Is the divide between SANFL and AFL a bridge too far?

Dalphonso

Premiership Player
Joined
Oct 10, 2009
Posts
3,716
Likes
1,855
Location
Alice Springs NT
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Territory Thunder,Waratahs FC
Thread starter #1
I know I quite often stir a few of you up stating the SANFL was only ever the "B " grade which always gets a bite but has the chasm between the 2 leagues now become that great that it is now not a lot better than the Great Southern league down Victor way?
Blokes like Mitchell.Young ,Moore and Ah Chee burn it up in the SANFL fully warranting a place in the AFL side. But when they get there the pace and pressure is far too quick for them.They are only spot fillers at best and soon find themselves back in the magoos where they are superstars once more.
Monfries who arguably has been quite pathetic this year in my opinion goes back and dominates like Russell Ebert no doubt earning a recall next week where no doubt he might play serviceable at best.
Obviously there is not a lot we can do about it unless we play in the actual VFL one day but I personally don't think our seconds are getting the development they need in the SANFL.
Perhaps this is just one reason amongst many why our season has faltered so badly in the big league this year? I know a few of you will come out and say the SANFL is the best second tier league etc .Didn't WA beat them this year? It is more of a third tier league nowadays.
I guess we are still in a better position than the God Coast and Brisbanes seconds in the Qld league.They are really up against it.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Jim Dixon

Club Legend
Joined
Aug 5, 2013
Posts
2,946
Likes
4,107
Location
Canada
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
#2
God Coast and Brisbane have reserve teams in the NEAFL League. They play against such spuds as the Sydney Swans reserves, the GWS reserves, the NT Thunder and Sydney University.

As to your question, there's no doubt the gap is growing wider in terms of skills, and it really grinds my gears that the SANFL is allowed to have such a divergence in terms of rule (does any other league play with 21 players and have '25 meter penalties'?). However your average SANFL club will be full of mature bodied blokes who are hard at it even if they lack the skill and polish of an AFL listed team. Look at how much trouble Norwood gives to us. I can see the day when we don't benefit at all from playing in the SANFL but I do not think we're there yet.

Having said that, the SNAFL are a pack of arseholes who can all gagf; we should have a genuine AFL reserves competition and cut our links with the SNAFL entirely. But that's just my tuppny ha'pence worth. Your milage may vary.
 

scottjr

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 8, 2012
Posts
5,718
Likes
4,332
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
#3
The sanfl will do until there is a fully fledged AFL reserve competition. I don't think we are disadvantaged in the sanfl although I'm sure we learn more about where players are at during the week in match simulation drills.
 

Dalphonso

Premiership Player
Joined
Oct 10, 2009
Posts
3,716
Likes
1,855
Location
Alice Springs NT
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Territory Thunder,Waratahs FC
Thread starter #4
God Coast and Brisbane have reserve teams in the NEAFL League. They play against such spuds as the Sydney Swans reserves, the GWS reserves, the NT Thunder and Sydney University.

As to your question, there's no doubt the gap is growing wider in terms of skills, and it really grinds my gears that the SANFL is allowed to have such a divergence in terms of rule (does any other league play with 21 players and have '25 meter penalties'?). However your average SANFL club will be full of mature bodied blokes who are hard at it even if they lack the skill and polish of an AFL listed team. Look at how much trouble Norwood gives to us. I can see the day when we don't benefit at all from playing in the SANFL but I do not think we're there yet.

Having said that, the SNAFL are a pack of arseholes who can all gagf; we should have a genuine AFL reserves competition and cut our links with the SNAFL entirely. But that's just my tuppny ha'pence worth. Your milage may vary.
Good call.
I knew the Qld teams played against GWS and the Nt Thunder(I think they played here in Alice yesterday?)But couldn't remember what they changed the name to but NEAFL is correct. As of last week I believe the NT thunder was third on the ladder with a team full of no names who are in no way good enough for AFL. So that particular league is a real shocker. I used to follow the Thunder but now I don't care.
 

*PAF

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Feb 17, 2005
Posts
21,573
Likes
9,393
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
#8
Nah.We still need to work out that now the SANFL only exists to develop our AFL players. The Magpie were the past, the Power is the future.
The king is dead, long live the king.


Good SANFL form means frk all in the scheme if things as there will always be players that play poop at SANFL level and great at AFL level, and vice versa.
Deliberately put the poop first as atm we looove the vice versa stuff and completely ignore the first part.

Get it right Kern. Fix it.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
Apr 23, 2010
Posts
8,842
Likes
7,070
Location
Adelaide, SA
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Greendale Human Beings
#12
Blokes like Mitchell.Young ,Moore and Ah Chee burn it up in the SANFL fully warranting a place in the AFL side. But when they get there the pace and pressure is far too quick for them.They are only spot fillers at best and soon find themselves back in the magoos where they are superstars once more.
Add Sam Gray, Amon, Colquhoun, Neade, Stewart, Clurey and OShea to that list.

The gap is wide and getting wider by the year.
 

PA88

Premiership Player
Joined
Apr 6, 2014
Posts
3,316
Likes
3,223
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
#13
So WA beat SA and now SA is a third tier league? I don't think so. They are both at the same level. They are both amateur leagues with two AFL sides playing development young players. I think the argument is different with the vfl. The sanfl is a tough league for these 18 to 22 year old afl draftees.

Our problem in the sanlf is not ability, it is skill execution. It is annoying to watch sanfl teams kick and handball the ball better than us weekly. What differs is how many times we're able to get our hands on the ball and how much one on one pressure we put on the opposition. Our pressure this season has been inconsistent.
 

Jim Dixon

Club Legend
Joined
Aug 5, 2013
Posts
2,946
Likes
4,107
Location
Canada
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
#14
Maybe check the ladder Giants are no spuds.


Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
Ah sorry to offend, I was actually using the potato phrase sardonically in response to the suggestion that the Qld AFL teams have reserves in the Qld league. I'm getting to the point that the Port Magpies would be better off in the NEAFL.
 

General Giant

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Apr 12, 2012
Posts
29,522
Likes
20,719
AFL Club
GWS
#15
Ah sorry to offend, I was actually using the potato phrase sardonically in response to the suggestion that the Qld AFL teams have reserves in the Qld league. I'm getting to the point that the Port Magpies would be better off in the NEAFL.
As someone whose reserves play in said comp. No you wouldnt.

The competition is terrible. A national reserves is whats needed.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
 

ROBBBO

Club Legend
Joined
Mar 17, 2014
Posts
1,310
Likes
1,874
Location
Adelaide, South Australia
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Rangers, Leeds Utd
#19
Coming from a soccer background I can't believe the two competitions are played with different rules, absolutely absurd. You see young players coming up having to change their style where they can hold the ball in in SNAFL yet pinged for the same in AFL. I notice the young players give up a lot of ball in and under in AFL where they rush handballs out etc. It is a ridiculous situation that SANFL play their own rules.. anyway I think this doesnt help with the divide
 

Portology

Cheap, fast, safe: pick two, or juggle three.
Joined
Sep 27, 2007
Posts
7,991
Likes
7,261
Location
Sydney
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Manchester United, Barcelona
#20
The ******* rules are different, and that is annoying. Every interpretation is different. This is why we need an AFL ran reserves competition.
It's far more than annoying, it's ****ing unacceptable for a development league.

Not the primary source of our current malaise though.
 

Waspy79

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 14, 2008
Posts
8,853
Likes
7,403
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
The Arsenal
#21
The ******* rules are different, and that is annoying. Every interpretation is different. This is why we need an AFL ran reserves competition.
Serious question - what rules are different apart from the 25 metre penalty?

Every interpretation is different from week to week and from umpire to umpire in the AFL too, I see this as a non-issue in terms of player development.
 

General Giant

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Apr 12, 2012
Posts
29,522
Likes
20,719
AFL Club
GWS
#22
Serious question - what rules are different apart from the 25 metre penalty?

Every interpretation is different from week to week and from umpire to umpire in the AFL too, I see this as a non-issue in terms of player development.
Do u think we need an AFL reserves comp?

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
 

ab56452001

Club Legend
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Posts
1,605
Likes
810
Location
salisbury
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
#24
I know I quite often stir a few of you up stating the SANFL was only ever the "B " grade which always gets a bite but has the chasm between the 2 leagues now become that great that it is now not a lot better than the Great Southern league down Victor way?
Blokes like Mitchell.Young ,Moore and Ah Chee burn it up in the SANFL fully warranting a place in the AFL side. But when they get there the pace and pressure is far too quick for them.They are only spot fillers at best and soon find themselves back in the magoos where they are superstars once more.
Monfries who arguably has been quite pathetic this year in my opinion goes back and dominates like Russell Ebert no doubt earning a recall next week where no doubt he might play serviceable at best.
Obviously there is not a lot we can do about it unless we play in the actual VFL one day but I personally don't think our seconds are getting the development they need in the SANFL.
Perhaps this is just one reason amongst many why our season has faltered so badly in the big league this year? I know a few of you will come out and say the SANFL is the best second tier league etc .Didn't WA beat them this year? It is more of a third tier league nowadays.
I guess we are still in a better position than the God Coast and Brisbanes seconds in the Qld league.They are really up against it.
The only gap widening is the physicality one , when its wet and tough footy is the name of the game many Afl listed blokes go missing . A few years ago some moaned when our Afl listed blokes struggled to get an A grade game at SANFL level , bias we screamed , well I watched a few of ours and the Crows play , and they didn't deserve an a grade game . Don't know if its the types we pick , but when the games played in shitty condition ( Norwood , Sturt ) we really go missing.
 
Top Bottom