Question for Carlton's fans. Do you think that SOS would make the same decision next time? I personally doubt. He was genuinely shocked that Suns did not accept his offer. It was very stressful time for Martin and his partner. You don't want a player you trying to get to go through PSD. This is the last thing players want to go through. Not good image for future trades.
I think his reaction was more in regard to Papley. That's one part of the trade period I think he got wrong - he clearly thought Swans would come to the party even if the Daniher trade fell over, but they were never going to budge.
As for image:
Gold Coast: "We're making a stand! No more crappy deals. We'll redraft Martin!"
*Martin Walks*
Gold Coast: "..."
Geelong: "How about Pick 27 for Pick 11?"
Gold Coast: "Deal."