- Aug 22, 2009
- AFL Club
- Other Teams
If that is why it's been booted (best not best n fairest), that's ridiculousIf you look at Rhett's website, you can see that one criteria is that only "Best and Fairest" awards are considered. "Best Player", etc. awards are not considered "Best and Fairest". I guess that's for consistency, but personally I'd argue that "Best and Fairest" in today's terms really means "best player" as I'm not sure the coaching staff consider "fairness" in their voting anyway. I don't have a strong opinion either way.
It seems, however, that this thread is solely about Jack Dyer for some weird reason.
edit: Also on Rhett's website you can read some of the documents they used to come to their decision.