In all seriousness...

[leonmagic]

Don't fly off the handle, but what would you all think of this:

Chris Tarrant - Chris Judd.

Would you do it? Bearing in mind we've got C.Cloke, Davidson, Rocca, Morrison, T.Cloke and Josh as tall forward prospects...

Personally, I probably wouldn't go for it, but it's interesting food for thought.

 

[grayza]

i would think about it but dismiss it

those players you mentioned dont/wont provide the type of game that tarrant does and although judd would be great i wouldnt give the weagles tarrant for him

 

[shuveradda]

Seeing as we've got so many of those types, I Probably would go for it as Judd Is exactly what we need. But i would need to think about it for a long long time.

 

[Magpie Mick]

NO WAY !!!

 

[hotpie]

No. You build a side around your best player, especially if he's a forward. You never trade them unless there's been a serious falling out and/or salary cap issue.

 

[JazzPie]

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!

 

[MarkT]

NO.

I would love to get Judd but i wouldn't swap a quality tall for a quality small. Quality talls are much harder to find. A tall not of Tarrants quality for Judd would be fine. We don;t have any that WCE would want yet. Next year if we get some promising games into Hall, Davidson or Morrison then maybe one of them could be a trade.

 

[Lonie_from_50]

No, fair trade money wise, but it will never happen.

I can tell you that Chris Judd is the best midfielder in the competition at current time, But Chris Tarrant would be a big no no to give away. He will always be needed at Collingwood, It would be a tall-forward line, but i would rather get Steve Salopek to fill up Buckley's spot, because trading duds and we will get him.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

If it was say Paul Licuria or Shane O'Bree and 2ND Round Pick then I'd say yes. Worst Trade Ever.

 

[rychenroller]

Originally posted by The Lonie Range
If it was say Paul Licuria or Shane O'Bree and 2ND Round Pick then I'd say yes. Worst Trade Ever.

We'll beat the Eagles next time, coz they'll still be laughing at this

At 20 yrs old, he'd be the most sought after player in the comp, after J. Brown.