Analysis Inexperience watch

[Dalions]

Thank heavens for that.
Don't want to go back to those years.

Although the last 3 weeks.
Younger and slightly more experienced than the Swans.
Younger and less experienced than the Saints.
Quite a bit younger and less experienced than Richmond would have been even further behind if Lohmann was still in the team.

 

[Section 5]

Although the last 3 weeks.
Younger and slightly more experienced than the Swans.
Younger and less experienced than the Saints.
Quite a bit younger and less experienced than Richmond would have been even further behind if Lohmann was still in the team.

Yes, but not in the high 60's through to the high 70's games experience back in the bad days. Going from memory so could be wrong.

Saints 101, Swans 96 then the 2 games with Rich & Gunston Hawks 121, Crows 120

 

[Dalions]

Yes, but not in the high 60's through to the high 70's games experience back in the bad days. Going from memory so could be wrong.

Saints 101, Swans 96 then the 2 games with Rich & Gunston Hawks 121, Crows 120

Yep, hope we are never there again.
Although I do have fears for when Fages leaves and during the Gabba re-build period.
And playing games at suckfull QSAC.

 

[Viceregal]

It has been a while since the thread title was correct

Well it is normally correct for at least one team ... and technically you could consider us (when were are more experienced) as under-inexperienced just like something can be hotter by minus 7 degrees (ie colder)

 

[Jivlain]

	Brisbane	West Coast
(0 to 10 games)	1	4
0 to 24 games	4	8
25 to 49 games	2	2
50 to 99 games	3	3
100 to 199 games	10	6
200+ games	3	3
Games played	116.55	90.73
Age	26.32	24.79
Height	187.91	189.32
Finals played	6.77	4.27

Interactive version

 

[Elixuh]

Such a weird list balance for a side with 90 games avg experience. I know that is partly through injury.

 

[twhowler]

Such a weird list balance for a side with 90 games avg experience. I know that is partly through injury.

Yeah it's not the average that gets you necessarily - but the 8 with 0-24.

It's been interesting looking at this - even though Geelong were awesome last year with an absurdly high number of games played, you really do see diminishing returns above about 100. Our less experienced teams (to me at least) have been the better ones this year. Mainly about pace i guess.

 

[Elixuh]

Yeah it's not the average that gets you necessarily - but the 8 with 0-24.

It's been interesting looking at this - even though Geelong were awesome last year with an absurdly high number of games played, you really do see diminishing returns above about 100. Our less experienced teams (to me at least) have been the better ones this year. Mainly about pace i guess.

It highlights how terribly their experienced players are performing as well

 

[Jivlain]

	Melbourne	Brisbane
(0 to 10 games)	1	1
0 to 24 games	3	3
25 to 49 games	1	1
50 to 99 games	6	3
100 to 199 games	10	12
200+ games	2	3
Games played	116.64	127.14
Age	26.07	26.77
Height	186.27	187.77
Finals played	6.00	7.55

Interactive version

 

[Dalions]

Interesting to see that it looks like Melbourne don’t have any players between the ages of 24-27 for this game, quite a decent gap and is ultimately the reason why we are a bit older and more experienced for this game.

 

[Jivlain]

	Brisbane	Geelong
(0 to 10 games)	1	0
0 to 24 games	3	0
25 to 49 games	1	4
50 to 99 games	3	5
100 to 199 games	12	7
200+ games	3	6
Games played	125.50	146.68
Age	26.67	28.03
Height	188.18	189.27
Finals played	7.45	13.55

Interactive version

 

[Nathan Barley]

Take out Zorks ans Geelong have the 7 oldest. 8 when Tuohy is a late inclusion

 

[Jivlain]

	Gold Coast	Brisbane
(0 to 10 games)	0	2
0 to 24 games	3	3
25 to 49 games	2	1
50 to 99 games	7	3
100 to 199 games	8	12
200+ games	2	3
Games played	102.18	125.95
Age	25.78	26.74
Height	188.23	188.32
Finals played	0.73	7.45

Interactive version

 

[Dalions]

View attachment 1757138

	Gold Coast	Brisbane
(0 to 10 games)	0	2
0 to 24 games	3	3
25 to 49 games	2	1
50 to 99 games	7	3
100 to 199 games	8	12
200+ games	2	3
Games played	102.18	125.95
Age	25.78	26.74
Height	188.23	188.32
Finals played	0.73	7.45

Interactive version

On that profile they really should have won more games than they have.

 

[Viceregal]

View attachment 1757138

	Gold Coast	Brisbane
(0 to 10 games)	0	2
0 to 24 games	3	3
25 to 49 games	2	1
50 to 99 games	7	3
100 to 199 games	8	12
200+ games	2	3
Games played	102.18	125.95
Age	25.78	26.74
Height	188.23	188.32
Finals played	0.73	7.45

Interactive version

Kind of makes you wonder how they will go when/if they play in a final one day...

 

[MSB ROYS]

Finals played for the Suns = 0. At least they will make the VFL finals I suppose.

 

[Jivlain]

	Fremantle	Brisbane
(0 to 10 games)	1	3
0 to 24 games	6	5
25 to 49 games	3	4
50 to 99 games	9	2
100 to 199 games	7	12
200+ games	1	3
Games played	77.35	109.54
Age	25.21	26.15
Height	187.15	188.58
Finals played	2.23	6.50

Interactive version

 

[Grasshopper17]

I read somewhere that Freo's win over Geelong last Saturday was the biggest difference in combined games experience a team had overcome to win a game, ever.

 

[Nathan Barley]

I read somewhere that Freo's win over Geelong last Saturday was the biggest difference in combined games experience a team had overcome to win a game, ever.

We should have passed on this thread to them

 

[Jivlain]

I read somewhere that Freo's win over Geelong last Saturday was the biggest difference in combined games experience a team had overcome to win a game, ever.

For the record,

	Geelong	Fremantle
(0 to 10 games)	0	1
0 to 24 games	0	5
25 to 49 games	4	3
50 to 99 games	4	9
100 to 199 games	8	5
200+ games	7	1
Games played	152.78	74.83
Age	28.31	25.15
Height	189.17	186.70
Finals played	13.78	2.22

Interactive version (permalink)

 

[Jivlain]

	Brisbane	Adelaide
(0 to 10 games)	0	3
0 to 24 games	1	6
25 to 49 games	3	4
50 to 99 games	2	5
100 to 199 games	13	3
200+ games	3	4
Games played	132.68	89.91
Age	27.01	25.58
Height	188.55	187.86
Finals played	7.86	1.91

Interactive version

 

[Section 5]

You would think on experience alone we should comfortably account for the Crows.

0-50 games Lions 4 Crows 10
50- 100 Lions 2 crows 5
100 plus games Lions 16 Crows 7

 

[briztoon]

You would think on experience alone we should comfortably account for the Crows.

0-50 games Lions 4 Crows 10
50- 100 Lions 2 crows 5
100 plus games Lions 16 Crows 7

Just like Hawthorn and Gold Coast.

 

[Section 5]

Cats probably thought the same against Dockers last week and did not get them very far.

Just like Hawthorn and Gold Coast.

Very true on both those counts.
Still experience is always a good guide on how teams perform.

 

[Jivlain]

Unusual situation these days!

	Collingwood	Brisbane
(0 to 10 games)	1	1
0 to 24 games	1	2
25 to 49 games	2	2
50 to 99 games	8	2
100 to 199 games	6	14
200+ games	5	2
Games played	138.59	124.18
Age	27.83	26.52
Height	187.64	187.77
Finals played	8.05	7.36

Interactive version