Traded Jack Steele [Traded to Melbourne for 2027 R3 (Melb)]

[bird_man]

broken? Oliver had a better year than petracca if you actually watched some footy this year. Bargain for GWS. And are you salty just because Mackie couldn't get anything done?

2025 Keith 'Bluey' Truscott Memorial Trophy​

1. Max Gawn – 592 votes
2. Christian Petracca – 479
3. Kysaiah Pickett – 467
4. Jake Bowey – 459
5. Christian Salem – 404
6. Kade Chandler – 376
7. Clayton Oliver – 353
8. Ed Langdon – 333
9. Harvey Langford – 318
10. Jack Viney – 313

 

[Dez!]

broken? Oliver had a better year than petracca if you actually watched some footy this year. Bargain for GWS. And are you salty just because Mackie couldn't get anything done?

No, no he did not.

 

[Falchoon]

2025 Keith 'Bluey' Truscott Memorial Trophy​

1. Max Gawn – 592 votes
2. Christian Petracca – 479
3. Kysaiah Pickett – 467
4. Jake Bowey – 459
5. Christian Salem – 404
6. Kade Chandler – 376
7. Clayton Oliver – 353
8. Ed Langdon – 333
9. Harvey Langford – 318
10. Jack Viney – 313

 

[danster168]

2025 Keith 'Bluey' Truscott Memorial Trophy​

1. Max Gawn – 592 votes
2. Christian Petracca – 479
3. Kysaiah Pickett – 467
4. Jake Bowey – 459
5. Christian Salem – 404
6. Kade Chandler – 376
7. Clayton Oliver – 353
8. Ed Langdon – 333
9. Harvey Langford – 318
10. Jack Viney – 313

why are you using the bnf? as soon as the results came out all the dees fans laughed at the fact that they gave Petracca 2nd. Also, you go for stkilda, so as if you watched the dees play every week.

Oliver was always the better player, and his accolades show this, and he'll be elite for GWS.

 

[bird_man]

why are you using the bnf? as soon as the results came out all the dees fans laughed at the fact that they gave Petracca 2nd. Also, you go for stkilda, so as if you watched the dees play every week.

Oliver was always the better player, and his accolades show this, and he'll be elite for GWS.

Well if you prefer I could use the coaches votes where Petracca had 46 and Oliver has 10?

Or would I better using the Brownlow votes where Petracca got 16 and Oliver didn't get a single vote?

 

[TruRoo]

Most people should be aware by now if you are arguing with danster you are bringing a gun to a knife fight

 

[Elixuh]

broken? Oliver had a better year than petracca if you actually watched some footy this year. Bargain for GWS. And are you salty just because Mackie couldn't get anything done?

I agree with Danster.

 

[Dez!]

why are you using the bnf? as soon as the results came out all the dees fans laughed at the fact that they gave Petracca 2nd. Also, you go for stkilda, so as if you watched the dees play every week.

Oliver was always the better player, and his accolades show this, and he'll be elite for GWS.

He was not always the better player and Petracca was head and shoulders better than Oliver this year, it's not even a debate.

 

[danster168]

He was not always the better player and Petracca was head and shoulders better than Oliver this year, it's not even a debate.

Petracca was trash this year.

Oliver: More disposals, at better efficiency, more tackles, clearances at significantly less time on ground due to lack of fitness.
Petracca: more goals and inside 50 and metres gained.

 

[Dez!]

Petracca was trash this year.

Oliver: More disposals, at better efficiency, more tackles, clearances at significantly less time on ground due to lack of fitness.
Petracca: more goals and inside 50 and metres gained.

He wasn't trash this year at all, he wasn't at his best but he was still far better than Oliver who had zero impact on games.

 

[bird_man]

Petracca was trash this year.

Oliver: More disposals, at better efficiency, more tackles, clearances at significantly less time on ground due to lack of fitness.
Petracca: more goals and inside 50 and metres gained.

On disposals average they were 0.2 disposals per game apart from each other.

Petracca averaging 4 times the goals, two times the goals assists and almost two score involvements more pre game.

Please stop embarrassing yourself.

 

[danster168]

On disposals average they were 0.2 disposals per game apart from each other.

Petracca averaging 4 times the goals, two times the goals assists and almost two score involvements more pre game.

Please stop embarrassing yourself.

how much fwd time for Petracca get compared to Oliver. embarrassing not to mention this...

 

[Tasmanian saint]

Released a club champ so he can play senior football should be applauded.

Great work both clubs.

Surprised Essendon were not keen

 

[bird_man]

how much fwd time for Petracca get compared to Oliver. embarrassing not to mention this...

Embarrassing not to mention how much more midfield time Oliver got with his 0.2 extra disposals a game

 

[Dez!]

how much fwd time for Petracca get compared to Oliver. embarrassing not to mention this...

You mentioned clearances for Oliver...

 

[danster168]

Embarrassing not to mention how much more midfield time Oliver got with his 0.2 extra disposals a game

probably similar because Petracca had significant more time on ground. Next.

 

[Jeremy McLovin]

Well if you prefer I could use the coaches votes where Petracca had 46 and Oliver has 10?

Or would I better using the Brownlow votes where Petracca got 16 and Oliver didn't get a single vote?

Hahaha, imagine embarrassing yourself by using such shitty comparisons. Check their votes in the danster168 medal if you want a useful gauge of value.

 

[WilloTree]

I'm convinced SOS doesn't understand how the TPP works.