Draft Profile Jack Lukosius

[Juice0103]

A version of Westhoff that was consistent across his entire career would be a hell of a player.

yep

 

[Juice0103]

why don't carlton get a PP pick in the top 10. I know GCS are losing Lynch but we are worse than them and both teams deserve top 10 PP Picks

 

[Pablito]

If trading picks in the draft is introduced, it could be that Carlton drafts him with 1, and when it gets to pick 8 and Adelaide see rankine gone, they throw everything they have to trade us for him.

At that stage sos could collect 4 top 20 picks off Reid.

 

[Drewie11]

If trading picks in the draft is introduced, it could be that Carlton drafts him with 1, and when it gets to pick 8 and Adelaide see rankine gone, they throw everything they have to trade us for him.

At that stage sos could collect 4 top 20 picks off Reid.

You can trade picks but I am not sure you can draft a player and then try and trade that player

 

[Shaz2012]

If trading picks in the draft is introduced, it could be that Carlton drafts him with 1, and when it gets to pick 8 and Adelaide see rankine gone, they throw everything they have to trade us for him.

At that stage sos could collect 4 top 20 picks off Reid.

I thought I read somewhere that you can only trade picks for the player that has just been taken, as soon as the next pick is taken that last player is off the table.

It would make it more interesting if you could do that though. You could then actually trade for the players you want, rather than just picks where you don't know what your going to get. Would be interesting, but something that the players association may not like too much. For example, say you took Luko and Crows take Rozee and RCD. Then Carlton could actually make a decision like is Luko worth Rozee and RCD, vs pick 8 and pick 14. This wont happen this year, but I do think its a good way to do it.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

keep telling yourself that and i am sure you will wake up happy

Keep thinking your thoughts, will be upset at the outcome.

 

[Juice0103]

If trading picks in the draft is introduced, it could be that Carlton drafts him with 1, and when it gets to pick 8 and Adelaide see rankine gone, they throw everything they have to trade us for him.

At that stage sos could collect 4 top 20 picks off Reid.

drafts who?

 

[footyfan1978]

Elma Fudd

 

[Juice0103]

I think Luko is coming to Carlton. It's like saying Rayner wasn't going number 1. Luko could be a superstar and Carlton need to take a risk.

 

[M Malice]

The proposed live trading will only be the trading of picks and will not include players. If the Crows want Lukosius they will need to trade up to pick 1 BEFORE it is used on the night, once a player is taken at a particular pick that is it, he's not going anywhere.

 

[Antares]

I thought all the papers were linking Walsh to Carlton at #1? Dangerfield also said on radio if Carlton don't take him at #1, they'd regret it.

Carlton's key-forward stocks are pretty good, and while Lukosius would be a big addition to any team, I can see them opting for the midfielder because that's their big problem area right now.

That leaves Lukosius to Gold Coast. Adelaide aren't trading their way up to the top 3 picks unless there's a deal involving a good player going to the Gold Coast, which as it stands, is highly unlikely. Clarkson tried to flog Breust and Sicily among others to them, and none of them wanted to go. In the miracle chance say, a Mitch McGovern is happy to go there on big money, Adelaide will get their top 3 pick and one of Lukosius or Rankine.

 

[Antares]

I think Luko is coming to Carlton. It's like saying Rayner wasn't going number 1. Luko could be a superstar and Carlton need to take a risk.

Petracca was rated #1 all year every week in 2014 and the Saints picked McCartin.

McCluggage was rated #1 all year every week in 2016 and the Bombers picked McGrath. GWS even took Taranto ahead of him.

 

[branedotorg]

Walsh please

 

[harrisendblue]

It’s not a thread about Westhoff but his problem has been consistency, not talent.

Perhaps not generational no, though that sounds more like a buzz word to me than having any real substance, but if Westhoff had played more years like this year throughout his career he would have All-Australians and best and fairests to his name, I have no doubt.

Your correct its not about the Hoff. He was the example of the player that I believe that JL currently, based on my viewing of his output, projects to becoming. JL needs to become much better in the contest for him to being a guaranteed no 1.

 

[David C]

You can trade picks but I am not sure you can draft a player and then try and trade that player

Correct

 

[Juice0103]

Petracca was rated #1 all year every week in 2014 and the Saints picked McCartin.

McCluggage was rated #1 all year every week in 2016 and the Bombers picked McGrath. GWS even took Taranto ahead of him.

fairo

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Petracca was rated #1 all year every week in 2014 and the Saints picked McCartin.

McCluggage was rated #1 all year every week in 2016 and the Bombers picked McGrath.

2016 was an open field for most of the season and Petracca came from well back through the course of 2014.

 

[Antares]

2016 was an open field for most of the season and Petracca came from well back through the course of 2014.

So? He was rated the best player of that draft by just about everyone who follows the U18s. Who cares if he came from "well back"?

 

[GUMBLETRON]

So? He was rated the best player of that draft by just about everyone who follows the U18s. Who cares if he came from "well back"?

So Petracca wasn't "rated #1 all year every week in 2014".

 

[Antares]

So Petracca wasn't "rated #1 all year every week in 2014".

Ok, hyperbole aside, he was for most of the year.

 

[HARKER]

I thought all the papers were linking Walsh to Carlton at #1? Dangerfield also said on radio if Carlton don't take him at #1, they'd regret it.

Carlton's key-forward stocks are pretty good, and while Lukosius would be a big addition to any team, I can see them opting for the midfielder because that's their big problem area right now.

That leaves Lukosius to Gold Coast. Adelaide aren't trading their way up to the top 3 picks unless there's a deal involving a good player going to the Gold Coast, which as it stands, is highly unlikely. Clarkson tried to flog Breust and Sicily among others to them, and none of them wanted to go. In the miracle chance say, a Mitch McGovern is happy to go there on big money, Adelaide will get their top 3 pick and one of Lukosius or Rankine.

Carlton would need to listen to what may be around.
Lukosius would be a great get, but I see that Carlton may prefer the local lads.

If Lukosius is seen to be the marquee player GC want, they'd have to pay and pay now.
I may well be wrong but I don't think GC would want one of the Kings as much as they'd want Lukosius, as Lukosius would add immediate value to the club and GC have Wright already and may have to back him in to become the forward they need, post Lynch.

Maybe (I said maybe) a trade involving Carltons 2018 #1 and 2019 first can be traded for GC's 2018 #2 & #3 (Lynch compo)
GC get the marquee player of the draft, along with a possible #1 in 2019, whilst Carlton take Walsh & MKing at the draft with #2 & #3.

It's all so early though as who really knows who will have the #1 yet.

 

[Antares]

Carlton would need to listen to what may be around.
Lukosius would be a great get, but I see that Carlton may prefer the local lads.

If Lukosius is seen to be the marquee player GC want, they'd have to pay and pay now.
I may well be wrong but I don't think GC would want one of the Kings as much as they'd want Lukosius, as Lukosius would add immediate value to the club and GC have Wright already and may have to back him in to become the forward they need, post Lynch.

Maybe (I said maybe) a trade involving Carltons 2018 #1 and 2019 first can be traded for GC's 2018 #2 & #3 (Lynch compo)
GC get the marquee player of the draft, along with a possible #1 in 2019, whilst Carlton take Walsh & MKing at the draft with #2 & #3.

It's all so early though as who really knows who will have the #1 yet.

Not a chance in hell. Gold Coast want quality AFL-ready players more than anything now, especially more than 2019 picks. They sold the farm for Weller for that very reason.

They'd be more than happy to take Walsh too.

 

[Tushay]

I doubt Brisbane feel ripped off for Charlie. Looked superb and worth what they paid for him until injured. Have to remember he was contracted to Crows so they were always going to need to pay a bit more.

No, that can't be right. Check the Gibbs board.

 

[MITSUHIRATO]

He moves like a young Waylen “Cyrus” Manson

 

[Thetrader15]

Walsh please

Thank you