 when he clearly had more to give.

 

[Bianconeri]

I'd take Leon over Krak too. Both great to watch though.

Leon cops a bum wrap on here.

Leon cops a bum wrap but not from me, I’d take him over Krak as well just think the latter was the better front an centre player.

 

[TradeDraft]

In other likely early movement, Giants small forward Bobby Hill will move to Collingwood in a trade of their future second-round pick, with another pick coming back to Collingwood this year.

GWS, Tigers agree on Taranto deal ahead of trade period start

A deal to send Tim Taranto to the Tigers has been agreed and is due to be formalised early when trading begins on Monday.

www.theage.com.au

 

[Robroy22]

Leon cops a bum wrap but not from me, I’d take him over Krak as well just think the latter was the better front an centre player.

take em both. Neon as a small defender and Krak kicking magic goals up front.

 

[loki04]

take em both. Neon as a small defender and Krak kicking magic goals up front.

I loved watching Leon play forward as good as he was in defence.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Leon running forward of the wing and lacing it to a target in the 50.

 

[Taylor]

Might be the first one to drop.

 

[Rusty Beam]

Might be the first one to drop.

Sounds like it. Paperwork being lodged now supposedly

 

[Rob R]

Sounds like it. Paperwork being lodged now supposedly

Sounds like Pies are getting a good deal - Hill + 40 for 43 and F2 (mid-late 30s after FS And academy ).

On SM-A125F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Rusty Beam]

Sounds like Pies are getting a good deal - Hill + 40 for 43 and F2 (mid-late 30s after FS And academy ).

On SM-A125F using BigFooty.com mobile app

My assumption is that we trying to bank higher point carrying picks, so we can at least to try to snare Brisbanes first rounder.

 

[Pistol Night]

Is there a go-home factor to worry about with him down the track? I’m surprised he isn’t preferencing a move to the Eagles or Dockers instead.

Perhaps hes an independent man that's no longer breast fed like some draftees

 

[PieLebo87]

My assumption is that we trying to bank higher point carrying picks, so we can at least to try to snare Brisbanes first rounder.

Lions need their first for Dunkley, don’t they?

 

[Taylor]

Collingwood can buy Brisbane's future first for 20 second and third round picks if it wants to, any points still needed will carry the deficit to the next year and take effect at the end of the season - long before the AFL strips down the number of picks a club has to match the vacant list places.

So Collingwood could do that.

 

[TradeDraft]

Sounds like it. Paperwork being lodged now supposedly

Taking while to get Confirmation of it

 

[Rusty Beam]

Lions need their first for Dunkley, don’t they?

Yeah, you’re probably right. That has thrown a spanner in the works

I’m sure Wright and Hine have some sort of deal lined up though

 

[Northernsoul74]

Collingwood can buy Brisbane's future first for 20 second and third round picks if it wants to, any points still needed will carry the deficit to the next year and take effect at the end of the season - long before the AFL strips down the number of picks a club has to match the vacant list places.

So Collingwood could do that.

Brisbane would need to have 20 list spaces to use the theoretical 20 picks.

 

[Bay Pie]

My assumption is that we trying to bank higher point carrying picks, so we can at least to try to snare Brisbanes first rounder.

More likely targeting Essendons 2nd rounder, IMO.

I think Gold Coast have the picks to grab the BL first.

 

[Taylor]

Brisbane would need to have 20 list spaces to use the theoretical 20 picks.

No they don't. A club can carry as many future picks as it likes.

 

[Northernsoul74]

My assumption is that we trying to bank higher point carrying picks, so we can at least to try to snare Brisbanes first rounder.

It’s a plan but GC and West Coast look very attractive to Brisbane currently.

 

[Northernsoul74]

No they don't. A club can carry as many future picks as it likes.

You still need the list spots to use them to match.

 

[Taylor]

You still need the list spots to use them to match.

You do not when you are using points to match a deficit from the previous draft.

 

[Orange crush]

You do not when you are using points to match a deficit from the previous draft.

Point deficits come of the 1st pick, do they not?

 

[Taylor]

Point deficits come of the 1st pick, do they not?

If you don't have a first they will come off your next pick.
The first round protection means that if the bid for a player comes after the first round then any extra points needed don't come off the future first.

 

[mrposhman]

If you don't have a first they will come off your next pick.
The first round protection means that if the bid for a player comes after the first round then any extra points needed don't come off the future first.

I don't think there is any first round protection. The ruling as I understand it, is any deficit comes off the future year in the same round the bid was made.

Eg. If a bid was made in the 3rd round and there was a deficit, then neither the 1st or 2nd rounders are touched, and any deficit comes off the 3rd and 4th (if required).

If both Ashcroft and Fletcher are bid on in the first round, then there is no protection whatsoever to any of Brisbanes future picks.