Remove this Banner Ad

It's all over!!!

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

gocatsgo

Club Legend
Apr 30, 2000
1,052
9
Melbourne
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Reading
It's official, we have LOST the trophy!

And once again it was our fearless skipper that has cost us the game.

2 terrible mistakes in the last few overs have handed India victory.

1. Bowling Colin Miller without a second slip and a gully, quite simply the dumbest move he has ever made. 3 nicks later India have gone from 19 behind with 3 wickets left to 9 behind with 3 wickets left (2,4,4)

2. Not attacking fully when they still needed 8 to win. ie not having a third slip. Yet another nick, this time off Gillespie that would have gone straight into the breadbasket of third slip, instead it goes for 4.

Two crucial errors that have quite simply cost Australia a test series win in India.

They will say that it has been the most competitive series in history. RUBBISH!

Australia let India off the hook in the second test as well as the third. Australia are simply a better team. It was only 3 players - perhaps 4 (and a suspect umpire)that were the difference in the series. The players are Singh, who terrorised the Australian's imparticular Ponting, Gilchrist and Warne, Laxman who's innings in Calcutta turned the match and Steve Waugh who cost Australia a massive first innings total by handling the ball and by his failure to tighten the screws when Australia had a chance of winning. The 4th player I speak about is Ricky Ponting. The only supposed batsman in the entire series to not get at least 50 in total runs - not in an innings. 100 or so runs from him over the course of the tests and the results would have been far different, he was our Ganguly, Ganguly never played well but still made enough to be a contributor.
 
Australia's biggest mistake in this test was not to bowl McGrath a bit earlier. I think Steve Waugh persisted with Miller just a bit too long. To be honest, two of Miller's wickets were bought (especially the dismissal of Laxman - that was entirely due to Waugh's athleticism). McGrath would have put more pressure on the middle to late order.

But to be brutally honest, the game was India's to lose rather than Australia's to win. Nerves got the wickets of Ramesh, Ganguly, Laxman and Bahutule. Even Tendulkar would probably have played a more confident stroke to Gillespie's short ball under different circumstances.

Steve Waugh did all he could to bring us into this contest. 154 is simply not defendable, no matter how close we came to actually achieving it. Barring Hayden, our batting rarely rose to adequate. Our bowling was carried by McGrath - without him we would have been murdered. And to think that Kumble was missing - it could have been worse.
 
Wonderful game, a privilege to watch. Brilliant test match cricket, this game demonstrated how much better test cricket is compared to one day cricket.

I also thought Dighe was out leg before to McGrath. Hit just outside the line but when you consider he wasn't playing a shot and some of the decisions earlier in the series, it probably should have been given out. May not have made a difference but we would have had a better chane at victory.

Btw, M.Waugh catching, in particular the one off Laxman, was absolutely sensational on the last day. Magnificent stuff.
 
Originally posted by gocatsgo:

And once again it was our fearless skipper that has cost us the game.

1. Bowling Colin Miller without a second slip and a gully, quite simply the dumbest move he has ever made. 3 nicks later India have gone from 19 behind with 3 wickets left to 9 behind with 3 wickets left (2,4,4)


No gocatsgo,
he took the fielders out to stop the quick singels and put pressure on them. Miller simply dropped them short.
God I hate armchair critics like you. With them chasing 155, getting 8 wickets is a brilliant effort. Especially aginist the likes of Tendulkar,Laxman,Dravid,Ganguly,Ramesh etc.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I haven't seen too many instances where an off-spinner bowls with 2 slips and a gully.

As for Waugh not attacking enough in the field, I don't know how you can blame him for the fielding positions. I'm sure you would have been the first to complain if one of the batsman was able to consistently hit the ball through square leg or the covers or wherever you wanted the slip fieldsman to come from.

Besides, I think Steve Waugh's captaincy kept us well and truly in the match. The decision to keep Miller bowling after tea almost won us the match. He did start bowling a little short towards the end of his spell but Australia would not have been at all close to a win had he not picked up those quick wickets.

------------------
Fortius Quo Fidelius
 
Congrats to the Indians...........bugger

I only listened, btw, thanks ABC for an great coverage (I'll ignore occassional technical difficulties), a couple of fielding positions seemed odd but going off the commentators it seems that you're going a bit hard on S Waugh gocatsgo.

If there's one thing I'd like to pick on our mob for it is a tendency to get carried away with some of the mind games stuff. Occassionally it concentrates a foes efforts & works to enhance their performance. While they may have got into Ganguly's head I also suspect that they may have steeled the Indians resolve to our own detriment.

Ispose comments like that just date me
biggrin.gif


[This message has been edited by karnaby (edited 23 March 2001).]
 
Gocatsgo man,get off Steve Waughs back dude.
The mans a dude.If any dudes to blame it Slater man and Ponting dude.

Warnies a brother dude so he can't be bagged [he does look like a fat David Beckham
biggrin.gif
].

Millers another brother so he's cool dude.


p.s Sorry but after listening to Greg 'YEAH YEAH' Matthews for three weeks I keep hearing 'Dude' 'Man' & 'Brotherhood' in my head
biggrin.gif
biggrin.gif
biggrin.gif
biggrin.gif


------------------
"Hey ,just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand"
 
What do you mean once again Steve Waugh cost Aust the game? What other games has he cost us?

His dismissal in the first innings (for 47) was worse than Ponting's 0 or Gilchrist's 1? I don't think so.

In a close series India won because too many Australian batsmen couldn't play Harbajan and our spinners bowled poorly (particularly Warne).
 
i thought this cricket team was invinisble...i have seen them crumble to the pressure of india twice now who are ranked 8th in the world of test cricket..Invinsible my arse
 

Remove this Banner Ad

It's all over!!!

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top