Gone Critical
Moderator
- Moderator
- #51
To do that Collingwood have to drop Didak, Davis, Medhurst, Cloke and Anthony to the VFL come Finals time.
How much longer are Collingwood going to ignore these same blokes year in year out going missing in Finals.
With these imposters playing for them I can't see Collingwood winning anything.
I suppose you can still dream, but I bet you still believe in the Tooth Fairy.![]()
Tazhawk , possibly in the Appleisle you are considered a rapier wit but a little knowledge doesnt go astray
Cant argue with your assessment for Davis but
Didak has had many great finals matches over his career 07 semi in Perth, 03 Qual Final spring to mind off the top of the head
Cloke Won best finals player in 2007 series, 3 excellent matches
Anthony Given 2009 was his 1st full season of AFL seniors and he did kick the winning goal in the Semi V Adelaide your idea he has been "missing in finals year in year out" seems lame
Medhurst Injury plagued 2009 but excellent finals record 2007-8
I give you a score of 1/5.
I understand that gets you a pass in Tassie so well done




