Ins And Outs v Dorks

[Timmy from Thomastown]

In J Cloke Licuria
Out Wakelin Pendlebury

Consider Davis in for Morrison

I'd also play T Cloke at CHF and play Rocca off the bench as second ruck.

 

[Dazman]

In: J. Cloke
Out: Wakelin

If Lica/Davis are coming back into the side its gotta be for Morrison/Lonie. Lonie could do with a game in the magoo's to get confidence back. Lets persist with Pendles.

 

[Lockyer24]

In: Licuria J Cloke Rowe
Out: Morrison (dud) Wakelin (injured) Pendlebury (rested)

 

[Murray]

In Shaw Cloke
Out Morrison Wakelin

 

[Coin_Toss]

Out: Morrison Wakelin
In: Rowe J Cloke

Consider Shaw in for Davies

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

I'd bring Shaw back in for Morrison, rather than Rowe, because like him or not, Morrison DOES play a defensive role, and we'll need someone else to do that when he finally gets dropped.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

What happened to Lica and Rhyce? Also whats with Davis?

 

[CarnthePies]

All play dud games the other week, nothing serious.

 

[jefffff34]

Consider Shaw in for Davies

Davies was great, why would you drop him?

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Davies was great, why would you drop him?

Theres no way they'll drop Davies.

 

[Jabso]

IN: L.Davis, H.O'Brien
OUT: C.Morrison, S.Wakelin

With Wakelin out we need more cover in that area, O'Brien offers alot of consistancy. Lica can either be rested or played at Willy.


B: H.Shaw, S.Prestigiacomo, J.Clement
HB: R.Lonie, T.Cloke, T.Lockyer

C: C.Egan, B.Holland, D.Thomas

HF: S.O'Bree, C.Tarrant, N.Buckley
F: S.Burns, A.Rocca, A.Didak

R: J.Fraser, B.Johnson, S.Burns

Int: B.Davies, S.Pendlebury, H.O'Brien, L.Davis
Emg: P.Licuria, J.Rowe, J.Cloke

 

[Nesian]

I dunno, I wouldn't mind seeing licuria get another weeks rest prehaps, depending on how he is feeling and what not. But if he is 100% ready then sure bring him back in.

I think Morrison(he should no longer be in the team after another crap display), Pendles(yeah rested i think too). Wakelin out for the obvious injury reason.

Surely J Cloke and Rowe sound like they deserve a call up after a good game in the 2s. R Shaw also would be a possiblitie if Morrison did get dropped, need a defensive option as vinnie said. Davis is another option, but I dont think we actually struggled in the forward line this week and still have enough options to stretch the Hawks young defence, but is Davis 100% anyway?

Pity Fraser doesnt really have much of a back up, what happened to guy richards, still injured??

Ins: J. Cloke, Licuria/Rowe, Davis/R Shaw
Out: Morrison, Wakelin, Pendles

 

[doppleganger]

malthouse has come out in the paper saying that cloke is the back up for wakes, presti & clem.........he played a good game against pav so surely he could handle dixon!!

if he doesn't play jason it would be career over at collingwood situation

morrison is giving us nothing, he has lost confidence in himself, think the players too became a bit wary of him having the ball.............if based on form he must go

trav was also ordinary down back, would keep him in the team tho use him up forward as part of a three man ruck-tall forward rotation with fraser & rocca

davies has to stay in the team, he deserves a couple of games in a row, always performs at willi and was good on satday

give licca a few weeks off now to get over any niggles, we will need him at his best in the finals

maxwell a couple more games at willi to regain, confidence, touch

so

IN - J.Cloke, R.Shaw
OUT - Wakes, Chad

 

[Lonie_from_50]

IN: Jason Cloke, Rhyce Shaw
OUT: Shane Wakelin, Chad Morrison

 

[goalpie]

Considering Rocca had run out of puff 15 minutes into the first term he might need some time down at willy. How come hes so out of condition.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Considering Rocca had run out of puff 15 minutes into the first term he might need some time down at willy. How come hes so out of condition.

You never know around this time of year - It might just have been a chest cold or something, but then again, he's been out of form for a month now.

I've heard that he might be carrying an injury, so there might be something to that too.

 

[Pemby]

In: J Cloke, Licuria, R Shaw
Out: Wakelin (inj), Lockyer (rest), Morrison (omitted)

 

[MarkT]

Out: Morrison, Wakelin.
In: Rhyce Shaw, Licuria.

Consider J. Cloke if Hawthorn’s side requires a taller replacement for Wakelin. O’Brien is worth consideration also. Lockyer must be close to the door.