If you were Alastair Clarkson which club would you go to - GWS or Gold Coast?

[coxon]

As for Western Sydney, your questioning a choice of living on the Gold Coast or in (select one) Smithfield; Green Valley; Parramatta or heaven forbid, Blacktown?

why select one? pretty sure toby greene/jkelly all live in the eastern beachside suburbs... why would clarko have to actually live in western sydney?

 

[HairyO]

Keep in mind Roos took over Melbourne in 2014

2013 - 2 wins (54.1%)
2014 - 4 wins (68.4%)
2015 - 7 wins (77.0%)
2016 - 10 wins (97.6%)

Any way you look at that that is a huge improvement, and the young guys brought in under Roos, and the standards set by Roos are some of the things helping Melbourne now.

He had a dozen top 20 players. Of course there would be improvement.

 

[RUNVS]

He had a dozen top 20 players. Of course there would be improvement.

Melbourne had that in 2013 as well.

 

[HairyO]

Melbourne had that in 2013 as well.

When they were only just coming out of their tanking. When they stopped tanking they started improving. Kind of expected.