Is Kozzi Pickett a top 10 player

[Lingsface]

It will come back to hurt them.
Seriously, other than Greene, how many league footballers in the modern era listed under 5ft'11 have become perennial household names and worthy of 900k per annum?

Rioli, Betts, Neale? and it gets thin thereafter.

I was answering to this post.

 

[yulong]

Top 10 worst players at Melboure? Absolutely.

Seething with jealousy...

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

Definitely a top 10 player at Melbourne, knocking off the likes of Bowey and Salem to be crowned third in their B&F in a season where they went 7-16.

 

[Shooter#17]

Daicos, Butters, Ablett, LeCras were all 6ft' and over.

And I don't really assess greatness by Brownlow medals as they are a midfielders award and the likes of Carey, Matthews, Bontempelli have never won it despite being the best in the competition for a number of years.

And Serong, is he really a household name. I mean certainly not here in Victoria he's not.

None of Daicos butters or ablett are 6ft . Lachie neale goes alright also

 

[My Tilly]

None of Daicos butters or ablett are 6ft . Lachie neale goes alright also

Strange bump.

And yes, Daicos and Ablett were 6 foot while Butters at 181cm is just a tad off the mark.

 

[Shooter#17]

Strange bump.

And yes, Daicos and Ablett were 6 foot while Butters at 181cm is just a tad off the mark.

Keep doubling down on your stupidity, none of them are 6 ft, Daicos is 182 which has recently been changed to 184 as he has a complex, ablett is also 182 . Do you even know what height 6ft is?

 

[My Tilly]

Keep doubling down on your stupidity, none of them are 6 ft, Daicos is 182 which has recently been changed to 184 as he has a complex, ablett is also 182 . Do you even know what height 6ft is?

I understand you started this thread and as such, implied Pickett was a top 10 player in the game.
He subsequently made the All Australian team but failed to win your best and fairest.
Finished with under 20 disposals and precisely 2 goals per game. Excellent effort.
Would not get near the top 10 players in the game if you ran a poll. If you had the balls, you would have added that option.

And yes, 182cm is virtually rounded to 6 feet tall, lol, not even sure why you are making this such a big deal.

As I stated previously, very few players under this height have become all time greats of their sport. Pickett will be no different.

Keep on bumping this thread mate as I look forward to quoting you next year when Pickett takes a backward step in season 2026

 

[PowerfulPies2023]

Yes. Or maybe no. Or maybe. Or maybe both. Or all three.



What.

 

[PowerfulPies2023]

Can we also turn this thread into - Kozzy Pickett - Can he be the GOAT

Can he? He already is.

 

[Shooter#17]

I understand you started this thread and as such, implied Pickett was a top 10 player in the game.
He subsequently made the All Australian team but failed to win your best and fairest.
Finished with under 20 disposals and precisely 2 goals per game. Excellent effort.
Would not get near the top 10 players in the game if you ran a poll. If you had the balls, you would have added that option.

And yes, 182cm is virtually rounded to 6 feet tall, lol, not even sure why you are making this such a big deal.

As I stated previously, very few players under this height have become all time greats of their sport. Pickett will be no different.

Keep on bumping this thread mate as I look forward to quoting you next year when Pickett takes a backward step in season 2026

Lmfao finished under 20d a game by a whopping 0.4 , and of course he didn't win the b&f he missed the first 3 games and the side has Max gawn who was utterly dominant.
Dod nick daicos win the b&f? Must be nowhere near a top 10 player in the game ...

I've come across some imbeciles on big footy but you take the cake numpty

 

[Seattle Mariners]

Not top 10 but certainly top 25.

 

[HairyO]

Not top 10 but certainly top 25.

Lets wait for Robbo's list before we get too certain about anything.

 

[Lingsface]

100 percent now.

 

[Equatic Doom]

Yup

 

[StartTheCarr]

100 percent now.

If he does it every week yes. Def top 20.

 

[keithrichards]

If he does it every week yes. Def top 20.

If he does what every week? 29 and 4

 

[M Malice]

Awesome player, elite pace and evasion, great kick, a game breaker/X factor player of the highest calibre.

 

[Cmarsh]

100 percent now.

Not saying he's better than Nick Daicos, but he's doing things Nick Daicos can't do.

 

[Mr Meow]

Player Ratings have Pickett in the top 10 for 2026 as of now. The list is as follows (for players with 4+ games):

1. Petracca
2. Heeney
3. Butters
4. Bontempelli
5. Daicos
6. Gawn
7. Pickett
8. Grundy
9. Smith
10. Watson

Goodwin was coaching 4 of these players not that long ago! And Oliver is about 15th.

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Surely people figured this out 12+ months ago?

Moreso top 5 for quite a while

 

[M Malice]

IIRC there were lots of takes on Big Footy that Kysaiah was taken too early in the 2019 draft by the Demons.

 

[Former Decathlete]

If he does it every week yes. Def top 20.

When was the last time Butters or Daicos had 4 goals and 29 disposals

Yes that's right. Never. And they never will.

 

[AFLOnline]

Surely people figured this out 12+ months ago?

Moreso top 5 for quite a while

Top 5?
Daicos, Bont, Butters, Heeney, Gawn, Petracca, Grundy? Who’s he ahead of here

Amazing game last night against Richmond but I think people are knee jerking a bit

 

[Fadge]

When was the last time Butters or Daicos had 4 goals and 29 disposals

Yes that's right. Never. And they never will.

When was the last time Kozzy finished top 25 in either the Brownlow or Coaches Award, or top 2 in his club Best and Fairest?

 

[Fadge]

Top 5?
Daicos, Bont, Butters, Heeney, Gawn, Petracca, Grundy? Who’s he ahead of here

Amazing game last night against Richmond but I think people are knee jerking a bit

Throw in Rowell, Anderson, Serong and the best key position players such as Andrews, Thilthorpe and Cameron, and we're looking at circa Top 20 for Pickett, and that's allowing for his inconsistency.