Think majority of cats fans think he’s historically been a good player. But 0.01% of cats fans would be happy to trade anything more than a R2 pick. R1 picks will never be in the discussion. If that’s what saints demand for a player wanting out who has been out all year and unfit then if cats have. Y brains they walk away. Not 1 cats fan would do that trade.In 2018 his last full season was equal 6th in the Brownlow and so yes must a be a dud.
Amusing that so many Cat's fans don't rate him, but yet strangely still want him. Go figure eh.
Trading first round picks for banged up 30 year olds with mental issues is diabolical. Richmond/Freo of the 90s type trading.
How much would you pay for Selwood? A far superior player with no mental issues? What did you pay for Hannebery? That’s his value. We have cap and if Kelly leaves we will have a lot of cap.
Geelong in window doesn’t mean we have to go full ****** and over pay. It could turn into Mitch Clark 2.0. How did H McIntosh work out for us.
It looks like Steven wanted us last year, it doesnt appear we are desperate, I doubt we are selling the farm. He’s an UFA next year.
If you’re expecting a R1 prepare to be surprised.
To think otherwise is akin to a dirty salesman trying to sell you a 2000 Monaro on last legs, telling you it’s basically new.