Remove this Banner Ad

Ins & Outs vs Geelong

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
lamaros said:
I don't mean to be rude. But chances are when a thread is 6 pages long there'll be a few thoughts posted on the various possibilities already. ;)
Click to expand...

No, I wasn’t being sarcastic or bagging you at all, I was actually being serious. LOL. Its hard to detect sarcasm and so on over the internet isn’t it . My fault, Sorry.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

dont think cj is ready..
needs a game or two in the ressies..get some confidence up..
mcphee was f****** unbelieveable at CHF after lucas went down last week so why not move McPhee to CHF and bring in another pacy midfielder/forward.
eg. lovett,winderlich (if fit) even magin if he gets promoted lol prob not but if he did why not but monfries would be my main man i think
 
donsman4eva said:
Geez, how many Dyson doomsayers are there in this thred. Pre season everyone was singing his praises, then he has one bad game and everyone is on his back again.

In all honesty, yes, he did play a bad game, but does he deserved to be dropped? He was one of our best players in the NAB cup. That must count for something.
Click to expand...

Never have and never will, plays like an average U/16 kid. From what Ive read he didnt set the world on fire against West Coast. I think people are forgetting that he isnt a rookie, played his 50th game on Monday. How many times has his VFL form demanded a match?
 
Merv Neagle said:
Not me, he's no good and i have always said it.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?p=10022578&postcount=3
Click to expand...

Dead agreed Merv. If he was playing his 1st season I'd cut him some slack, but he is in his 4th season and is still as useless as his 1st season. Until he can continually hit targets he should be nowhere near the AFL side. People bag Monfries, but at least he hit targets, he may not be as quick as Dyson but he hits targets. No point being quick if the pass is 5 metres from your own player!:thumbsdown:
 
donsman4eva said:
Geez, how many Dyson doomsayers are there in this thred. Pre season everyone was singing his praises, then he has one bad game and everyone is on his back again.
Click to expand...

Merv Neagle said:
Not me, he's no good and i have always said it.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?p=10022578&postcount=3
Click to expand...

I expressed my long-term faith in him in the same thread & I'm not going to retract it from one poor performance:

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?p=10022581&postcount=4

Knights showed great faith in him because he obviously sees something in him worthwhile nurturing for at least 2 years. He'll therefore continue to give him opportunities to prove himself for at least another couple of weeks.
 
Charliebrow 16 said:
Skipped a few pages of this thread cos i'm sick of reading so here's my team. I don't usually select teams preffering to leave it to the self proclaimed experts here on Bigfooty...

Lonergan played a great game, did some very good things and had a few nice runs on the wings. I think he did enough to retain his spot.

Dyson was disappointing and i think he deserves another round to prove himself but in saying that, we can't afford to have him in the side against Geelong. Maybe bring him back in a few weeks.

I'm thinking that Welsh still may need another week to get himself right and that's why he isn't selected, however if he is deemed fit then bring him back in at the expense of maybe Slats?

If we need forward targets then maybe bring back CJ but i'd rather this not happen. Laycock and Hille can rest in the forward line and cause problems for the Geelong defense. Neagle may be in line for selection if his ankle is 100% to rotate up FF/CHF with Lloydy.
It's very hard to drop players from a team that won by nearly 10 goals...

Out - Lucas, Dyson
In - Lovett, Winderlich (if fit)
Click to expand...




Ahhh....the great Dyson conundrum. What are we to do with him? Two year contract sounds like a life time away. Fans are divided,footy 'experts' are confused on how to write about him..the coaching staff must be pulling their hair out.

Bet young Ricky is spewin now he didnt take up Freo's offer. He'd get a game for sure:thumbsu:


Winderlich and Lovett have to come in.
Dyson out and Lonergan too probably.
 
From all reports Lovett's game at Bendigo wasn't anything special. Wait until he's back in form.

I would make the obvious change:

Out: Lucas (inj)
In: Winderlich


We don't need another tall - a runner to rotate would help after last weeks effort, and a 6 day break.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top