Club History Is Robbie Gray our greatest ever of the AFL period?

[Macca19]

Kane was better than Burgoyne in the GF

 

[Jones2ByrneJones]

Thurstans should have won the Norm imo

 

[bomberclifford]

Troy Chaplin did some excellent stealth work off the bench.

 

[Tibbs]

I cheered louder than anyone else in the stadium! That medal should have been mine ... Ripped off!

 

[70sDinosaur]

I think Tredrea is the best CHF to have played since Carey and I'd have him at number 1.

I think Gray has overtaken Wanganeen for number 2. I'd have Gav at number 3 now and probably C. Cornes at number 4, with Primus rounding out the top 5.

After that, there's a group of players including the likes of Boak, Francou, James, P. Burgoyne, K. Cornes, Lade and Wingard that I'd struggle to place in order. Some of them would have longevity in their favour while others would have sheer talent and impact.

There are a few players in the current team who may shake up the list in the next decade or so.

 

[MALTSY]

1. Tredrea
2. Wanganeen
3. R.Gray
4. C.Cornes
5. Boak

 

[longdonkey]

Francou and Ladey not getting much love in these lists

 

[Vagabond0]

Thought they treated Tredrea short last week at the Saints game.

Understand it was Anzac day and time was short but he took the effort to come out with the kids and felt they cut him short.

He probably didn't mind but personally not how I like to see anyone treated, let alone one of our greats.

 

[PJ Power]

Yeah, nah, for me it’s

1. Butters
2. Tredrea
3. Georgiades
4. Gray
5. Wanganeen

 

[Andre]

Tredrea wouldn't have accepted last night's performance against a team for the 4th time in a row and would have stepped up and made others come along. Prior to him playing on fumes I can't think of any times of the top of my head we were completely embarrassed by the same side multiple times in a row.

 

[PAFC_1870]

1. Tredrea
2. Wanganeen
3. R.Gray
4. C.Cornes
5. Boak

I don't mind this, but I think Wanganeen falls a bit lower given he had some of his best years before, arguably given the Brownlow.

Still top 5.

 

[FishingRick04]

Francou and Ladey not getting much love in these lists

games played works against them. Especially Francou, who easily could have been a Brownlow medalist also if it wasn’t for the s**t votes we get from
umpires.

isn’t he coaching Sydney as an assistant now?

 

[longdonkey]

games played works against them. Especially Francou, who easily could have been a Brownlow medalist also if it wasn’t for the sh*t votes we get from
umpires.

isn’t he coaching Sydney as an assistant now?

I thought he was at Gold Coast his son should be getting close to draftable age.

 

[FishingRick04]

I thought he was at Gold Coast his son should be getting close to draftable age.

Yes he is