ins and outs Rd17

[FREO81]

The same Webster that is pretty slow even though your looking for speed?
ANd the same Browne that has only played reserves at WAFL level in his comeback from another injury?
Oh and the same Thornton that provides excellent run fro defense and has been sensational since returning to the side?

Your ins and outs are very laughable.

Webster straight replacement for Dodd.
Schammer in for Macca
Farmer in for Thornton.
So hows that laughable. Webster BOG for Royals. Can do Dodds job better than Thornton. Takes strong marks, can kick long, can play foward or back or midfield, can tag and oh yeah he can run. Maybe not as fast as Thornton but Webster is a better choice. Just look at who i swapped for who at the the start of my post.

if you look carefully and read stats Browne is an EMG and his comeback game in wafl res was outstanding. And if your unhappy with browne then i can put peake in seeing Havey said he should be alright instead of browne.

 

[westy1]

it may be a little left field but what about asking roger to run with g ablett jnr ,harvs seems keen to bring roger into the game,cant see macca keeping up with gazza myself,
worthy of discussion?
if peaky comes back then ignore this suggestion

 

[Hap Hapablap]

NEXT YEAR !!! Mate, it will be an assualt this year, or none !!
You watch !

dont worry sumavich if you go to the wce board ive put yous in the 8 (7th position) harveys a godsend!

 

[pistol17]

Id say the guys in the mix for a run are Foster, Ibbotson, Haddrill, Dunn and the Wiz

 

[rgauci]

Everyone needs to take the red rose tinted glasses off. If Warnock was 25 years old you would want him dropped for Sandilands. I know he has shown heaps of potential, but at this stage we need results not potential.

Warnock will cement a spot by next year. But at this stage Gilmore provides more around the ground. And Sandilands is a bigger tank and less likely to be muscled around the contest.

Ottens/Blake is a different kettle of fish in comparison with Hudson/Maric. If we went in with Warnock/Gilmore they will muscle them out of the ruck duel and i can see Geelong getting 1st use.

IN: Farmer, Sandilands
OUT: Dodd, Warnock

I'd also be tempted to swap Mundy for Haddrill depending on his WAFL form.

 

[Bradesmaen]

Pfft, Warnock is doing alright and we are almost out of a finals spot, whats the harm in playing him? Its good to get games and confidence into the bodies before he needs to take the next step a year later.

 

[Ripper]

Pfft, Warnock is doing alright and we are almost out of a finals spot, whats the harm in playing him? Its good to get games and confidence into the bodies before he needs to take the next step a year later.

The bolded part is the key. I don't think they have played Big nockers in two games in a row yet.

Interestingly Harves has flagged up to five changes.

 

[dugrene]

The bolded part is the key. I don't think they have played Big nockers in two games in a row yet.

Interestingly Harves has flagged up to five changes.

Round 11 10/06/2007 Tigers
Round 12 16/06/2007 Bulldogs

Not like you Rip.

 

[Ripper]

Round 11 10/06/2007 Tigers
Round 12 16/06/2007 Bulldogs

Not like you Rip.

Caught out!! Next time I will check the stats.

 

[dont bowl there]

Round 11 10/06/2007 Tigers
Round 12 16/06/2007 Bulldogs

Not like you Rip.

He played in round 11, 12, 13 and 14! Rip was well off the mark.