Remove this Banner Ad

Free Agency Jack Silvagni - [Joins St Kilda as UFA]

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Realistically who would actually want a player like Jack? bit of an inbetween player who gets by on his effort and desire which probably comes from his life long love for the club.

Played fantastic on Friday night vs Naughton.
 
I honestly cannot see a team that he fits better than Carlton
maybe his dad see's a need for him at the saints but will be 28 before he plays a game for a new club and has had injury concerns

3 year deal at Carlton on 500k would be his value but are Carlton better off using this cash to sure up TDK
 
I honestly cannot see a team that he fits better than Carlton
maybe his dad see's a need for him at the saints but will be 28 before he plays a game for a new club and has had injury concerns

3 year deal at Carlton on 500k would be his value but are Carlton better off using this cash to sure up TDK
Plenty of names we should be trading before Jack. One of the few that actually busts his ass every week despite being limited in terms of natural talent.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Realistically who would actually want a player like Jack? bit of an inbetween player who gets by on his effort and desire which probably comes from his life long love for the club.

Played fantastic on Friday night vs Naughton.

SOS ?.

Just to keep the theme of needing to poach Carlton players going ?.
 
Pretty sure i could delist 10 players at carlton before Jack S
Starting with McNuggets & Williams
Unfortunately Williams endless deal still has a year to run.

McGovern
Docherty
Motlop
Orazio
Evans
Haynes

Would be my first picks. If someone was willing to take Williams for a 5th rounder I'd take it.
 
Realistically who would actually want a player like Jack? bit of an inbetween player who gets by on his effort and desire which probably comes from his life long love for the club.

Played fantastic on Friday night vs Naughton.
Several teams would be interested in a ready made third tall at either end that comes without needing any trade capital

My team included
 
Several teams would be interested in a ready made third tall at either end that comes without needing any trade capital

My team included
I don't think North would tbh, and I can't really see who else would. As others have said, he's probably best placed from a career perspective at Carlton with their current list. He's not a genuine 2nd option at either end but he doesn't have to be at the Blues.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I don't think North would tbh, and I can't really see who else would. As others have said, he's probably best placed from a career perspective at Carlton with their current list. He's not a genuine 2nd option at either end but he doesn't have to be at the Blues.
thats what I am saying 3rd tall at either end

Is what teams would be after
 
Think he would be the perfect Sam Mitchell player. Just chuck a few magnets around for the fun of it.
The kind of player you'd love at the club due to his heart and versatility.

But would be behind too many with us (Everyone currently in our best 22 plus Serong and McCabe).
 
Realistically who would actually want a player like Jack? bit of an inbetween player who gets by on his effort and desire which probably comes from his life long love for the club.

Played fantastic on Friday night vs Naughton.
I'd have him in a heartbeat at the Dockers. He might not be the most skilled but always goes at 100% and gives a contest.
 
Realistically who would actually want a player like Jack? bit of an inbetween player who gets by on his effort and desire which probably comes from his life long love for the club.

Played fantastic on Friday night vs Naughton.
As much as it pains me to say about any Carlton player, based on his work as a defender this year I’d take him in a heartbeat at the pies.
Good family friends with the Daicos’ too, would be excellent to see Daics and SOS get loose in the box watching their boys play together. You just know Pete would be a bad influence 😜
 
As much as it pains me to say about any Carlton player, based on his work as a defender this year I’d take him in a heartbeat at the pies.
Good family friends with the Daicos’ too, would be excellent to see Daics and SOS get loose in the box watching their boys play together. You just know Pete would be a bad influence 😜
He's been really solid this year. His kicking is highly underrated. But pretty sure we all know the chances of a Silvagni going to the Pies is below 0
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

He's been really solid this year. His kicking is highly underrated. But pretty sure we all know the chances of a Silvagni going to the Pies is below 0
Ben Silvagni has already played for the pies VFL so you’re wrong on that count!

Jack is also good friends with Houston and the Daicos boys. Time to get nervous buddy 😜
 
Ben Silvagni has already played for the pies VFL so you’re wrong on that count!

Jack is also good friends with Houston and the Daicos boys. Time to get nervous buddy 😜
Yeah... I don't think I'll be losing any sleep over that one. Bleeds blue unlike most on our list.

Ben far less so when he started off at the Blues, didn't look like he really cared a whole lot.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top