
Books
Norm Smith Medallist
The team that finished above Hawthorn on the ladder?
The team that had to donate pick 7 to sort out their salary cap.
Presented by The Golden Ticket - For Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the MCG and Marvel.
The team that finished above Hawthorn on the ladder?
At least they got deals done.The team that had to donate pick 7 to sort out their salary cap.
The team that had to donate pick 7 to sort out their salary cap.
We will take pick 6 and take O"Meara's full wage and we will throw in Meek as a sweetenerThe team that had to donate pick 7 to sort out their salary cap.
At least they got deals done.
You're trying to judge them they same as other clubs."HI EVERYONE WE HAVE PICK 7 AND ALL YOU NEED TO DO IS PAY SLIGHTLY ABOVE AVG WAGES FOR AN AVG PLAYER"
Yeah, no idea how they managed to get that deal sorted.
Like offering pick 2 for Lachie Weller. I mean, if they offered us pick 2 for Daniel Howe a few years ago we probably would have accepted it. Probably.
Not all clubs are GCS and GWS. So list managers actually need to do some work.
You're trying to judge them they same as other clubs.
Weller was an important get for them. And they've been over supplied with high draft picks. They can't keep them all.
What irrational expectations?Weller was an avg player and continues to be an avg player.
That you think it was an important trade speaks to your irrational expectations.
GCS and GWS live in a fantasy world.
What irrational expectations?
Right. Those are my expectations are they?Pick 24 for Meek
Us giving you OMeara, paying his salary, and getting a pick in the 40s
Been a few doozies in here.
Jaeger for a future second & Meek.
Thought more of a Mundy replacement.Bizarre that JOM is being seen as Acres replacement. We have plenty of wingers in the wings - which is why we lowballed Acres.
JOM is a replacement for Tucker (traded) and Blakely (delisted) - and an upgrade on both.
Think it’s the doggies 2nd from the Lobb tradeIf that is North's F2 then we made out like bandits.
I'd be pretty surprised if it was that and pretty angry. Future 2nd (Brisbane) and Meek makes more senseIf that is North's F2 then we made out like bandits.
Do Freo fans feel like they've gone forwards or backwards this trade period?
CuriosityA step forward... Why do you ask ?
Do Freo fans feel like they've gone forwards or backwards this trade period?
Curiosity
It really depends on if Taberner stays fit. We also have Amiss, Treacey and Corbett. If any one of those three has a decent season next season we would have improved dramatically.Do Freo fans feel like they've gone forwards or backwards this trade period?
A little bit backwards for 2023; a huge step forwards for 2024 and onwards.Do Freo fans feel like they've gone forwards or backwards this trade period?
This is a thread about a player traded to Freo.How do you feel Carlton went ? Forward or backwards ?
Backwards over the next 12 months but they have an amazing list for the future, particularly if Amiss comes on as expected.
It really depends on if Taberner stays fit. We also have Amiss, Treacey and Corbett. If any one of those three has a decent season next season we would have improved dramatically.
Seems to be the consensus, thank you for engaging in a proper conversation.A little bit backwards for 2023; a huge step forwards for 2024 and onwards.