Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Isaac Cumming

  • Thread starter Thread starter crow2crow
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

DJ75 said:
Pretty average season in the end from Cumming. A few good games, a few great moments and then the most bruise free finals series I've seen.
Looked terrified to go near anyone.
Should NOT be a lock for starting 18 come round 1 next year.
Click to expand...
On that note I'd say that only Dawson, Worrell and RT should be 100% rolled gold locked in for Rd 1 next year.
 
skam85 said:
On that note I'd say that only Dawson, Worrell and RT should be 100% rolled gold locked in for Rd 1 next year.
Click to expand...

Based on Nicks running the side into the ground in 2023, i would not be surprised if he did the same thing in 2025 and our recruits like so many of our other players just ran out of legs. Not making excuses but all 3 dropped off significantly. Its just a thought.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Scorpus said:
Dan Curtin was obviously the better wing but even then he only averaged 13.4 disposals this season, which is worse than an average Mackay season back in the day
Click to expand...
Worse than a lot the wingers weve had who are vastly inferior players.

Staggering that youve got 2 of your better marks, and kickers of the ball not getting used.
 
AFC979810 said:
Careful mate. You will get the wroth of the Cummings fans.

First they will try and tell you how good he is. When that fails they will tell you we dont use wingers and that 19 year old Curtin was almost as bad.
Click to expand...
Nice driveby.

You like stats, theyre there for everyone to see. Your choice whether you look at them.
 
Only missed one game given his injury history in the past few years is a positive in regard to regaining confidence in his body, we saw the same with Milera last year who played very tentative compared to this year.
 
AFC979810 said:
Where are the Cumming fans?

Player A Cumming.

Player B Murphy.
Click to expand...
Not this year!

Murphy was awful.

No way was Murphy anywhere near as good as Cumming this season.
 
I still don't know how people were convinced Cumming was better than this? He peaked 3 years ago and has regressed ever since.

His season was probably better than could have been reasonably anticipated.
 
Interloperer said:
I still don't know how people were convinced Cumming was better than this? He peaked 3 years ago and has regressed ever since.

His season was probably better than could have been reasonably anticipated.
Click to expand...
He's another icing player, which is fine, because now we have to go out and get more cake
 

Remove this Banner Ad

He‘a not the problem

The gameplan, and by proxy the lack of focus on our midfield due to Nicks being a shit coach, is the problem

Give our team a better midfield, and he’ll be more effective
 
Without being disrespectful, it would be good to see him going well but gee he’s been underwhelming this season so far. Have to start asking the question of his spot and this may be unpopular but I’m considering asking him to find some form in the 2s in favour of building confidence in Edwards rather than the automatic drop when daws is back …
 
I’m not a fan. Hes played a couple of good quarters but that’s about it. Massive disappointment. Brayden Cook has played more good games than Cumming since Cumming came over, and Cook played only a few games last year.

I honestly cannot understand how anyone can defend his performance. If he was a first year player he’d be playing 2s.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Temu David Mackay on double the salary.
 
We've swapped Cumming and Cook's role around now. Cumming is in that Chayce Jones defensive side role which is not one that is conducive to actually getting the ball. It's all shape keeping and defensive running for the most part.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom