Remove this Banner Ad

Toast Jack Redden

Should Redden be dropped?

  • Yes

    Votes: 33 28.2%
  • No

    Votes: 50 42.7%
  • Mandatory Jack Watts option

    Votes: 34 29.1%

  • Total voters
    117

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Reddo's highlights definitely benefited from the beasty contested marking power of Jack and Josh. Really glad Redden found his feet in the side this year.

10 Goals out of Redden.
14 goals from Yeo
12 Goals out of Gaffy
9 goals from Hutch
8 from Dom
6 from Shuey

Almost 2.5 goals a game from the midfield makes a big difference over a season.
 
We traded pick 17 in possibly one of the worst drafts in recent history for this bloke who's just came 2nd in our bnf in a premiership year. the pick ended up at NM (Ben McKay) and the only players of note taken after the pick (in my opinion) were Dunkley (wanted to stay in Melbourne for family reasons), Cole (who we got anyway), Phillips and Menangola. Hindsight is a wonderful thing but holy hell this was a good bit of business
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Reddo's highlights definitely benefited from the beasty contested marking power of Jack and Josh. Really glad Redden found his feet in the side this year.

10 Goals out of Redden.
14 goals from Yeo
12 Goals out of Gaffy
9 goals from Hutch
8 from Dom
6 from Shuey
7 from Masten
Almost 2.5 to 3 goals a game from the midfield makes a big difference over a season.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Still don’t buy this idea that Redden played a hugely different a role/position this year compared to previous years.

Sure, Priddis left, but Yeo also played full time on-ball which he had never previously done over a long period of time.

I think he was given slightly less of a defensive role this year as Hutchings became the preferred tagger. But I think it’s a bit much to say he played HFF until 2018
 
Still don’t buy this idea that Redden played a hugely different a role/position this year compared to previous years.

Sure, Priddis left, but Yeo also played full time on-ball which he had never previously done over a long period of time.

I think he was given slightly less of a defensive role this year as Hutchings became the preferred tagger. But I think it’s a bit much to say he played HFF until 2018
Who's the opposition poster who used to come and post centre bounce rotation figures? Wonder if they have the info from last year?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

With all the talk of Kennedy, can we address this particular elephant in the room as well?

Really doesn’t have a natural place in the side with Kelly in the middle now. When X O’Neill is fit he should take that spot and add some run.

A fantastic 2018 has not been backed up - pretty emblematic of the whole side, really.
 
With all the talk of Kennedy, can we address this particular elephant in the room as well?

Really doesn’t have a natural place in the side with Kelly in the middle now. When X O’Neill is fit he should take that spot and add some run.

A fantastic 2018 has not been backed up - pretty emblematic of the whole side, really.
Yeah he's redundant now. Can't play outside with his lack of pace, especially with shortened quarters. Too similar to Sheed in speed to play midfield. One or the other this year
 
Was never the most talented guy but tried his damn hardest and we wouldn't have won the premiership without him in 2018, but yeah along with JK and Hurn is starting to look like he's at the end of his career. They should always be respected, but we need to start looking at who the replacements are going to be damn soon as it looks like this group may have run its course and needs a refresh/pruning just like we needed at the end of 2017. Pity we have no draft picks and damn average kids for the most part, which is making me feel when we drop off it might be for a bit longer this time.
 
There are so many parallels between him and Wellingham.

We know how it ended for Wellingham.

Redden averaged just over 25 disposals in his best year (2018) and is practically averaging half that (13) in his three games thus far in 2020. At 30, the pressure is mounting.
 
I can't say I have ever rated Redden. I couldn't understand why we recruited him in the first place. If I remember correctly he had a very good second half of 2018 but that was about it. Unless he is tagging, like Hutchings, there is no place for him in the side.

On another issue, why are we such a physically weak side? I have been saying it for years that we can't hold a tackle and now it looks like we barely enter the weights room.

I think the Eagles off-field need a shake up in their sports science department. Too many people have been there for too long.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Toast Jack Redden

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top