If West Coast played Melbourne, Collingwood or Richmond in the Grand Final, who wins?

[MWPP]

?????
gee the drugs must be good over there

We haven’t beaten Hawthorn at the G since 2006 (10 point win in our Premiership year)
Our record against Collingwood at the G is even worse (haven’t beaten them there since 1995)

Our recent record against Richmond at the G is respectable
(10 point loss in 2017, 20
point win in 2015)

 

[Figure09]

This annoys me. The media in VIC need to show some respect to West Coast anything is possible. Yeah Richmond being based in Mel have already won the flag in 18 I guess.

 

[JP2]

I don't know who's most likely to win, but I know I'll be cheering on any team that's not Richmond, because I don't think I can take another 12 months of Richmond fans acting like petulant bellends in every single thread they come across.

 

[Trav 20]

2 horse race, dees and wce by far looking the most impressive sides this season

Nice try.

The Tiges remain the team to beat.

 

[Wacko23Jacko]

Who would win if the teams played at Adelaide wearing two left shoes and after eating a chicken Parma and drinking two pints on a Sunday with weather between 17-18.5 degrees c?

 

[richcogs]

Dees will 100% win it.

 

[Blackas87]

Tiges will 100% win it.

 

[captain cotch 9]

This annoys me. The media in VIC need to show some respect to West Coast anything is possible. Yeah Richmond being based in Mel have already won the flag in 18 I guess.

Why do u care what the media says about your team haha?

 

[Figure09]

VICs hate West Coast that's what

 

[HTT]

VICs hate West Coast that's what

Yep, forget about Richmon’s arch rivals Carlton and Collingwood, West Coast tops the lot.

 

[mellowyellow]

Tiges will 100% win it.

Here!take the cup.its yours

 

[kendrick]

Who would win if they played at suncorp stadium using a rugby ball and no handballs or kicks backwards.

 

[wcegls]

Tiges will 100% win it.

Tigers probably this year (only coz it’s at the g) but next 3 years Melbourne will 3 peet. Exciting times ahead for demons fans

 

[Boston tiger]

I don't know who's most likely to win, but I know I'll be cheering on any team that's not Richmond, because I don't think I can take another 12 months of Richmond fans acting like petulant bellends in every single thread they come across.

Imagine all those “ worst back to back premiers “ threads that would pop up.

 

[BigVic]

Richmond vs West Coast - Easy Richmond win
Melbourne vs West Coast - close game
Richmond vs Melbourne - Tigers win due to experience

 

[The_Eagles]

West Coast will pulverise Melbourne in my view
And 60 40 favourites against Richmond, that short kick game dismantled them and got them shook

 

[Trav 20]

West Coast will pulverise Melbourne in my view.

It's known to be poor.

 

[juss]

VICs hate West Coast that's what

No we dont, why? I dont get this. If West Coast won I dont have an issue. There are no West Coast fans in Melbourne that I know. Any other Vic side has a greater rivalry with us than West Coast. The banter of Melbourne-based footy fans simply doesnt involve West Coast.

You are quite irrelevant in the football heartland.

 

[Trav 20]

VICs hate West Coast that's what

I hate Carlton, Richmond, and Essendon, among others, but it's hard to hate a corporation. And that's all West Coast and Adelaide are. Cheeseburger clubs with no soul.

 

[Yippy Yi Yeo]

I hate Carlton, Richmond, and Essendon, among others, but it's hard to hate a corporation. And that's all West Coast and Adelaide are. Cheeseburger clubs with no soul.

Tell that to the fanbase which dwarfs Melbourne's

 

[Joey longshadow]

VICs hate West Coast that's what

In all honesty. ..I don't care about west coast enough to hate them

 

[Boston tiger]

VICs hate West Coast that's what

Love your song

 

[Coach_Required]

I don't know who's most likely to win, but I know I'll be cheering on any team that's not Richmond, because I don't think I can take another 12 months of Richmond fans acting like petulant bellends in every single thread they come across.

I used to be like you, but then we won a flag.

Maybe one day you will understand after such a long drought, I hope you do get to experience it, then ram it right up to everyone who has given your team nothing but s**t for as long as you can remember.

 

[Coach_Required]

In all honesty. ..I don't care about west coast enough to hate them

ooooohhh in Perth, thems fighting words. That's even worse than saying you hate them LOL

That's because in Perth its us against the rest of Australia, it's mentally inbred into everyone here, when in all honestly your right no one on the east coast gives a s**t about WA

 

[ChookMFC]

Tell that to the fanbase which dwarfs Melbourne's

My local McDonald's customers dwarf my local hamburger stand's customers, but one has a soul and one doesn't.